I would find a patterned chair with a cream background. A small wing chair would look good. I have a question, what is the long console in the back? Are they a single piece or kitchen cabinets, or what? It's just the thing we need in our living room. Thanks!

Thank you! Those are part of kitchen cabinets with granite top. Great storage!

Hi although I'm just probably more "used to" seeing 2 side chairs that match each other, I've also seen living room groupings that I love where the side chairs don't match either (like in pic #2 below). I think (just like with anything else you're thinking of adding or modifying in a room) as long as the new side chair complements the decor and other furniture pieces (in style, color, scale, etc.) it will be fine and can actually add more interest to the space. Good luck and post more pictures after you make the change! :-)