Style Secret: Methodical Mismatching

Eclecticism wears its lack of pedigree proudly and draws its energy from contrast. The trick is to find enough common ground to make a space gel. The dining area shown here weaves together a narrow palette and subtle shine, from the table to the frames to the chandelier. No two chairs match, but all of them have strong silhouettes and roughly the same proportions.

Road-test it: The best way to master the medley: Dive in. Choose a few must-haves to anchor the space, then experiment with rugs, artwork, lighting, accents and other elements. Play light against dark, honed against glossy, rustic against elegant — but look for opportunities to create parallels. And be firm about editing; you can't stuff every piece you love into a single room.

When you find the right balance, you'll feel it instinctively. But if you have doubts, try this trick: Snap a photo of your space, wait awhile, then study it. What shouts at you? Winnow out any discordant elements and try again.
eclectic living room by Kailey J. Flynn Photography
Style Secret: Repetition

Visual echoes, from color to shape to finish, help an eclectic room find its rhythm. Look closely: This living area is essentially a series of rectangles, from the windows and the framed artwork to the coffee tables and vintage café sign. And the accent pieces reiterate the brilliant yellow of the room's focal-point chest.

Road-test it: Choose a few fundamental pieces to anchor your space, and survey the architecture as well. Then consider which elements you can repeat. Do you have a big, round ottoman paired with Eileen Gray side tables? Pull the circle motif into the room: a round mirror, a vintage schoolhouse wall clock, a collection of straw orbs. Throw in a few contrasting shapes for balance and you'll spark an engaging mix.
eclectic living room by Nichole Loiacono Design
Style Secret: Scale, Proportion, Composition

These tenets are essential to any well-designed space, but they're especially important in a room with so many disparate parts. Paying special attention to fundamental principles helps ensure that each element feels of a piece. In less skillful hands, this living area could have looked like a garage sale gone mad, but peek closer and you'll see how well balanced it is. Dramatic draperies hold their own against the sultry sofa, and the coffee and breakfast tables add just enough presence without fighting for the spotlight. Despite the tumble of artwork and accessories, there's nothing accidental about this space.

Road-test it: Before you bring a piece into an eclectic room, consider its relationship to the setting. Does it overwhelm everything else, get lost in a sea of openness or crowd the space? If so, maybe there's a better spot in the house for it.
eclectic home office by Lisa Borgnes Giramonti
Style Secret: Layered Textures

Texture gives an eclectic space its depth. Nearly every surface in this living room brings something different to the party: the nubbly Oriental rug over coarse sisal; the rich wood of the floors and trim; the thick, lush upholstery fabrics and sleek desk. A rich collection of textural elements makes a space appeal to our senses and resonate on a visceral level.

Road-test it: This one's easy — play by the rule of opposites. If you have shiny pieces, add matte ones. Offset metal with wood and plastic with porcelain. Marry smooth silk with coarse burlap. Use your hands as much as your eyes to gauge the level of textural interplay you've achieved.
eclectic bedroom by Erika Bierman Photography
Style Secret: A Clean Background

Working the eclectic look is like seating guests at a dinner party: Put the chatterboxes next to the shy types and everyone's happy. This style begs for a blend of strong, singular pieces, so keep the backdrop — walls, floors, windows — simple in order to avoid competition.

Road-test it: Err on the side of neutral and build the background from there. You'll rarely go wrong with pure white walls in an eclectic space, but if they look too bland for you, use an unassuming hue such as chamois, smoky gray or pale blue. Still not enough? Choose a color that's already in the room and try it out on an accent wall or on the ceiling. Or you could just hang more artwork, mount colorful window treatments and throw down a vibrant rug — all quick fixes that are easy to reverse as the room evolves.
eclectic bedroom Decorate by Holly Becker and Joanna Copestick
Style Secret: Cohesive Color and Pattern

In an eclectic room, you almost have carte blanche with the color wheel — almost. Pair bright citrus hues with shy pastels, mix and match every shade of green, restrict the palette to basic black and white. Likewise, you can combine sassy stripes with a mod floral and overscale chevrons. Conventional wisdom wags its finger at you? Bah, we say.

Road-test it: However, and this is a big however, the scheme needs to make sense. If you try to bring in every single shade you love, or if you pile up patterns with no restraint, you'll be left with a mess. For example, the bedroom here has a lot happening, from the bold print coverlet to the zigzag rug. Now imagine adding a patterned wallpaper or brilliant paint. Feel the headache coming on? Instead, a handful of strong colors and motifs enliven it without overwhelming it.
eclectic living room by ABCD Design LLC
Style Secret: Unexpected Accents

In what other decorating style could you make a weathered sideboard, an Oriental rug and a wall of vintage ads get along? The fun of eclectic style lies in the element of surprise. This is the time to get personal: Showcase mementos from your trip to India last year; bring out the faded concert posters of your favorite band; stack books inside your Radio Flyer wagon from childhood.

Road-test it: You can go overboard with quirkiness in a hurry. If you have a vintage bicycle next to an old dentist's chair next to a surfboard next to a ... well, you get the picture. Use really outlandish pieces as you would exclamation points: judiciously. Tempering them with a few simple, classic furnishings can elevate the look without diluting its eccentric charm.
eclectic bedroom by Niche Interiors
Style Secret: The Odd One Out

Eclectic decorating invites cross-pollination between wildly different design periods. So what do you do if you have a piece that you're wild about, but it doesn't seem to gel with its counterparts? Give it pride of place. Don't try to blend it into the background. Think of it as the room's black sheep: You love it for who it is rather than trying to make it something it isn't.

Road-test it: This approach is best used sparingly. In this bedroom, the chartreuse tulip chair works because the rest of the space allows it to take center stage. A whole room full of strong statement pieces like this one would be overkill. In a pinch, you could always rotate: your prized Arne Jacobsen Egg Chair one season; the next, an antique bergère updated with a zebra print.

What's your take on eclectic style? Tell us about it in the comments.

More:

More style guides
Eclectic Style: Brave Color Mixes
Vintage Modern: What Does It Mean?

Comments

Samantha Schoech Love these rooms--all of them.
15 months ago · ·
sheilablake There is an occasional electic room that I like, but, for the most part, I find most of it jarring.
15 months ago · ·
koolbeanzzzz Love this idea book and, for the most, this is my favorite design style. I have coined it "Organized Chaos" [in a good way].

Thank you for all of this great information on this design style.

~koolbeanszzzz
15 months ago · ·
Lisa Laskey really nicely written piece Lisa; I think you captured this style's essence. Thanks!
15 months ago · ·
Ajithaa Very well explained! The 'eclectic' look gives a 'lived in' look to a house.
15 months ago · ·
twinmommy Nice post. Eclectic style is daring and fun, but can easily go horribly wrong! Your post is a nice guide.
15 months ago ·
comfy by design For those who find this style a bit or very jarring try adding one piece to a room you don't spend the bulk of your time in. It might be a brightly painted chandelier or a table that shines with sunshine yellow. Trying something new can be fun and who knows you may grow to like it. You don't have to spend alot of money to make a simple change a can of paint and a yard sale or vintage shop find is all it takes. So. the next time you see that piece you would love to have but aren't sure what to do with it-make it an artful piece and see just how much fun it can be.
15 months ago · ·
DeCesare Design Great topic, and you covered it nicely!
15 months ago · ·
Coach House Antiques These rooms are fun...they draw you in. It's always the touch of whimsey that makes this style such a pleasing place to be.
15 months ago · ·
Pangaea Interior Design, Portland, OR Excellent points on how to pull off the eclectic room. I like the feel these rooms have of being "collected". Cannot abide matching sofa-loveseat-chair with matching coffee-side-console-tables. Even if you don't want to go full-on eclectic, using these design principles will at least help you to pull together a look that didn't come as a set at the local discount furniture store. And that's a very good thing!
15 months ago · ·
lmorrisdsgns Thank you, Lisa! I love the interest that eclectic style brings to a room. It's a very difficult design approach to do well and you have given us lots of great suggestions.
15 months ago · ·
lizzazz918 Dog doo all over the house also gives it a lived in look and in my opinion it still comes up looking like sh**. I would have a migrane in something like any of this.
15 months ago · ·
jennifer8237 What a fantastic collection of design info and ideas! I wish I could add this whole article to my ideabook. :)
15 months ago · ·
atfoxsmith Nicely written... All of these rooms are interesting to look at and feel personal -- and not as if they're trying to copy a room/design straight out of a magazine.
15 months ago · ·
storklady I'm all about eclectic. I always have been. As the person above said - the matchy matchy furiniture showroom look is pretty awful and shows zero personality. I love the 4th and 7th photos best of all. I'm not into eclectic and busy. Personally, the 3rd photo is a nightmare for me because the room is way too busy and cluttered. Great post. Thanks.
15 months ago · ·
Kelley Lowry I am so eclectic and I love how point on the above info is...it describedme yo a "T". But I also got more guidelines and pics to educate myself on being eclectic.
15 months ago · ·
bajablue Charming and whimsical. I love, Love, LOVE them all.
15 months ago · ·
rsmigel koolbeanzzzz...that's exactly what I call my house. Organized Chaos. But it truly become who I am as a person and every piece of my antiques, collectables, modern elements; has a story to tell and means something to me. My home is truly MY home.
15 months ago · ·
Maureen Stevens Wonderful insight on what "eclectic" is. For most people, they think it's about mixing-not matching which is a very bold move {in my eyes, much better than a matchy matchy, almost cookie-cutter room| but in design, like you wrote, they still have to "gel" correctly.
15 months ago · ·
kathyjmw I really liked this idea book. I hate a 'match-matchy' room, and love to have my accessories mean something to me. Some of the rooms displayed here are way too busy for my taste, but there is something about each of them that I can learn from. My favorite is the gorgeous bedroom in the 6th photo.
15 months ago · ·
Vintage Renewal LOVE!
15 months ago ·
PaintColorHelp.com Dallas Well-written and useful advice on this topic. Personally I enjoy a mix of style elements - otherwise a room feels too sterile or stuffy. If the examples shown here are too much for an individual, perhaps they should keep in mind, eclectic can be a matter of degree. One needn't set out to be deliberately eclectic. Instead, go ahead and build the basic room - be it very modern or very traditional - then add in a dash or two of the unexpected. An old, weathered chest among chrome and leather; a colorful modern canvas above a carved plaster mantle and Louis chairs. I give my clients this advice frequently, because it adds balance. Nothing but antiques can feel too heavy, and nothing but hard, glossy lines can feel too "Star Trek." IMO.
15 months ago · ·
graysonj Thanks for this idea book; it was informative and fun. I learned a lot!
15 months ago ·
Jan Yatsko My electic style is cohesive through color and theme. I like bright colors and my theme is funky animals (made from craftspeople), who also carry the color theme and bring a bit of humor. It is a sophisticated but comfortable style that everyone feels comfortable in.
15 months ago · ·
ellie48 Electic! I like electic. It allows me to mix. I can show my own style. And I know it can be done well. Thanks for the guide-lines. Brilliant.
15 months ago · ·
Lisa Frederick Thank you all for the kind comments! Comfy by design, I think that's a terrific point about how to ease into eclectic style. Sometimes it's all about taking that first small risk.
15 months ago · ·
nenamarci Thank you Lisa. Eclectic style is perhaps the most difficult to execute. There has to be enough restraint to avoid the random clutter look.
15 months ago · ·
Lauren Elyse GREAT article & spaces!!
15 months ago ·
blossom61 My problem with what members of the media call "eclectic" style is that it's not eclectic, it's just junky. To me, eclectic means mixing old and new SUCCESSFULLY. I've seen this done in the old houses of my town but never in the media (not even here). What I see here (what I always see referred to as "eclectic") is a confusing mix with no weight or substance. Instead of lots of small stuff, use fewer pieces (one large painting and one large sculpture, each of which make a statement on their own that when juxtaposed against one another create a real dialogue - instead of a bunch of small "art" arranged half hazardly, desperately competing for attention but ultimately disappearing), judiciously chosen, that fit together, regardless of what they're made of or from what point in time they come. Like a gorgeous old stone in a straightforward modern setting worn on an otherwise bare hand INSTEAD of a handful of small jewelry from opposing periods, no piece of which deserves even a moment's worth of attention. It's about paring DOWN to what's necessary, rather than building UP with "filler." What bothers me here is everything FEELS scattered and cluttered and nothing about the look compels me to enter. Eclectic doesn't mean junky.
15 months ago · ·
CAROLE MEYER You did a great job writing this piece and I love the look....it is always so much more interesting to have a collected look. I does take time because you do need to get out and collect it....but that is over half the fun.
15 months ago · ·
henryfamilyinla some of this is great other not so much but I do like many of the suggestions given for maintaining balance. Editing being the most valuable word for me.
15 months ago · ·
fairytailess Eclectic has always been my kind of style - mix and match is something I've done since I was a child. Love everything here and many thanks for the styling tips!
15 months ago · ·
violinconlimon I'm with storklady. The 4th and 7th photos are fantastic.
15 months ago · ·
midmodfan While the photos do have a certain appeal, it's very difficult to do this right. That's why imo many homes are not eclectic, but a hodgepodge.
15 months ago · ·
Ann Allen Love this post. I tried doing "color schemes" but ever since I painted my walls white and can add any color I want without worrying about matching, I feel like I can play around without being locked into a scheme. I love the clean bright white walls. Everything looks good against them.
15 months ago · ·
leeandcarol For the most part I'm eclectic but lean more to clean and uncluttered look. I do like to mix and match textures but use only 3 colors to bind them with. These photos are very inspiring
15 months ago · ·
Lisa Frederick Great input from everyone. I share the feeling that clean white walls make everything look good. Now I'm trying to convince my husband of that. :-)
15 months ago · ·
Phancy Design Very well explained but the look is much too hectic for me personally. It would stress me out to live like that!
15 months ago · ·
mildredrowe Love them all anything goes as long as the colours blend well together
15 months ago · ·
annathomas Great website, love your designs indoors as well ad outdoors. Good job!
15 months ago ·
4ferrukis Well, I feel that my style is what you called here Eclectic, I like old stuff mixed with new or recycled items that I refuse to get rid off. My hubby can't agreed with me ever and often people makes fun of my decor. Do you think perhaps I over mix stuff that really doesn't look good/ but i like it!
15 months ago ·
Stephanie Nickolson Design Always eClEcTiC!
15 months ago ·
GHStyleworks Eclectic style, when pulled off — is the most interesting of styles, in my opinion! Love it!
15 months ago · ·
mjbevilacqua quite a few people missing the point of this style...its about YOU personally-so if the above images are jarring, this probably isnt your style!! and very expensive designer pieces dont always go with..well other expensive designer pieces! to me that would look convoluted and üp myself"! eclectic for ME means the above, pieces collected thruout my life that with gentle thought and due care look happy together and allow a few interesting pieces to really shine thru. so wonderful article and i think accurate and informative. i dont believe we should start hating on a style if we dont like it-it means we are all unique and thank goodness for that! ;)
15 months ago · ·
Becky Harris Like Pangaea intimated, I think the new word for the successfully eclectic rooms you have shown is "collected." Somehow "eclectic" has come to describe not only the fun, well-done bohemian, mix and match style but also the hodge-podge hot messes ( in some unfortunate circumstances) (she types, from her, ahem, eclectic living room) :)
15 months ago · ·
Lisa Frederick Good point, Becky. Eclectic is a loaded word these days, kind of like country (the whole duck-on-a-stick misconception). ITA that people hear "eclectic" and think "junk room." It's an interesting line, because I think you could call any really well-layered interior collected to some degree.
15 months ago · ·
myhouse385 Certain styles... industrial age, shabby chic... started out as eclectic... but became styles in their own right as they were adopted. So I think eclectic is any style that works but that isn't in common use by others.... those of us who love beautiful things usually wind up being eclectic because we can't discipline ourselves to one period or style as collectors... we love it all and have to find a place to put it... the hard thing for me has been moving to a very small home and not wanting to sacrifice my accumulations... I am in hell.
15 months ago · ·
Madison Modern Home Brava, Lisa! This is just about the best distillation of eclectic style that I've read anywhere. And we're talking about a style that, by its very nature, resists being distilled. Thanks for the insight. I'm going to back to re-read it; there's a lot of information there.
13 months ago · ·
irieiris I love the eclectic style. It's always had a homey feeling for me, yet at the same time, it's classy.
12 months ago · ·
Michael I love these rooms. They all have depth and interest. There is a feeling of history to them and make me want to know the people that possess them. So much of interior design is like a mask, expressing how a person seems to want to be seen instead of who they really are. That red and cream duvet is fabulous.
12 months ago ·
Randi Crawford What an eclectic group of people have commented on this great article! I like to call my style eclectic, but it's really just what I have collected and love at the moment, combined with what works for me on a practical level, while not always coordinating in any meaningful way. I usually have several "projects" in various stages, some of which never come to fruition!

English Country House style I think is one of the first influences on American eclectic style, with the layers of objects, fabrics and furniture pieces accumulated over the centuries and by successive inhabitants.
Jonathan Adler is one designer whose playful, colorful, eclectic style that has had a huge influence on current design trends.

It is interesting to me that someone commented how much they hate Photo #3 -It is my favorite room! I don't love all the rooms shown, but that is the point of eclectic - it's your own personal style!

Yaletownman made an excellent point - so many times I look at beautifully coordinated rooms in magazines or tv or web in a certain color scheme and style, and I think they look so staged and bland, not appealing to me at all!
Many homeowners primarily want to display their wealth and status. Since I have neither, maybe my dislike is sour grapes, but I think a home misses a certain warmth without pieces that really reflect the personality of its inhabitants.
Contemporary is especially tricky in that regard, as it often comes off as cold and unwelcoming. PaintColorHelp.com made a great comment on that as well.

Very well written article, and great design tips, Lisa!
10 months ago · ·
Rana Bilal Manzoor Totally agree with your suggestion... Very nice post and good information here... Thanks for posting that....

http://star-drama.com/StarTVDrama/star-plus
8 months ago ·
mamyte I DO have a style, after all! You voiced all my justifications so well!
5 months ago ·
joan settina people walk into my house and say "it's you" and my decor choices are personal, have stories and are treasures that I must surround myself with touch everyday....nothing is structured to impress or display. The rooms are my life as it is, changing here and there but subtle and casual.
5 months ago ·
Paul D'Amico - Period Design I find all the interiors you show devastatingly effective and seductive These eclectics are subversive and yet familiar objects within the composition reassure us.
4 months ago ·
Transformations This is the most difficult style to get right - even though it seems to the uninitiated that it should be easy. This quote is so accurate: 'If you toss a little of this, a little of that and a dash of the other into a room at random, it'll look like exactly what it is: a mess.' Great tips for everyone who wants to try for eclectic and it's crazy beauty!
4 months ago ·
Maria Lucido i like..
3 months ago ·
bfergie Great guidelines...things I have been trying to incorporate but not knowing exactly why some things clicked and others fell flat. Now I have a better base to build on because I love this style but had a difficult time getting the principles behind it...and there actually are some!!!
8 weeks ago ·
Sign Up to comment