SHOP BY DEPARTMENT
apprenticerosarian

Banana Peels. Use or Toss?

ApprenticeRosarian
19 years ago

I was told not to place banana peels in my compost. Any idea why? Was I misinformed?

Comments (68)

  • north_jersey_girl
    19 years ago

    How much & how often for the peels & grounds? Can the peels really be frozen for later? Thanks

  • Hawkeye_Belle
    19 years ago

    Sorry I left out some vital information with the banana tonic. Yes you can freeze banana, peel and all. If it makes you feel better put them in a plastic bag.
    When I have collected enough bananas, I place one banana, peel, too, minus the hard tip ends in the blender. (You can slice the banana easily if it is frozen). Put in enough water to cover the banana and liquify. Pour this mixture into a gallon container. (Milk containers are great, but you must use a funnel). Fill the container with water and pour this mixture on the rose at the crown and around the drip line. One banana per rose, one gallon of the tonic per plant. Simple.

  • Related Discussions

    Help! Need Exterior Paint Color to Match White Roof in Florida

    Q

    Comments (101)
    I'm writing in case people are still reading this thread. I'm not a professional but I have studied,researched theory, and worked with paint on my own for years. First thing I'd say is that they is no way you can pick out paint colors for the exterior of a house unless you know what region of the U.S. the hous is located. A gray that's beautiful in Portland, Oregon isn't going to look good on a house in Florida. I wish all these people that live in Florida knew that. Perhaps you wouldn't be seeing all these brownish/gray beiges that look muddy and dreary. You have the correct undertones to deal with the harsh sun in Florida. Battleship gray doesn't work. Any color you choose be sure to paint a large patch on the side of the house before you paint the whole thing. Look to see if it looks grayed out and muddy. Or way too saturated with color. A peachy color on a small swatch at the paint store will look totally different on a whole house. Like the lady in a subdivision where I use to live who decided she wanted a shell pink house and ended up with pepto bismal pink. And expensive lesson, since the HOA made her repaint it. Florida, at least Central Florida, is terrible with this style of mediterrean architecture. Those huge columns and arches on these mide size homes are so over powering. I feel it's best to try to stay monochromic with color choices as not to highlight all the columns, archs and do-daddy styrofoam trim they put all on one house. It's not easy choosing exterior paint color there a lot of things to consider. Just make sure to invest in paint samples.
    ...See More

    What kitchen implement do you use the absolute most?

    Q

    Comments (71)
    Sharp knives, silicone spatula, garlic press, and lemon squeezer. They are in the sink almost every night. I also love my very old (30+ years) cuisinart. We have had to replace the wookbowl and knife blade a couple times over the years. It is the only electric appliance that is worth the counter space.
    ...See More

    POLL: Do you compost?

    Q

    Comments (103)
    "We don't compost because the process puts the maximum amount of METHANE into the air." No, it doesn't......well, not if you do it properly. Landfills, where stuff gets buried and is prevented from contact with oxygen in the environment, is where a lot of methane is produced. But if you (or your municipality) composts properly, turning the decomposing material frequently to allow proper exposure to air and making sure it doesn't dry out, then only a very minimal amount of methane is produced or released. No biologic body will stay inert, so get that idea out of your head. Depriving that old banana peel of oxygen in the landfill allows it to decompose in an anerobic environment, thereby producing vastly more methane.
    ...See More

    POLL: Do you use shelf paper?

    Q

    Comments (140)
    PLEASE DO NOT USE A FOAM-BACKED VINYL SHELF LINER. My tenants used it only 2 and 1/2 years ago. When they started to remove it, the foam tore, separating from the vinyl, and leaving a HUGE MESS of foam and adhesive still stuck to my nicely painted pine shelves. They only removed one shelf and left the rest of the kitchen for me to deal with!!!! Since we spray painted them with a quality water-based enamel, I can't use rubbing alcohol. I'm going to have to experiment. Maybe paint thinner, turpentine or kerosene will work without ruining the paint ?? Grrrrrr !! Twenty-seven years ago I used coordinating vinyl backed wall paper to fully line the shelves and back wall of the overhead cabinets. The same tenant used it for 22 years and it still looked ok when she moved. It was dry strippable so I did have to wet the paper and wash it off. But really, it wasn't too bad. We've also used 4x8 sheets of vinyl at Home Depot, cut to lay on top of the shelves. It worked great, can be easily removed and cleaned; but it was more expensive ($15 - $20/ sheet ??) Let me repeat -- DO NOT USE FOAM-BACKED VINYL. That's going to be the next thing I add to the tenants' "Do's and Don'ts List."
    ...See More
  • flowerchild_tx8b
    19 years ago

    I know this is far too easy (lazy), but I just put the whole brown banana or peel on the ground next to the bush. Same thing with carrot and potato peels and coffee grounds, etc.. In our heat the breakdown seems to happen overnight, and no one has ever noticed my organic fertilizers. I hate to put stuff down the disposer, and compost piles seem like work.

  • Hawkeye_Belle
    19 years ago

    Flowerchild, as a former Texan, I can bet that just burying the whole thing would work just fine as long as you don't have four legged critters that would dig them up.
    I have a dog, squirrels, rabbits, gophers, birds and who knows what else. I envy your ease. Go for it!

  • mrskjun
    19 years ago

    You guys are getting me some strange looks. Already I show up at work each morning with bucket in hand to collect the days coffee grounds. Yesterday the cook made a huge banana pudding for dessert. Guess what I came home with a big bag of?

  • Hawkeye_Belle
    19 years ago

    Just what the rose doctor ordered--banana peels!
    I know what you mean about strange looks. Last Saturday I had a surprise visit from my friends. On my kitchen counter were 12 thawing banana peels getting ready to be toniced. When I told them what I was going to do with them (she's a cook and thought I was making a lot of banana bread) there was a sudden silence. Oh, too strange.

  • PatienceDonkey
    19 years ago

    lol!! I've been feeding banana peels and brown mushy bananas to my Staghorn Fern. That fern is actually sittin up like a beggin dog lol
    Lilly
    P.S. some really funny posts in this thread

  • kitova
    18 years ago

    great to hear all this talk about banana peels. i love bananas. i would buy a whole bunch and then walk around my garden eating bananas and tossing the peels into my bed. it's great but my neighbors must think i'm crazy or just a dirty littering lady!

  • joyce58
    18 years ago

    What other flowering plants /shrubs might benefit from burying banana peels?

  • kitova
    18 years ago

    hi i just wanted to add that i caught a chipmunk trying to steal a banana peel. Too bad it was too big for him! I think I prefer to put banana peels whole covered with a little mulch because if i put them deep, i'm afraid my little family of chipmunks will dig em up and hurt some roots..

  • socks
    17 years ago

    If y'all like the banana and coffee grounds idea so much, you should go on over to the vermicomposting forum and find out how to turn those peels and grounds into compost.

  • wildrose1996
    17 years ago

    Well, to foil the greedy chipmunks, squirrels, etc., make the tonic, and just pour it around the dripline as described above. It really doesnt take long. The hardest part is washing the blender afterwards. I think my husband is going to think I have well and trully lost my mind when he catches me making banana smoothies by the gallons for my garden!!!
    Allison

  • Lyrical
    17 years ago

    Banana Batido:

    Grind ice in a blender, then add and beat bananas and milk. It tastes sweeter than you'd expect.

    This makes a great liquid lunch when it's too hot to eat, and will give you an infinite supply of banana peels.

  • nancysil
    17 years ago

    I have fun pulling the peels into little strings with my fingers, and then I just put the stringy mess on top of the soil around my roses, tomatoes and peppers. The strings of peel turn brown very quickly and are not particularly noticeable. they become both mulch and food.

    I haven't noticed the million or so chickmunks, squirrels and raccoons who visit my yard removing the peels, but if they want to steal some banana peel they are welcome to it as long as they leave my tomatoes alone!

    Also the worms in my worm bin love banana peel so I'm sure the ones in your garden would love it too. Attracting worms around your plants adds extra fertilizer.

  • EBird
    17 years ago

    As for coffee grounds, our Starbucks has a sign that says if you call ahead, they'll provide you with grounds gratis.

  • zone29
    17 years ago

    I not only use banana peels, but any fresh unused bits of produce, which I put in my blender and mix with water, I use it everywhere in my garden and what a big response - next day the plants I have used it on are standing straighter, look shinier and seem to be saying "feel good today".

  • nebancsvirag
    17 years ago

    I do feed banana peels to both my roses and my staghorn ferns, but reading this thread, i am thinking ---if banana peels are so good, then the banana trunk i cut off after fruiting, should be equally good???
    Does anyone have any experience with this???
    Irene

  • nancyd
    17 years ago

    FYI, bury them deep. Squirrels love banana peels, too, or at least are curious enough to dig up what they smelled. If you have a large squirrel population, you'd be better off composting them.

  • PatienceDonkey
    17 years ago

    I have also heard that banana peels are good for putting under banana trees, makes them very very healthy, provides much needed potassium to the growing banana tree.

    Lilly

  • catfishred2006
    17 years ago

    I love peels and coffee grounds, my roses just love them.

  • peachiekean
    17 years ago

    If we can get coffee grounds from Starbucks, why can't we get some banana peels from some of these smoothie businesses like Robek's or Jamba Juice? I say this because some folks have SO many rose bushes! I have been lazy about my banana peels lately and this thread has inspired me. To the kitchen right now!

  • phylrae
    16 years ago

    I hope you don't mind a newbie to this forum adding to this post? (I'm a regular on the Rose Forum & Gallery). Like mentioned already, Starbucks has an "official" program (see their website) for gardeners/rosegrowers who want their used coffee grounds. I used to call first, but now I just stop by (or have my husband stop by) anytime we're in the area (3 miles up the road) sometime in the late afternoon or early evening and they hand us a garbage bag doubled up full of the day's used grounds. I just add to my compost bin or scratch into existing soil. I have tried to access used coffee grounds from 2 local Dunkin' Donuts and a Panera Bread restaurant (gourmet pastries/coffee shop), but since theirs' isn't an "official" program, I have been disappointed with them. They'd promise to save me the grounds, but always forget. So I gave up on them and just go to Starbucks. Great soil amendment. Phyl

  • butterflygardener
    14 years ago

    Hi, I am new to this forum (usually in Florida gardening) but, have been lurking abit. I tried a banana and coffee grounds smoothie on a poor leggy rose I rescued at an estate sale. And wow! You should see all the beautiful new growth within just a few days! I am a believer! Thanks for the tips!
    Kat

  • pkapeckopickldpepprz
    14 years ago

    If you use cut up banana peels will you need to bury it or will it being moist cause mold or fungus to grow which would be bad for roses?

  • ppcorella
    14 years ago

    Two years ago I had black spot on my roses and I was ready to toss the plant. I can't tell you how many roses I dug up and threw out because of black spot. Anyway that year we moved the rose bush and put banana peels in the hole. We had no black spot last year and I am going to scratch some more banana peels in the root area so I don't get black spot this year. I live on Long Island.

  • treelover
    14 years ago

    pkapeckopickldpepprz: Maybe you should add a little milk to the bananas & coffee grounds for any fungus that might form. This is sounding more and more like a banana-mocha smoothie!

  • girlndocs
    14 years ago

    Molds and fungi are simply workers in the system of decomposition. Sometimes you see 'em -- like on banana peels left on top of the ground -- sometimes you don't -- like the miles and miles of mycelium active in your soil food web, under your feet.

    On compostables, they are nothing to fear. They are the good guys.

    Kristin

  • burntplants
    14 years ago

    Making smoothies??!!
    Haha! That's waaay too much work for me.
    I just throw them in the compost bin or, if I'm feeling energetic, tuck them deep under the mulch in my garden!

    But I NEVER, ever plant a rose without a black banana (the whole thing!) in the bottom of the hole.

    Talk about strange looks--for a week my mother tried to sneak a whole bunch of blackened bananas in the trash when I wasn't looking--I was expecting a whole hedge to be delivered and I wanted to be prepared!

    Vicky's blog!

  • petalz
    14 years ago

    I just heard about this from a friend that did yard work for a woman with roses. He would sneek and bury banana peels around her tired scraggly plants and they erupted with new growth and flowers. Never told her what he did!
    Also I am going to do an experiment with the help of my friend who has" less than nurtured" roses and put just one of each of the wonderfull things im reading about on each; alfalfa tea on one and alfalfa pellets on another (since I am seeing so much controversy as to which one is better) horse manure, fish and seaweed emulsion, coffee grounds and Botanicare organic liquid fertilizer and wait to see which ones work best for our Hawaii climate and use a combo of the best.
    By the way did I leave out anythig I should try?
    Also I think i will add the banana coffee smoothie sounds fun

  • auburngardengal
    14 years ago

    I've been putting our neighborhood Starbucks coffee grounds in the compost pile, but too much seems to throw off the breaking down of the pile. Husband and my two boys used to eat bananas but rarely now--have to depend on donations from neighbors. Recently came across an organic web site that suggested using Epsom salts around (12 to 18 inches away from the crown) the base of a rose to boost and revive it. I'm trying it on a few of mine.
    I'll take homemake banana bread anyday over a banana smoothie!

  • aureliajulia
    13 years ago

    I have to agree that the official banana smoothie sounds like work to me, but after reading this (again, it's been around for years), I'm eying the bunch on my counter with a mixure of guilt and anticipation.

    Fish, seaweed, coffee, bananna, manure. I need to get to work.

    I loved that comment describing the "silent" reactions of friends to the thawing bananas. Hysterical!

    AJ

  • heidi_louise
    12 years ago

    My husband did not get my traditional mother's day rose bushes last year (slacker). He will have to do double time this year and provide me with all the bananas I need -as well as make the smoothies to go with them!!! Thanks for the great advice!!H

  • yvonne2009
    12 years ago

    it's march now and my roses are leafing out but they seem to be dying also, is it to early to put bananas on them?

  • fulvio
    12 years ago

    Oddly, I picked up this tip from the movie 7 Pounds (great movie btw), where Will Smith advises a lady to dig banana peels around her roses and it works marvellously.

    So I came here to check out if its true. Great discussion and tips, and I've just started with the worst of our dozen bushes. Now to go buy some more bananas so I can do the rest. Thanks all.

  • Kimmsr
    12 years ago

    Banana peelings are one, small, part of what your roses need to grow into strong healthy plants. By themselves they will not magically help your roses grow into nice plants. Start with a good, reliable soil test. Contact your state universities USDA Cooperative Extension Service office and ask about having a good, reliable soil tewst done so you know what your soils pH is and what the base nutrient level is and also dig in with these simple soil tests,
    1) Structure. From that soil sample put enough of the rest to make a 4 inch level in a clear 1 quart jar, with a tight fitting lid. Fill that jar with water and replace the lid, tightly. Shake the jar vigorously and then let it stand for 24 hours. Your soil will settle out according to soil particle size and weight. A good loam will have about 1-3/4 inch (about 45%) of sand on the bottom. about 1 inch (about 25%) of silt next, about 1 inch (25%) of clay above that, and about 1/4 inch (about 5%) of organic matter on the top.

    2) Drainage. Dig a hole 1 foot square and 1 foot deep and fill that with water. After that water drains away refill the hole with more water and time how long it takes that to drain away. Anything less than 2 hours and your soil drains too quickly and needs more organic matter to slow that drainage down. Anything over 6 hours and the soil drains too slowly and needs lots of organic matter to speed it up.

    3) Tilth. Take a handful of your slightly damp soil and squeeze it tightly. When the pressure is released the soil should hold together in that clump, but when poked with a finger that clump should fall apart.

    4) Smell. What does your soil smell like? A pleasant, rich earthy odor? Putrid, offensive, repugnant odor? The more organic matter in your soil the more active the soil bacteria will be and the nicer you soil will smell.

    5) Life. How many earthworms per shovel full were there? 5 or more indicates a pretty healthy soil. Fewer than 5, according to the Natural Resources Conservation Service, indicates a soil that is not healthy.
    to see what else you might need do to make that soil into the good, healthy soil that wil grow strong and healthy plants.

  • plan9fromposhmadison
    12 years ago

    I sheet compost beneath some of my roses. I just tuck the kitchen scraps (all plant material, & about 30% Banana peels)beneath the layer of pine straw. Noticed just the other day, that a bucketful of Banana peels at the base of one rose had completely decomposed since December.

    As to the encouragement of moulds and fungi....well...yes! And you want them around your roses, except for the ones that attack roses (these are not interested in banana peels). Microbial Antagonism is a valuable tool in keeping a healthy garden. Microbes fight and kill each other all the time, and that is a crucial component in the health of plants and animals. Too, microbes manufacture all manner of substances beneficial to plants. Having the banana peels on or in your soil allows your roses to uptake those substances as they are being released.

  • Nicole_Willner_gmail_com
    12 years ago

    Some say not to throw bananas in the compost bin because their skin is laden with pesticides, which then end up in your compost and garden soil. But if you buy organic bananas instead of conventional, then you should have no worries. FYI - The price of organic bananas is almost the same as conventional.

  • Zyperiris
    12 years ago

    I have several roses in pots...since I am lazy I just plopped the entire banana or peel right in the pot. A few days later I buried the peel..

    What I so love about doing this..is that you can do something with trash

  • serenasyh
    12 years ago

    I think one of the best! nutrients is sweet potatoes... when my parents went on vacation they forgot to bring some boiled sweet potatoes with them and were afraid of it rotting in their refrigerator... So my newly acquired own root roses were planted with good 'ole fashioned Southern cookin' hahaha! I bet they liked those even better than a banana peel... oooo, all those stocked vitamins...

  • apeelin
    11 years ago

    How about this question: BURNED BANANA PEELS. USE OR TOSS? I took the advice of one of the posts on this wonderful forum and baked the banana peels with two goals in mind: first, to dehydrate them in hopes of speeding up decomposition and second, to reduce the banana smell in hopes of decreasing the number of bugs (fruit flies are such an issure around here!). My intention was to turn on the oven to get it hot, then turn it off when I left the house. Unfortunately, I forgot to turn it off when I left the house. They baked at 350 for 4 hours. They are totally charred. I am totally bummed. Any use for them now? I suppose the potassium has become carbon.

  • friedabyler
    11 years ago

    I suppose they would qualify as "browns" in the compost pile! I would use them...

  • skayc1
    11 years ago

    ever since I read about using used coffee grounds and banana peals in the garden I've been feeding my plants with it, my tomatoes and peppers went crazy, as for my roses, maybe I didn't give them enough of the banana /used coffee grounds cause only after I fed the roses tomato fertilizer did they put out tons of new growth. so today I decided to feed the roses, which are in containers, cold coffee. Maybe my new floribunda rose that I recently got will start doing better, it had cane borers and looks puny.

  • maryiwalton_yahoo_com
    10 years ago

    Another idea for those who want to do coffee grinds and banana peels. go to starbucks or other coffe joint and get there used grinds. then go to your local grocery store and ask the produce department to give you a call or let you know when the go through and toss the old fruits and veges then take them home with coffe grinds and blend them in a blender with some water and pour around your plants, soaks in ground faster and dont have to worry about attracting animals and its all free.

  • gardenstudent7
    10 years ago

    Hello! I just got back from burying banana peels and crushed eggshells, an idea I got from this and other forums and discovered tons of ants (black) have made their home in the bark mulch of my roses. This cannot be good for them. :( (My bushes are about a year old and I am new to rose growing.) How do I get rid of them??? the cheap, organic, or homemade way would be good...

  • samcrowther7_earthlink_net
    10 years ago

    For years and years I have told my friends and acquaintances that NOTHING will eat a banana peel. My expertise relied on my jogging 3 days a week for years and picking up trash on the road. Kids driving to school late toss out banana skins on the road. Three years later the skin is still there! Eventually, fungi and mold destroy it. Now you have proven me WRONG. I'm 77 and not supposed to be wrong. Now I have to tell people that worms and Mr. LIncoln love to eat banana skins!
    Thanks a lot!

    PS. I'm using them now in my garden and worm bed!
    I can be taught, however reluntanly!

    Mr. Sam

  • granmabarbara
    10 years ago

    Has anyone heard of using pickle juice on rose bushes? Could you use diluted vinegar?

  • mwenrick
    10 years ago

    When I plant a rose bush I use composted manure and a whole banana. My earth worms love it and my bushes do really good. I make gardening as easy as possible. I've tried the compost teas and grounds, but I don't notice a difference with all the work. I sprinkle Osmocate a couple of times during the season. I enjoy pruning and deadheading but I really want to enjoy my roses and not stress myself out with work. Seems to do fine for me.

  • kirpi57_yahoo_com
    10 years ago

    I freeze banana peels in a big ziploc bag (OK, several big bags!) and then bury the frozen peels (chopped up if I'm feeling energetic) around the rose bushes in the spring. Works a treat! I have beautiful old roses that have been thriving in the yard for over 60 years.

  • pedroinfante82
    10 years ago

    I used banana peels when transplanting my inside house plants into bigger pots and I have to say that my plants have never looked so nice. Must be that Potasium. I burried the peels about 6 inches deep under the plants just to make sure we dont get any mosquitoes and by the time they started to decompost was around the time that the roots start growing into them. Never throw away banana peels in my opinion.

  • weehawlw
    10 years ago

    I assumed it was because bananas are highly treated with pesticides that would stay on the skin and then in the ground or compost ,, anyone have any idea about this ,, fact or fiction ?