Here's an island that gives way to a table and as it's making that transition, the room changes from the kitchen to a wider space for socializing. It's close enough to be of the kitchen without being in the kitchen.
I have no issue with an island for extra counter space -- it's strategic, but if there's a space for breakfast nook, what about a table rather than banquettes etc? could be interesting.
Here's an island that gives way to a table and as it's making that transition, the room changes from the kitchen to a wider space for socializing. It's close enough to be of the kitchen without being in the kitchen.