When it came time to reinvent the fireplace, Matt and Larissa once again called on Beech Tree Building Company. The original mantel was just a small, unattractive shelf — completely out of proportion to the fireplace. Rather than tear it down, they opted to build over it. Matt explains, "I thought it would be nice to leave it intact, in case someone else in the future wants to restore it completely back to its original state."The new mantel is extra thick to accommodate the old one hidden within. Matt left time-capsule-like notes in various places before they were covered over — "Who we were, what years we did certain things to the house," Larissa says. "But he also wrote a few funny ones. Things like, 'Shame on you for tearing down all of my hard work, do you know how long that took me?' "Mantel: Beech Tree Building CompanyPhotograph: "Fan Light Over Green Point" by Christopher Petrich