Software
Houzz Logo Print
sweetbean_gw

Please help me choose a dining table & chairs (pics attached)

20 years ago

For context: We live in a Tuscan-ish house with a large greatroom that's immediately in front of you when you step into the foyer. You go through one of 3 arches and down 2 steps to enter it, and the ceiling is of normal height (the foyer has a 2 story ceiling, so you go from large/airy foyer to lower ceilinged/cozy greatroom). To your right is the seating area with a large white Texas limestone fireplace, and the dining area is to your left. There's a row of 3 French doors at the rear of the greatroom, which overlooks the back of our property.

In 4 yrs of marriage, we've collected a few pieces of furniture here and there (although we didn't have much in our TINY last home) and find ourselves stuck when it comes to the dining table and chairs. We've been looking for the perfect set (not necessarily a matched set) ever since we moved into our home over 1 1/2 yrs ago, to no avail.

I find that I LOVE French Empire but DH thinks it's just too delicate in proportion and design for the space and our other furnishings (and honestly I don't know that I could make it work with the Tuscan feel). We have 2 ornately carved Tudor sideboards we love (one is English, one is ?), but I don't want a Tudor table & chairs. Too heavy, too clunky. I've never seen a set that looked elegant.

We can't afford high-end new so I'm looking at used, vintage & antique, as well as a new line from Stanley (Provincia). We can't spend more than $5000ish for a table & 8 - 10 chairs.

Everything I find seems to be Queen Anne, Duncan Phyfe, mid-century modern, or that new tacky heavily carved "European" style (like you'd find at Rooms to Go). It all seems too glossy, too modern, too overdone, or too delicate.

I want something that doesn't scream "Purchased in 2006!". I don't want to hate it in 10 years. The table needs to seat at least 8, preferrably 10. It can't be too formal or too casual. I'm open to leather or upholstered chairs, but don't want cane or rush seats (too casual). I'd consider cane backs if it was the perfect set. I don't want a glass table, either.

Other than that, I'm open to any ideas. I've attached a link to photos of the tudor pieces that we have, a closeup of a detail from our sofa, the Stanley set we're considering, as well as a Bassett set I like (DH is not so crazy about it) and a Henredon table that is nice but not perfect.

Thanks for sticking with me through this lengthy post! What's your opinion? Have any suggestions?

And if anyone knows anything about the buffet, I'd love to hear! We know the tall sideboard is English but the other one is a little more ornate and we aren't sure.

Here is a link that might be useful: The search for the perfect dining table & chairs

Comments (12)

  • 20 years ago

    See if you like the American Home Collection from Hickory White.

    Here is a link that might be useful: HW American Home

  • 20 years ago

    I love the Stanley Provincia set, very appropriate looking for your home style and it doesn't look over-sized. Would this set fall within your budget?

    I'm sorry I don't know anything about the buffet.

  • 20 years ago

    Check World Market's tables and chairs.

    They are heavy and dark, but not overly ornate ... and even have extensions.

    I'm impressed with the one we bought (the Ajara), although I'm still looking for chairs.

    Here is a link that might be useful: World MArket site

  • 20 years ago

    I think you and your hubby need to figure out a style first and then search it out. This site has some lovely stuff but I'm not sure of the prices:

    http://www.frenchheritage.com/Templates/collectionDetail.cfm?ProductID=2384&CategoryID=10

    This site gives you some good examples of different types of legs and what style they would be:

    http://www.tablelegs.com/indexold.htm

    Here is a link that might be useful: Table Leg Styles

  • 20 years ago

    Your home sounds lovely. My advice would be to focus on the table first and not to search for an entire set. I agree to get something medium weight; not too clunky and not too delicate. A European style would be perfect, one that is expandable with leaves.

    You need to see a lot of table styles and when you find the right one you will know it. I would go to a website like Rose Furniture or Lexington Furniture (which is posted above) and really study the different styles.

    Once you find the table, then I would look at chairs. I would look at fully upholstered chairs (no wood trim) and exposed wood legs and possibly a curved top. This style looks more European than a straight top. This way you don't have to match the chairs to the table and it will be easy to select the right proportions, fabric and price since there are many dining chair vendors out there.

    Some good suggestions above. I would also look at Harden and Nichols & Stone.

  • 20 years ago

    Thank you all for the input/insight! Thanks dktrahan for the link to the table legs. Our style for this home is definitely Tuscan, but also incorporating French & British Colonial elements. We are more into an eclectic look. Plus the house kind of forces that, as it's Tuscan in style (arches, etc) but also has more traditional touches like crown moulding and white painted cupboards and built-ins.

    Kathypass, I just saw IRL photos of the Provincia chairs (someone had them on craigslist) and unfortunately I wasn't as impressed. I know it was just a photo but the chairs were just kind of blah. :( I still like the table, though.

    Lazygardens - thanks for the input. I've also seen some surprisingly nice tables at World Market. But none of them extend large enough for us. We do a lot of entertaining and need to be able to seat 10 (or more!).

    Lizh - thanks for the other manufacturer recommendations. I honestly hadn't even heard of those two! As far as your chair suggestions, I found a set I liked before I read your post, and the chairs are an exact match for your suggestions! LOL

    John, thanks for the link to the HW line. It wasn't exactly what we are looking for (though it IS lovely!), but it led us to the set attached!

    Everyone, what do you think of this set? Is it classic enough to last awhile? It's a bit more than we intended to spend (isn't that ALWAYS the case?)

    Here is a link that might be useful: {{gwi:1525546}}

  • 20 years ago

    That's a gorgeous set and it seems to match your requirements. The table is very refined and the chairs tone it down a notch to fit nicely with your decorating scheme.

    De

  • 20 years ago

    I kinda like the Stanley table with the Bassett chairs. The Stanley chairs seemed too much. Bassett table is pretty, I love the pedestals, but once you get a lot of chairs around the table, you don't see them anyway.

    What I picture in your dining room is something from the Milling Road collection from Baker. Unfortunately it's a different (ie, higher) price point than Bassett, but you could get ideas, and maybe even find it discounted somewhere.

    Good luck! I spent years looking for my dining room furniture, but last year I finally took the plunge, and am very happy.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Milling Road

  • 20 years ago

    Sweetbean

    I just went through this in our small 11'x11' DR that was largely over furnished with a lot of "this n that" - part of our entire home reno was out with it ALL! Yea
    DR set, 2 sideboards - one that matched the set, on that was a beast & did not - a PIANO , a beautiful built in

    I searched, searched , searched - DON"T give up - You will find a table/chairs

    I scoured all ads, and Craigslist - what I found were LOTS of DR Sets - I'm close to NYC and found people giving high quality sets away - I think people are moving away from formal DRs blowing kitchens into DRs
    So my advice is don't settle - live without and enjoy the hunt I did.

    I found a Duncan Phyfe Mahogany set which is really what I wanted - our house dutch col 1930 so it suited the home as well as the small scale of our DR - it was dirty, dirty dirty - I'm still working on cleaning waxing -It is really well made & found incredible fabrics on ebay that were really reasonable - so they will get a big face lift. The owners were asking $2,200 for the set - DR table, 4 side chairs, 2 arms - mirror ,sideboard, and tall china cab
    I didn't want the china cab (we have lovely built in) got them to $1300
    Dh thought i was crazy - wait til he sees it in DR

    Here is a pic in the prior owners DR

    In my almost completed DR

    chair w/proposed fabric sitting on it

    Guess I wanted to inspire you - I know the furnishings aren't your choice but to illustrate they are out there - get on a mission

    Link to craigslist

    good luck
    eileen

    Here is a link that might be useful: Craigslist

  • 20 years ago

    When you make a big purchase like a large dining room set, don't forget to consider how the set will perform and look over many years. Specifically, I wouldn't purchase a table where the diners could scuff the legs and feet with their shoes. I much prefer tables with legs at the corners or edges, since people can't really step on those.

    The Stanley Provincia is a nice set, but the way the bases are constructed I fear they would get very scuffed over time, especially since you do lots of entertaining.

    I have some square and rectangular Lane occasional tables that over the years have been chipped on the corners to the point where they are now trashed. And this is in a very careful household, I don't know how all those dings happened! So, watch out for square corners.

    Sometimes it takes years to find just the right furniture. My family was in the furniture business (cousins still are) since 1920 and even they had trouble finding just the right items for their own homes at times. Don't forget to try second-hand furniture stores, newspaper ads, estate sales. Good luck!

  • 20 years ago

    What about American Drew?? We recently ordered a set (Cherry Grove - small round pedestal & 6 chairs) from Blacks Furniture in High Point got a great price - quality seems to be pretty good at a great price. It is delivered next week - can't wait!

    Here is a link that might be useful: American Drew - Dining Rooms

  • 20 years ago

    Thank you all so much for your replies!!! Eileen, your Duncan Phyfe set is lovely! We have one ourselves. It's the only thing that would fit in our "dining corner" in our old house! It currently lives in the kitchen, as it's too delicate for the scale of our new dining room. I also love the fabric and wallcoverings you've chosen. Be sure to post the final photos!

    Beshel, the set you've purchased is lovely, too! I've poked around the site a bit and there are some great pieces there -- I have added a few to my design folder, in the hope that a used one appears in the future.

    Dianne, we have the same concern about a pedestal table. HOWEVER, we've decided we can live with those concerns because I have some very good news to report (Thanks for the encouragement, everyone!!!):

    We found the exact Hickory White table I posted above for less than HALF of what Lexington quoted. It's a floor sample, and like new.

    Once the room's all done I'll have to post pictures. There's lots to be done yet.