Software
Houzz Logo Print
daninthedirt

relocating urban squirrel pests ; what I learned

Four months ago we had a long discussion here about the value, humaneness, and legality of relocating urban squirrels in an effort to preserve gardens.

See discussion here

Well, I did that relocation and, now that it is the end of the summer, here is how it turned out. An important lesson was learned. Pardon the length of this report.

I live in an urban residential area. Riparian, near a creek. Lots of trees. Lots of squirrels. Mostly Foxs and a few Greys. I've lived here about 20 years, and recently I've noticed a lot more squirrels. I used to go outside and see maybe one. But this spring I'd see two or three. The squirrels started to be MAJOR vegetable garden pests, probably because of competition for food. Taking bites out of melons, eggplants, and making off with lots of tomatoes. Geez, if you're going to eat a melon, eat the whole thing! Oh, and they terrorized my bird feeders as well, and displayed acrobatics getting around my shields for them.

Scare them away? Ha. These guys are committed. I tried leaving used cat litter and cayenne pepper around, and there are outdoor cats that patrol the area. No effect. The idea that these squirrels can be discouraged by making stuff smell threatening is, in my neck of the woods, simply delusional. I tried. Hey, these are inner-city squirrels. Not easily-intimidated rural bumpkins.

Where I live, killing squirrels isn't permitted. No poison, no bullets. But trapping and relocating them is. By TX law you can relocate them to public land without permission. There is a lot of that riparian public land around here. I had read that you needed to move them at least two miles away, in order that they couldn't find their way back.

I did that FOURTEEN TIMES, in May and June. Got a Havahart medium trap and did it big time. Worked great. Dropped them off in mostly different places. Yeah, but that adds up to an hour or two of of driving. May and June are supposed to be well after rearing season, and well before put-food-away-for-the-winter season. So I score points for a humane strategy.

My wife laughed and said that I was just bailing the ocean. That for each squirrel I removed, another would come back to take it's place.

I was trapping and relocating one every other day or so. They disappeared for a week, and I thought I had 'em defeated. Then I trapped FOUR in one day. Boom. Boom. Boom. Boom. I think a rogue mob came by and was trying to take over the 'hood. But I got them.

Since then. NONE. It's spooky. I haven't seen a squirrel in my yard in two months. (Well, almost. I saw one last week once, but never saw it again. Just passin' through, I guess.) Next block over there are plenty. My summer garden has been unmolested. I am very happy. We have local raptors of several kinds, and they don't seem to be too bothered. They weren't doing their job for me in the first place!

So, what's going on? Where's the ocean that I was supposed to be bailing? In talking to a local habitat biologist, it's becoming clear. Squirrels are very territorial (not so handy for the squirrels that I relocated). Except for occasional rogue squirrel mobs, they pretty much stay put. The prediction is that I won't see any squirrels until early next spring, when the new squirrels are reared. They get thrown out of the nest, and look for unclaimed places to live.

The bottom line is that YES, it looks like you can rid yourself of urban squirrels by trapping and relocating. It takes some effort, but it works. After doing a big job once, you may have to do an ideally much smaller clean-up job every spring. We'll see.

Now, I don't want to hear sob stories about relocated squirrels. Yes, their ability to survive after relocation is questionable. But they're tree rats. Get over it. Kinda cute tree rats. My position is that I gave them a chance, which bullets and poison would not have given them.

Comments (14)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Interesting. How did you trap them? They are about to strip my pecan tree.

    This post was edited by marti8a on Sun, Sep 14, 14 at 23:13

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Thanks for the update. It's good to know that neighboring squirrels don't immediately move in to fill the gap giving you a little relief from veggie garden damage.

    A squirrel, I never saw more than one, quietly stripped my loaded pecan tree of GREEN pecans over a period of about three weeks. I don't care about harvesting pecans, but the partially eaten green pecans and the husks made a big mess and stained anything they landed on. I've never had them do that before.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    As I said, I trapped them with a Havahart medium trap. Worked very well, though there are some tricks. I used a slice of apple smeared with peanut butter as bait. In my experience, squirrels go absolutely nuts for peanut butter.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Thanks for the info. I'll bait my trap tonight.

    roselee, that's what is happening in my tree too, except I WANT the nuts. This pecan has big, sweet meats.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Hi all,

    Here's something I read in the Bryan Eagle. Might be of help to y'all trying to save your pecan crop. It's from Neil Sperry.

    "Use sheet metal to keep squirrels off pecan trees

    Posted 4 days ago

    Dear Neil: We have a good crop of pecans this year. Is there anything we can do to deter the squirrels?

    A. I face the same issues, as do commercial pecan producers. If a pecan tree is free-standing, that is, not touching other trees, power lines, etc., you can put a sheet metal collar in place around its trunk. Keep it loose so that it won't girdle the tree over time. Much better yet, affix it so that you can put it in place in early summer and remove it after all of the pecans are down in late fall. Other than that, there is nothing legal that you can do. I personally don't do anything to harm my squirrels. We always have enough pecans to share. Things like reflective strips, fake owls, etc. may work for a short time, but eventually the squirrels catch on."

    Lucy

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    We relocated 7 or 8 last year and didn't seem to lose any tomatoes to squirrels this year, while they stole or damaged virtually all of them last year. Makes a difference that we only have 2 or 3 hanging out regularly in the garden instead of the prior 8 or 9. Fruit trees are another story; they seem to relax the territorial boundaries and still descend in vast numbers on the pears and peaches just as they are ripening.... they stripped 100% once again, though did get some nocturnal help with the peaches from the opossums and rats.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    In a few years when the tree is taller and I cut off some lower limbs, the sheet metal might work. I have a piece of vent pipe around it now but the squirrels just laugh and jump from the ground onto the limbs which are weighted down with nuts and within their reach.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Marti, could you duct tape some old loose window screen between your low hanging branches and higher places? Maybe attach it to the pipe on one side and higher branches on the other? I dunno how your young tree is configured, but... maybe?

    Bad news wheh you lose pecans you want.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I know they do not like coffee grounds. You might see if a Starbucks has an abundance and lay a thick blanket of it around your tree where they leap. Might take less time than trapping since the squirrel munching has begun.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I've used the sheet metal around the trunk of my plum tree for the past few years. IT does seem to work. I get my plums.

  • 10 years ago

    It's awesome that you were actually able to get rid of them! The ones that tend to invade my yard are pretty stubborn. If they don't naturally relocate soon, like they did with you, I'm probably going to hire a pest control service. I love squirrels and think they're adorable, but they're more than my husband and I can handle. Hopefully things turn out as well for us as they did for you! http://animalcontrolspecialists.com/Squirrels.php

  • 10 years ago

    I hate them. You cant get rid of them. I big scary dog will greatly help but may not fit your lifestyle.

  • 10 years ago

    I live in a rural area, and the squirrels don't bother much, but my daughter lives in Austin, and they relocated about 20 of them as they were doing damage to their house.

  • 10 years ago

    Urban squirrels don't naturally relocate. If there is stuff to eat, there is no reason to move! Yes, you can't get rid of them *permanently*, but you CAN get rid of them for one season by trapping and relocating. That's because urban squirrels migrate from one locale to another seaonally. That is, if I rid my area (few houses around me) of squirrels, squirrels from neighboring areas won't move in until next season. I trap a bunch every spring, and my garden is largely untouched all summer.

    It's interesting. This year, the batch of squirrels I'm after don't seem too interested in peanut butter. Nor do they seem that interested in my vegetables. There may be some evolutionary pressure here, in that the ones that were last year have been thrown out.


Sponsored
Moda Kitchen and Bath
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars47 Reviews
Fairfax County's Custom Kitchen & Bath Designs for Everyday Living