Software
Houzz Logo Print
sherry_roma

My roses like me better now that I'm feeding them

17 years ago

I humbly apologize to all of you for all my belly-aching about leafless rose bushes, frantic whining about bare canes and general handwringing about my 'ugly' garden. Even a new mama knows that when baby cries, chances are he wants a bottle. But not this mama! This one kept checking the diaper every 15 minutes, scratching her head and wondering what could be the problem with the little dumpling. Thankfully, a very wise rose friend said, "Glory, honey, feed the child!" So four weeks ago I gave them all Miracle Gro. (Well, her actual words were, "In Florida MG is like crack for roses.") And ya know, in a few days their crying was noticeably less, and it seemed like they were getting a little chubby. Two weeks ago they got another MG feeding, and a few days later, sure enough, they were getting downright pudgy. Today I was in the front garden setting out sun-loving 'Red Ruffle' azaleas (my evergreen touch for a Florida rose garden), and don't ya know, they're so gorgeous and rosy-cheeked and FAT! Tomorrow they get another MG feeding. I'm SO happy to know I'm not starving my babies anymore and absolutely joyous at the condition of my summer rose garden.

I am here to tell everyone in hot, humid gardens (especially ones with sandy soil that leaches nutrients like crazy due to heat and heavy rains) that roses (Teas, Chinas, Noisettes and even a few moderns) DO bear leaves and make new growth and flowers (!) in the height of summer. And since I'm past the point of feeling utterly stupid, I am almost giddy!!!!!!!! Yippee!!! My garden has turned a huge corner - as has the gardener! Can't wait for the fall flush!! I think I might just cry.

Sherry

P.S. Don't ask me why I have been hesitant to feed in summer. I don't have a GOOD reason. Mostly because I thought they needed to 'rest' in the heat, also it's too hot to be out there scratching under rose bushes with organics, and MG is (dare I say it?) synthetic. Well, in this Florida organic garden 'any port in a storm' is fine with me. And, of course, I know I'm not telling ANYone anything they didn't already know. It just made me feel a little better about myself to give some good advise about something that works.

Comments (34)

  • 17 years ago

    Sherry, you have a way with words that's priceless. I love reading your posts but this one was extra-good. Not to mention good advice. However, since it's 104 degrees today I think I'll wait with the fertilizing until I don't collapse under the rose bushes. (Of course, it is a DRY heat!)

    Ingrid

  • 17 years ago

    I agree that MG is good in between 'good' fertilizing applications. It certainly perks everything up. I haven't been doing it the past two years because we couldn't water, but I did this year.

  • 17 years ago

    Ingrid, today was amazingly balmy for August, but you'd think I'd have been much cooler since my tee shirt was soaked with sweat. And I certainly don't blame you for not venturing out in 104 degrees (only 40 centigrade!). I wish MG could be run through a soaker system. It took me over 3 hours last time. My arms wouldn't work right for several hours. Nothing is easy!

    Buford, water is definitely a good thing!!! I will go back to organic when the weather breaks (mid-October). Until then I'm happy to use MG.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    Sherry...I thoroughly enjoyed reading your post! Speaking of "feeding", I have a young 16 yr. old
    friend that is raising a few rabbits, and I'll bet that he has some bunny poop around there somewhere. Anyone have any experience using this with roses? I have a feeling that I could talk him out of some of it.
    Barb

  • 17 years ago

    that is a great post---I'm ashamed to say I've neglected my roses this year. I will try to do better next spring---Hopefully I will be in less pain.

    Florence

  • 17 years ago

    But Florence, I bet you have good soil in your garden, because your roses look wonderful in the photos you've posted. I don't think they minded a little neglect this year, and absolutely, we're hoping for less pain for you.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    Barb, I understand rabbit droppings are fabulous for roses. Get all you can! I imagine your friend will be more than happy to get rid of them. Let's hope his mom is not a savvy gardener!

    Ingrid

  • 17 years ago

    Interesting...so if I use organic RoseTone monthly, do you think the roses would use a little extra 'candy' in the form of MG in the hot summer months?

    I've not used it before...is it a granular feed?
    -terry

  • 17 years ago

    Sherry, your prayers have been answered ... Miracle Gro, or any soluble fertilizer, can be run through a soaker system if you use one of those hose end sprayers, or have access to a fertilizer injector. The sprayer MG used to make was perfect, because it had a hose-in and hose-out type of arrangement on the nozzle. The one they're selling now won't work ... you can't hook a hose to the output end because of their fancy-schmancy variable pattern sprayer-thingie.

    I use a regular hose-end sprayer, the kind with the canister you pack with fertilizer. I screw the in-going end to my garden hose, and the out-going end to the supply line for my drip system. The friend who showed me this does it with soaker hoses.

    Bunny poo? It's fabulous for your garden. You can use it straight from the bunny if you want to, and it won't burn your plants. There's a photo of a whole truckload of the stuff spread out on my hybrid tea beds in the message thread about the cul-de-sac back yard from a couple weeks back ... it's good to have friends who raise show rabbits. :)

    Connie

  • 17 years ago

    I dunno Sherry, I've given my roses MG along with the blue bottle rose pellets that stink along with mushroom compost and they still hate this summer and are stick-figures.

    I've come to the conclusion that Florida summer is equal to northern winter and some plants go into survival mode. It has been a nuke-you-lur summer here.
    The heat has just this week scaled back to 90 intead of 93 plus 80 p.c. humidity.

    I compare my OGR's to other roses in the garden on Fortuniana and even the fort's are unlovely. Having said that I will now go give them another taste of MG as well as another spray for thrips later in the day. This summer has been one for the record books (following a record-breaking cold winter).

    I have the old style MG hose sprayer, yay.

    Denise

  • 17 years ago

    Terry, Miracle Gro is a blue powder that dissolves, making a liquid feed.

    Connie, that's good to know about the old sprayer. Too bad I threw mine out when I cleaned out the shed. Figures. I also thought MG's settling issue would be a problem. I have to constantly shake the sprayer or my blue water goes clear. I think I'll try holding the sprayer upside down today.

    Denise, I think I remember you said you haven't had much rain, right? That could be a major factor in your garden. In the last few weeks we have had rain at least 3 or 4 times a week, so that has to make a difference. I can absolutely attribute the improvement in my roses to the MG, and I've been assured that it will not damage the earthworms and microbes that I'm trying to develop in the soil. But your situation with high temps and little water to cool the soil is probably a recipe for dormancy. Even though rain washes away our nutrients, what a difference it makes along with the lower temps that come with the rain. Last summer my garden was sticks, too, with very little rain. Obviously, I don't know if MG would have helped then.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    terryjean,

    Plants can only use so much fertilizer, and too much is harmful. To use Rose Tone monthly is to feed generously, and I doubt adding MG would help. The exception might be when plants leaf out in spring. Nitrogen from organic sources may not be readily available in cold soil.

  • 17 years ago

    Sherry, I'm glad to hear that your roses are doing better! It is very discouraging to be working and doing what you think is good for your garden and have stuff not do well, despite your efforts. I have some plants in a bed where nothing seems to look very good; I'm thinking it's the soil so I'm going to work on that. When it cools off and I find the energy.

    I think I tend to overfeed my roses, although I'm getting better about not overdoing it. If roses could get fat from overfeeding, mine would definitely be of the husky form!

    Lynn

  • 17 years ago

    In Florida, we're SUPPOSED to feed something like Rose Tone (or other granular fertilizer) every month. Our soils, even the ones with a little clay content, are still very sandy and leach nutrients quickly. In addition to the granular, (and this can be an organic one), the ideal scenario is to feed every two or three weeks with a liquid fertilizer.

    This year, I have negelcted to do that, and my roses look like it too. I need to do what Sherry did, and at least give them some Miracle Gro.

    I'm busy weeding right now though, and it's HOT out.

    Sandy

  • 17 years ago

    Lynn, based on the label directions I overfeed, too. (Don't know about the MG. It's hard for me to calculate how much each rose is getting with the hose-end sprayer.) But between the slow release of the organics and my sandy soil I've never had a problem.

    Hope you can fix that bed somehow. Going back and re-doing is not my idea of fun.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    "something like Rose Tone (or other granular fertilizer) "

    Sandy, to me the distinction shouldn't be between granular and liquid, but between fast and slow release. Most manufactured granular fertilizers, such as cheap 10-10-10, are immediately soluble like MG. In fact, I sometimes dissolve it in water for use on potted plants (2 TB/gallon). The part that doesn't dissolve is, believe it or not, gravel added for filler.

    Rose Tone and other organic feeds release nitrogen gradually over the course of a year in Florida, or two seasons up north, so there shouldn't be much of a leaching problem. Possibly with very sandy soil and the summer monsoon, you might run low on potassium after a few weeks and get some benefit from mid-month MG feeding in addition to monthly Rose Tone.. The only slow-release potassium is in plastic-coated fertilizers.

  • 17 years ago

    Michael, are you saying that a dose of Rose-Tone should last a year in Florida and two years up north? That hasn't been my experience at all. I fed in May, and by July my bushes were practically nude with lots of what looked like blind shoots which are now sprouting. So I concluded that the plants used it all and/or the rain washed it through the sandy soil.

    Today's MG feeding only took about 2 hours, and I wasn't nearly as worn out. Though it's still hot and sweaty work (except that I'm soaked from the waist down by the leaking hose), I enjoy doing it so very much because I know the great results I'll have. It is the sweetest labor I have done in my garden. I look forward to it! And my azaleas look better, too.

    Sandy, try doing it early - at least before noon. The mornings have been pretty nice lately. And don't forget to rinse the leaves.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    I have two of the old MG sprayers! Because I thought I lost one. I did see the 'new' one, but I'll keep my old ones, thanks.

  • 17 years ago

    "Michael, are you saying that a dose of Rose-Tone should last a year in Florida?"

    No, one dose of Rose Tone is only (say) 1/10 of a year's nutritional requirement, but some nutrients from that dose will still be available a year later. It's said that the half-life of slow organic nitrogen is around 7 warm months.

    My point was that if you use mixed organic fertilizer, there may not be any benefit to feeding every two weeks. Nitrogen and phosphorus at least will be continuously available if you feed, say, every 5 weeks.

  • 17 years ago

    Sherry, if you don't have drippers, you might try simply teaspooning the allotted MG onto each bush and then water thoroughly. There was a fellow from Florida on the forum a while back that did it and I like the idea, as did my back not having to carry around a water can. Also, by measuring exactly how much I want for the size of the bush, I feel more confident about how much I've given.

    Thanks for the tip about using the bottles in-line in the drip, I'll have to give that a try.

    Does anyone use the MG for Roses? It is pink in color if you threw away your box. I don't have the stats in front of me.

    Btw Sherry, my roses like my husband better than me for this very reason ;-)

  • 17 years ago

    Sherry, we'll want pics again when they're fat and happy. :)

  • 17 years ago

    Michael, I'm trying to follow what you're saying. "It's said that the half-life of slow organic nitrogen is around 7 warm months." That is if it hasn't leached out of the root zone, right? Like if it were locked in some nice clay soil, right? Is the half-life relevant if it isn't there anymore? Forgive me, Michael, I'm afraid I'm being overly cute (and maybe a smart@$$) in an effort not to sound dumb. I have no doubt that if I used organic dry fert every 4 or 5 weeks it would be sufficient...well, I have SOME doubt that it will still be there at the end of 5 weeks. But the point is I physically can't put it out in the garden under 90-something roses in the heat and humidity of June, July, August & Sept. I have written a check my body can't cash, so I've opted for an easier way. In deference to what you're saying I won't repeat the MG in two weeks to see what happens. It certainly would be cheaper if you're right.

    Buford, I found my old one in the shed. I guess I didn't throw it away after all. I wonder if it will really get all the out to the end of the line.

    lagomorphmom, that's a good idea about teaspooning it to each bush. It saves on water anyway. I used the Rose MG earlier in the summer with my alfalfa tea & fish emulsion (oh, I can just see Michael tearing his hair out with that one) in my back garden. I can only say the roses in the back held their leaves and bloomed some whereas the ones in front didn't much.

    Gean, by everyone else's standards these may not actually be fat.
    Clotilde Soupert was really bare 2 or 3 weeks ago, but I think she's fairly chubby now. It's all relative, you know.
    {{gwi:304145}}

    Jean Bach Sisley was very 'thin'.
    {{gwi:304146}}

    Hermosas (3) and Jean Bach Sisley behind them. The Hermosas were definitely sticks before MG.
    {{gwi:304147}}

    Poor Don Juan is totally embarrassed that I'm posting his photo. He's still pretty emaciated but you can see the red new growth and the blooms. He was totally nekid 4 weeks ago.
    {{gwi:304148}}

    I was out watering a little while ago in the dark, and Anna Olivier is just amazing. I think I need to stop feeding her. She took a two week respite since dropping her last flowers and started blooming again while putting on new growth. She almost has TOO many leaves. What a woman!

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    It seems reasonable that roses that bloom so heavily need to be frequently fed, esp since your soil is sandy. Your roses are looking good to me, Sherry! I think I could hear them humming "for she's a jolly good feeder..." Gean

  • 17 years ago

    LOL, Gean, you're very cute!!

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    We need Dr. Malcom Manners wisdom here .
    He is the Florida rose guru and knows a ton about growing roses .
    Proof is in the amazing rose gardens at USF where he teaches .
    Dr. Manners - are you out there ?

  • 17 years ago

    Very interesting idea about spooning the fertilizer around the plant and then watering in. This doesn't burn the roots? I hate lugging cans around the yard although I have at least taken to filling a large trash can with the fertilizer mixture so I don't have to mix each can (which I have stupidly done in the past)

    Sherry, you should be the next spokesmodel for MG: "my roses were LEAFLESS WONDERS before I started feeding them Miracle Grow......." An endorsement fee could follow :)

    Lynn

  • 17 years ago

    Sherry,

    Slow organic nitrogen doesn't wash out of the soil because it's insoluble in water. Most of it is in proteins. Bacteria slowly digest it and secrete part of it as soluble urea. So after roughly 7 warm months, 1/2 of it is still in insoluble form; after 14 warm months, 1/4 is still in the soil. Espoma Tones have about half their nitrogen in slow form; alfalfa, 100% slow.

    I hope we do hear from Dr. Manners. I can't find his website and fear he has taken it down. There he described his feeding program as of circa 2000. It was based on Osmocote and Milorganite every 3 months, lighter in winter.

  • 17 years ago

    Sherry, I'm so glad that things are doing better! It's hard to get out and fertilize, I know. I used to give my roses "blue juice" through an in line device in the drip system. It did really work great. I've heard that it's hard on the health of the soil so now I'm doing other things. I found this powdered fish meal at our local nusery supply. I give the roses 1/3 of a cup. I'm trying to figure out how often to do it. They seem very happy with this so far.

  • 17 years ago

    Somewhere above Sherry talked about rinsing off the MG. I use MG sometimes as a foliar feed at half strength.

    When my roses or orchids (or really anything I value) are young and I am going for growth, I do use it. I am transitioning to more organics as I can. Sometimes the organics are just too much work or expense and I am no spring chicken.

  • 17 years ago

    Hey, Victoria, does that make us fall chickens? I thought MG was a foliar spray, too, but maybe just not in summer. The first time I did it, I burned a lot of leaves so now I rinse. And of course, using the MG sprayer, I have no clue how to make it half strength. When I was using my other sprayer, I was putting 4 tbls in the tank on a 4 oz setting. I guess I'm easily confused but these sprayers confuse me. And MichaelG is no help. :))

    Michael, as to "Slow organic nitrogen doesn't wash out of the soil because it's insoluble in water", I think the nature of sand is to even wash out solid organic matter. If the nitrogen was there, why weren't the plants green? And the same for phosphorus. Why weren't they blooming? I do use Milorganite which I've read is slow release.

    Mendocino rose, it would be nice if Lowe's carried powdered fish meal, but not yet.

    Lynn, spokesperson maybe. Spokesmodel never.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    "If the nitrogen was there, why weren't the plants green? "

    I never said your plants were fed enough. I was just explaining the mechanism. Probably your plants could use around 8 cups of Tone per year. If you only applied 3 cups, there would always be some nitrogen being released, but there would rarely be enough. I doubt very much that organic fertilizer would wash out of the soil in a year. What happens to it is that bacteria gradually eat it.

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks, Michael, I get what you're saying now.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    Sherry,
    one thing I've noticed about your garden is how fast your roses grow, and I've read about your soil prep so I know how much you rely on organics, manure, etc.

    Just the difference in the Natch N pictures makes me wonder if the bloom problems in the second pic were because of fertilizer needs. Your good soil prep and and climate seem to be so conducive to growth, that coupled with your sandy soil and constant rain lately, that I wonder if the N is being depleted really quickly, so something like a fast acting nitrogen is a good fix for right now.

    Makes me think that your feeding program next year needs more N overall...? I have been using Milorganite; some people don't like it because of suspicions about heavy metals, etc., but my roses sure like it. Anyway, just a thought.

    just one more anecdote, Hermosa for me started getting those washed out blooms like your NN. I got so disgusted that I cut it down to 6 inches and started feeding it Miracle Grow frequently. It snapped out of it, regained its lost growth and the bloom color went back to normal. That is purely anecdotal, but it makes me wonder if that's what caused the NN problems too. I don't know, just thinking aloud, so you know what that's worth! Love ya,

    Gean

  • 17 years ago

    Gean, you make some good points. I wonder if fast growth uses up more nutrients. And regarding milorganite, anything that the earthworms love so dearly can't be bad.

    I don't know about NN. Each new candalabra would give me hope that this one would be different, but after the first flush they were all the same. If I had plenty of room, I would not have given him the heave-ho, but I had others wanting his spot. It would be interesting to have found out if it was just a maturity issue or fertilizer or what.

    It really would be nice if I knew what I was doing. Love ya, too.

    Sherry