5 Former Design Trends That Should Rise Again

I'm a design and food-obsessed freelance writer and market research analyst, and a stay-at-home mom.
I'm a design and food-obsessed freelance writer and market research analyst,... More »
It's no secret that decorators borrow from the past when they're philosophizing about the next big thing in home design. The mid-century Palm Springs look has been especially popular of late, but that's certainly not the only historical period from which designers take inspiration.

It's interesting, though, to look at what has caught back on and what's still out there, waiting for rediscovery. Sometimes it seems like sheer luck that one design element gets elevated over another, though some discarded trends remain hidden because we've changed the way we live. (How many developers build servants' quarters into houses these days? How many should?)

With that in mind, I did some digging into design and architecture history and found five semi-forgotten trends that deserve another look:
Zebra wall
1. Drawing rooms. Drawing rooms, a shortened version of "withdrawing" rooms, have been around for a long time. Originally they were located outside royal bedrooms—a spot for the court to spend time—though by the 19th century, they were in the main part of the house, off the parlor, and provided space for the men's post-dinner cigars and brandy (the little ladies stayed in the parlor).

Lifestyle changes (lack of servants, again) and the sexual revolution made drawing rooms obsolete, but I think the concept, at its core, is a good one. After dinner, it's nice to have a comfortable (and pretty) room to sit in with friends. I love post-dinner chats and think it's nice if they're in a place that doesn't involve dirty dishes or a stained tablecloth.
eclectic living room by Bockman + Forbes Design
These rooms deserve a certain level of formality, as a nod to the old days, but should also have really, truly comfortable furniture. Both this space and the room above do a good job mixing comfort with a tiny touch of haughtiness.
modern kitchen by Tara Seawright
2. Separate Kitchens and Dining Rooms. I feel like a bit of a hypocrite here, since I've written tons of ideabooks celebrating the open kitchen. I even remodeled my house to open the kitchen to the dining room! But after a few years of dinner parties that started with a view of the splattered stove and ended with the dirty kitchen sink, I changed my mind and swapped my dining room and living room furniture, so I'd have a separate dining room and a lounge in the kitchen.

I think there's certainly room for hanging-out space in the kitchen. It is the center of the modern home and looks to stay that way. I like kitchen tables and lots of seating.

But kitchen socializing will always be casual and occasionally, it's nice to dress it up. That's where a separate dining room comes in.
eclectic dining room by LDa Architecture & Interiors
That's not to say that the dining room has to be so formal that it will only be opened up for state dinners. In fact, my ideal dining space would be separate from the kitchen and living/family room, but close and approachable enough to use every day. It would be functional enough to use all the time, but pretty enough to dress up for more formal occasions.
pictures
3. The Library. Ah, the library. Yes, I know this space is a luxury and that it's not exactly in keeping with the "not so big house" philosophy. I know it's kind of wasteful. I know that kindles and iPads may one day render huge book collections obsolete. But I don't care. I love to read (and, judging by all the book-related ideabooks, so do most of you) and I think the idea of a room dedicated entirely to books sounds incredibly romantic.
modern living room by Edward I. Mills & Associates, Architects PC
I'll admit that it doesn't make much sense for a modern home to have both a drawing room AND a library. We're not 18th century nobility, after all. So what about this: drawing room/library. Doesn't sound so bad, does it?
modern  by Feldman Architecture, Inc.
The library concept doesn't actually have to have its own four walls, either—just a dedicated space. Related: how fabulous is this ladder?
modern dining room by Amy Lau Design
4. The In-Office Bar. On Mad Men, the in-office liquor cabinet is so prominent that it's almost like another character. These days, we treat the cast's in-office boozing as a sort of sad punch line—romantic, tragic, funny and a way to remind ourselves how far we've come. That's why I know this might be controversial, but I think we need to bring it back.
eclectic porch by Thom Filicia Inc.
Not exactly in Don Draper form, though—I think we should look at office bars for the 21st century...which means home office bars. Think about it: home offices are on the rise and actually, they make the perfect spot for a slightly oversized wet bar. What do you really need in a home office? A desk for a laptop plus some files. If you're using a whole guest room for just those things, you've probably got some extra space (which is probably filled with boxes of Christmas decorations or something). Or maybe your "office" is a corner of the family room. Either way, instead of turning the home office into a glorified dumping ground, why not disco it up with a killer bar? That way, when you have parties, you can cover the computer, add a few lights and some music, and give the home office a second use that's a whole lot more fun.
Interior Courtyard
5. Courtyards. I'm cheating a bit here - courtyards aren't exactly a trend that's been lost to history, but they do deserve more play—they don't need to be relegated to Eastern cultures, old palaces, and the American Southwest.
tropical bathroom by MCM Design
Building houses around courtyards has a ton of practical purposes—not only do they create a very usable outdoor room, but they also add an ideal spot for small gardens (especially herb gardens)—a perfect fit for the urban farming trend.

Comments

Rough Linen I once had an old house with nineteen rooms, a room for every function! Talk about confusing, and I moved from a loft...

What I would give for a courtyard though.
2 years ago · ·
Sesshu Design Associates, Ltd I love the idea of the combined drawing room/library. Actually, I love the idea of a library anywhere in the house- could be a library/dining room too - I've always thought that books make a great focal wall.
2 years ago · ·
midmodfan I also love the idea of the drawing room/ library. I'm a fan of multy-purpose rooms.
But the best thing is the courtyard. Our next house has one and we chose it just because of the atrium garden (for the cat to roam). Small lot in a big town, yet with a completely private outdoor area.
2 years ago · ·
pickles69 The nostalgia of the writer is sweet but in a moment of economic malaise, the reality of virtually any of these ideas might only be manifested via a path of buying a forclosed McMansion in financially devistated region. Romantic maybe, yet gauche and excessive too. Listen to NPR or even AM radio (or read the WSJ) -Americans are wanting LESS house not more excess. Sorry to burst the bubble but the last thing we need are more rooms in houses of which the homeowners say, "I can't remember the last time I used that room". I adore beauty and great design. Let's promote it on a usable, functional scale. We're supposed to have vision here.
2 years ago ·
alliebean I completely agree with the separate kitchen and dining room ideas. While I sometimes am jealous when I visit houses with expansive open floor plans, I love my separate dining room. In fact, we decided to use the rooms on our first floor differently from their original intention. The 'formal' dining room off the kitchen was just way too small for the kind of entertaining we like to do (not super formal entertaining, we just like to have lots of people!), so we decided to use the 'formal living room' as our dining room. Similar to you, it is casual enough to use every day, but I love to dress it up for special occasions. The original dining room is now a kind of keeping room that we have a desk and bookshelves on one wall and two small chairs to sit and have a cup of coffee and read the paper. We do hope to open the one wall of the kitchen into the keeping room in the future. But I love the way it works for us!
2 years ago · ·
MFAMB aka Jenny that last image with the bath outside is almost too much for me to take..
2 years ago ·
Karen Evans I was thinking of swapping my dining room table and less formal kitchen table, but after hearing your mention of dining in a kitchen with a mess ensuing, I think I may have changed my mind!
2 years ago · ·
patscats2 No one should dictate how others should live. Some people will always love their big mansions and more power to them. If they can afford them, no one is to say they shouldn't have them.

That said, some of these made me smile as I thought to myself, I could never live with that style. LOL Did anyone else find that second photo with the blue victorian sofa and 2 blue beach chairs in that green Victorian room, truly ugly? What is that about? I don't know anyone who wants to put that blue and style of chairs in a room with those walls and those drapes. Do designers truly think this looks good or are they just running out of ideas and wanting to see if something this odd would fly? Thanks for the post.
2 years ago ·
laura mcleod Love the photos and everyone's perspective. We just expanded our dining room and filled it with an old farm table and modified velvet wing chairs - so cushy and comfortable. While we were doing it, everyone told me that "dining rooms are so over, no one does that anymore" - but we have an 1920's home and it just makes sense for the space. Plus, we have two young boys and I like the little bit of formality at dinner, it reigns them in just enough to make dinnertime (almost) civilized.

I am now scouting my place for a bar - I don't have a home office, but should could use more cocktails.
2 years ago · ·
jen_s Just remodeled our cape (1200 square feet) to have a separate dining room. We also have a library/ drawing room that sereves as a guest room with a daybed that pulls out to a kingsize bed. It all functions perfectly & I love it.
2 years ago · ·
lotuspetal Why would you need a drawing room when you now have a living room? In my grandmother's house there actually was a parlor. We went there after funerals and on Christmas. Now our entertaining area is the living room.
As for the dining room, in my experience the guests like to hang out with the cook. And the cook also doesn't like to miss out on the chatter amongst the guests. I like the open kitchen. If I had a cook and a maid, then it would be different.
My library I call my "media room". It has the office and TV (where I only watch movies) along with a wall of books. Works well. Used to be a master bedroom, but I prefer to sleep in smaller rooms.
2 years ago ·
cmu204 I despise the trend of open kitchen/dining rooms -- who wants to look at dirty dishes? A proper dining room is a huge plus for me.

And I love the idea of the drawing room, though I agree w/lotuspetal that a formal living room can be that space. Let the kids have the family room.

I would give my eyeteeth for a courtyard. That is all.
2 years ago · ·
rdutton Thanks for these ideas. I really like the idea of a drawing room. I think I am going to get to work on that right now and combine the drawing room and library.
2 years ago · ·
jeg700 700 I agree with pickles69...I abhor excess in all forms...in houses, behaviour and decor. In the world we live in today, it is necessary for beauty and function to co-exist. Also, who wants to clean all that extra space:)
2 years ago ·
myosotis I have a breakfast nook and a separate dining room which is used three times a year. Yes, you guessed it, New Year's Eve, Thanksgiving, Christmas day, and only because the breakfast nook is too small for all of us.
2 years ago ·
genericusername Remember that you decide what each area is. It doesn't have to be an entire room or a huge area in order to be a library. One bookshelf, one reading lamp, one comfy chair, and that becomes your library. A few large plants, something like an outdoor bench, maybe a table top fountain, and you have a courtyard (inside). I'm in a studio and created little nooks and crannies that give ME the feelings I want for my own space.

If you'd rather have a library than a dining space, do it. An office bar instead of a guest room, do it. Forget the labels assigned to a room or a space, and use the area for what you want.
2 years ago ·
marissa camacho If you think being excessive nowadays is an abomination, then so be it. These photos are here for those who may want to dream for now.
2 years ago ·
q34th After living in and old house with a separate dining room and kitchen without table space and a door I am sold on the concept. Departing the kitchen with all the food prep confusion is the best way to enjoy a meal. Viewing the kitchen mess takes the joy out of the simplest meal.
2 years ago · ·
wandm Great ideas; I am trying to figure out a way to make that first picture work in my bedroom as I'd love to have an intimate place to sit with my husband to relax, talk, read. Our dining room is the least used room in our house, people seem to like the kitchen table best, and it seats 8 and has a great view. I used to worry about the mess, but as I've gotten older, I figure, life is short...serve good food and wine and eat where you want to.
2 years ago · ·
scribbler Great article, and some thought provoking ideas. After years of wanting an "open kitchen concept," I finally have one that is semi-open. I don't like it for all the reasons you cited -- who wants to see dirty dishes and the results of prep? Joni Webb expressed the same idea in Linda Merrill's new e-zine Surroundings this month, too. Today I am cooking my husband's catfish for his lunch out on the back porch because strong cooking odors permeate the LR and get into the furniture and curtains! Febreze is used frequently in my house. A few years ago when I was house-hunting, my son expressed the concept perfectly: "An auditorium with a firepit!"
2 years ago · ·
Simpatico Interior Design I didn't want a separate dining room when the two of us moved into a large house to also use for my home business. Although we didn't use it often at first, I started getting requests from previous dinner guests; "can we please eat in the dining room, I just love that cozy feeling of that room". It is open to the living room, which, like a parlor room becomes the retreat sometimes after the meal. I use to entertain in the kitchen nook with small dinner parties, but now use my dining room. My guests can sit and enjoy conversation while I can clear away the table and sit right back down with them. The world we live in may have presented us with new challenges (and many stresses) but my home is my private sanctuary that can be used in anyway I choose. BTW, Careful, scribbler, that Febreze is fatal to birds so I'd go easy, it can't be that great for any living thing. (remember the canary in the coal mine test?)
2 years ago · ·
lmacedo Love the separate dining room. I never really thought about it until we moved into a house with one, but I came to love it. I also love the courtyard...so romantic and it sort of moves the yard inside. Housing trends have gone for that big great room, but I really love having separate spaces. I think this is what the writer is trying to say; not necessarily that we need bigger spaces, but more well-defined spaces.
2 years ago · ·
abrxx Hi, I've studied historical design, domesticity and architecture for some years, especially from the Victorian period onwards. I've read mostly about the British side, but also have read a little about European historical design and also about 19th and 20th century American design.

I'd enjoyed reading this article and agree with its basis premise, but wanted to comment on the following:

Drawing rooms - certainly in British Victorian and Edwardian society, these rooms belonged to the lady of the house. Smoking was considered distasteful in Victorian times and would certainly not have been permitted in here. In Georgian times men would remain in the dining room after dinner, after the plate and cloth had been removed by the servants, and would enjoy a hasty port and cigar before joining the ladies in the Drawing Room. By Victorian times social customs had changed somewhat, and if a home had a LIBRARY it was not uncommon for the men to retire to the library to smoke/drink before joining the ladies in the drawing room. Larger homes may have had a SMOKING ROOM, in which case smoking would only happen here (or perhaps also the BILLIARDS ROOM, if the house had one). In any case, the DRAWING room would not have been used for smoking or for the men gathering.

I know less about Victorian American culture, but I understand that the Drawing Room was introduced by middle / upper class Americans who were seeking to move on from the stiff formality of the PARLOR, which was more about social custom than a particular type of room or decor. In other words, the Drawing Room was basically a parlor without the social customs that the parlor imposed.

Most British Victorian homes also had a MORNING ROOM, which basically the ladies of the house used as an informal lounge in the morning (the men would use the library for the same). Mornings were more informal in Victorian times, with guests calling in the afternoon, who would then be ushered into the Drawing room.

For more info see: Kerr, Robert "The gentleman's house" and "The Domesticated Americans" by Russel Lynes.

I am currently planning my own dream home, and on the ground floor will have the following spaces

- dining kitchen
- playroom/family area
- library (with hidden tv and bar)
- great hall (for formal dining/living)

Hopefully between these four rooms we will include many old design trends that deserve a place in the modern home. The generic layout of the so-called modern home I believe does not support the best way for a family with children to really live.
15 months ago · ·
Amy Renea I'm late to this party, but loved this article!!

I too agree with many of your points! My husband really wants to open the kitchen up to the rest of the house, but I keep gently reminding him that I LIKE my small kitchen and seperate dining room. I like that only 1-2 people can fit in the kitchen and cook...I can do my thing and not burn the pierogies because I am trying to socialize!

I think all the chatterers about "no excess" kind of missed the spirit of the post. It isn't necessarily about adding rooms, but adding function. You could take one room that isn't being utilized and make it function as a library, bar AND half open to a courtyard. It is a way of life that we are no longer engagaing in....slowly reading, drinking and savoring plants and sit down dinners. It is a lovely thought and I am in complete agreement that we should bring back these elements of past design!
12 months ago · ·
Moments of Art Amy, I was thinking the same thing. It isn't about adding rooms, but about slowing down and enjoying life. A separate dining room, doesn't mean you can't have space for people to hang out during food preparation. It's just means having the people who do hang out in the kitchen help take the things you prepared to the dining room so the cook can get away from the mess and enjoy the meal too.

A library could certainly be incorporated into a home office along with a bar area. It would simply mean adding some book shelves and a small refrigerator. Add a small sleeper sofa and you have a room for guests, a place to read, a drawing room of sorts, a place to hang out for a toddy and space for an office... Multi-function at its best.
12 months ago ·
Moments of Art Oh! and for the person who said the room in the second picture was ugly. I couldn't disagree more. I love that room! It's so calming and soothing. I could live in that room a lot easier than the room in the first picture. That room is just too busy for me. I'd never be able to relax.
12 months ago ·
Sign Up to comment