#1 for the middle Fireplace. I would like a tile that is not the traditional square. I like this one because of the colors. It looks like it has browns and grays. Question is, would it look ok if I did a stone on the other fireplace? I don't know how the two separate materials would look in the same room. I also want to keep the open shelf area. Except maybe make it just one shelf instead of the three that it has now.