I know it doesn't give you an answer, but either will look fine with what you've chosen. It all comes down to personal preference.

Think about what coordinating items you want that will go with it. I wouldn't want one of the finishes on the faucets and the other on sconces, for instance. I actually think with the rustic floor, if your faucets were satin nickel and if you chose not to do satin nickel on your sconces as well, you could do a black or oil rubbed bronze finish on your sconces if you wanted. There are pics. in some of the bathrooms here that have done that and it looks great.

Any of those finishes will look great with Quartzite. We used brushed nickel because it's easiest of the them all to keep clean. :c)

Thanks for the feedback.

I had one other thought. Since you are talking about oil rubbed bronze for the scones, how do you think this would look for the faucet finish on the white sink? Note that the sink is a 1930's art deco style.

Can you post a pic. of your vanity?

This is the pedestal sink that fits in the space...

I don't know why I was thinking you had a white vanity, not a pedestal. Here's a pic. of a sink with oil rubbed bronze faucet and mirror. I think I would prefer nickel with it.

Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:1402012}}

Thank you both so much and stlouie that picture really helps me to see that I don't care for the orb with it.