The downstairs bathroom wall (which could have been Michele's 'something blue') is in Benjamin Moore's Newbury Port Blue. They're still looking for a new medicine cabinet but for now, it stays as is.The hexagonal tiles, added to give the bathroom new life, are from Home Depot. "Ryan's dad had the idea to lay them out with the black border around the perimeter to give it a high-end, custom feel," says Michele. The couple describes the bathroom's previous incarnation as "awful." They initially went with a contractor who was easier on their pockets than others they had canvassed. "Let us be a lesson to new homeowners: check references and don't always go with the cheapest bid," says Michele. They were able to hire a new contractor and are more than happy with the result.