Real Stone vs. Fake Stone
Sturgis Material IncAugust 24, 2012
It's a question we get asked time and time again, should I use real stone or man-made stone on the outside veneer of my house. Man-made (fake, faux, cultured, etc.) stone is a cementitious product made to simulate natural stone. The "stones" are made thin and applied to the exterior wall with a thin coating of mortar. While it seems simple, there's actually much more to it and this where your first problems arise. Cement likes to absorb water much more than natural stone. If not applied with the correct materials beneath it to keep this water out, you will have major issues down the road.
In addition, if you live in an area that has a frequent freeze/thaw pattern this too will eventually cause issues with man-made stone. We've all seen concrete driveways and sidewalks with cracks on the surface, this is caused crazing, and is common in man-made stone as well. Over time, these surface cracks will not only mar the appearance of the stone, but will also allow more water to infiltrate inside. Once this water freezes and thaws over and over again (here in Kansas CIty, we average about 90 cycles a year), the cracks will expand and contract, further weaking the stone until, that's right, off it pops from the wall.
The common perception of man-made stone was that it's more affordable than the real thing. Today, that price gap has narrowed considerably as some quarries are now producing a product called Natural Thin Veneer (NTV). This product is shaped like the man-made products, but completely genuine. It goes on like man-made stone, but doesn't attract water. And, because it's thin, the pricing is comparable. Our Crystal Ridge NTV (seen in the picture used on the latest Oklahoma Joe's) is just $10 /sq. ft. at Sturgis Materials. For more info visit our website at http://www.sturgismaterials.com/veneerspage.htm
Have you experienced these or other problems with man-made stone? If so, post your story here!
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
PRO
Sturgis Material Inc
Here's the pictures (not sure why they didn't post with the original). From top left clockwise we have Crystal Ridge NTV, Blue River NTV exterior, Blue River NTV interior, and Cavanal NTV.
    Bookmark   August 24, 2012 at 12:23PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
PRO
Custom Home Planning Center
I've done a few of both over the years and have found that the cost savings in labor for Man-made exceeds any needed warranty concerns.
    Bookmark   October 15, 2012 at 10:12PM
Thank you for reporting this comment. Undo
PRO
Sturgis Material Inc
But is that what's best in the long term for the homeowner who has to live with those "needed warranty concerns" for 20 years or more?

At Sturgis Materials, we carry a full line of thin veneers which are just as easy as faux stone to install. In addition, you don't have to deal with the amount of broken and therefore unusable pieces inherent in just about every box of faux stone that's out there on the market. This breakage (which makes faux stone unusable because it exposes the aggregate) is a hidden cost inherent in almost all projects where faux stone is used.

Easy installation, beautiful look, and long lasting without the warranty concerns of man-made stone, that's why today we only carry natural stone at Sturgis Materials.
    Bookmark   October 19, 2012 at 6:49AM
Sign Up to comment
Related Discussions
porcelain marble like wall tiles vs real marble
Which porcelain wall tiles look most like real marble?...
susanking1130
Precast vs real stone for exterior of Mediterranean house
Precast is much less expensive but not as attractive...
nedavossoughi
Is the stone on the side of the house faux or real?
I heard faux stone can lower the value of a home. ...
batmansmom
real stone vs. porcelain on condo floors and all bathrooms
We are redoing a condo unit in hilton head sc and contractor...
dldd
Which color stone for house?
I need help picking out exterior stone for our new...
reedzdream
More Discussions
Is this 9x12 carpet too big......
Would 8x10 be better for this space - and does it need...
mskdj
Paint color
I'm looking for a true medium grey color for a bedroom.it...
davekarenbeckyanddrew
Need thoughts on pairing stainless steel sink w chrome faucet?
our kitchen renovation- late 1700s- original wide pine...
Susan Laidlaw
house not yet "home"
please offer advice on how to make our tiny kitchen...
K. Ribeiro
HELP with the front of my house!!
I DESPERATELY need to do something with the front of...
kathleenkennedy41
People viewed this after searching for:
© 2015 Houzz Inc. Houzz® The new way to design your home™