Software
Houzz Logo Print
ideagirl2_gw

Once again, money fails to provide a good kitchen...

15 years ago

This was in today's New York Times slideshow about "what $700,000 will buy you." In this $700k home, we have a nice medium-sized kitchen with the following stupendously bad features:

* Range right next to the fridge, with nothing in between--so not only is there no workspace to the left of the range, there's A REFRIGERATOR that blocks pan handles and your elbows as you try to cook. And it's a 30" range, so it's not like there's room to spare.

* Range located in front of a chimney, which makes it stick out about 6" farther than the counter to the right. So yes indeed--there is ALSO no good workspace on the RIGHT side of the range!

What other forehead-smackworthy kitchen design sins can you spot??

Here is a link that might be useful: Idiotic kitchen design in $700k house

Comments (29)

  • 15 years ago

    Oh, and PS, this is a $700k four-bedroom Victorian in Salt Lake City, as opposed to, say, a $700k studio in Manhattan.

  • 15 years ago

    You should click through to the pics of the other rooms in the house! The kitchen is the best part! At least it didn't make me dizzy. I need to lie down now...but not in that master bedroom...

  • 15 years ago

    I know, the wallpaper was scrambling my brain!

  • 15 years ago

    sharonite - you crack me up!

    What's so crazy...someone actually stepped back and said 'yes, i like this...let's go with it' :)

  • 15 years ago

    Don't you guys just want to go and rescue that poor innocent farmhouse sink from that nightmare!

  • 15 years ago

    What a classic before--if the house isn't a total teardown. I didn't look at the rest of the pix, but the kitchen suggests the entire $700K or so value might be in the land.

  • 15 years ago

    Oh, that range hood is awful. Just a really poor layout. Almost as bad as mine. Looks like they just threw in new SS appliances to get it sold.

    The wall paper in the parlor, monkeys?

  • 15 years ago

    We have the fridge and the stove in a similar setup, but there is some space between. Yes, I realize this is not optimal and I do fine with the prep space I have, but we don't have a 700K home. At that price point, I would expect a better kitchen. So much more could have been done to get it ready to sell.

    I actually LIKE the home. It has great character with the exterior and the beautiful interior woodwork. However, it would take a year to get rid of all that wallpaper.

  • 15 years ago

    Wow - that's almost identical to the crappy kitchen layout in my 100K house.

  • 15 years ago

    that house really makes me feel like i need to open a window! yes, we need to go on a mission and rescue that farm sink!!

  • 15 years ago

    Oh Lord. Wizard of Oz Flying Monkey Wallpaper. I am going to have nightmares tonight for sure.

  • 15 years ago

    Frighteningly, I kind of like the wallpaper. I even like the clutter. I mean, I couldn't live there, but I understand it. Some people want to live in a Victorian home like Victorians. It's probably half the number of knicknacks and tschotschkes the original owner had.

    What I don't understand is why someone who tried to perfectly replicate Victorian decor in every room of their house got to the kitchen and decided to perfectly renovate a TGI Friday's.

  • 15 years ago

    Ah-ah-ah-CHOOOOOOO!!!!!

    I'd be sneezing all day and night in this place.

  • 15 years ago

    TGI Friday's--oh, Marcolo, such a low blow! Hahahaha!
    The crazy thing (apart from the dysfunctional layout) is, the story said the owner is an antiques dealer. You would think an antiques dealer, of all people, would know that throwing in a farmhouse sink is not going to make a crappy kitchen suddenly look period and charming.

  • 15 years ago

    Victorians are never to my taste, but I knew someone who loved them and lived in a Julia Morgan-designed Tudor, complete with Bradley & Bradley wallpaper. I would bet the wallpaper in that home is in fact B&B wallpaper, which depending upon when it was purchased, could be the handmade stuff. Even now with computer printing it is very expensive paper.

    Here's the description from the accompanying article. It is a shame they didn't do a better job on the kitchen, but the guy probably doesn't cook, LOL:

    SALT LAKE CITY
    WHAT: A house built in 1892 with four bedrooms, two full baths and three half-baths
    HOW MUCH: $699,900
    SIZE: 5,128 square feet
    PER SQUARE FOOT: $136.49

    SETTING: This house is in a neighborhood called the Avenues, a grid of streets just north of downtown Salt Lake City. The neighborhood is made up of Victorians and Craftsman-style houses built in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. While many are still occupied by single families, others have been converted into cafes, art studios and shops. The central business district is a few blocks away.

    INSIDE: Built in 1892 as a multi-unit property, the house was renovated for a single family and restored over the past 25 years. Much of the interior woodwork is original, and the current owner, a former antiques dealer, installed replica wallpaper and period light fixtures. A parlor, living room, formal dining room, media room and library with built-in bookshelves are on the main level. Upstairs, there are three bedrooms (including the master) and a reading room with a private deck. The third story is a workshop or extra room. In the basement, there�s a mother-in-law apartment with its own kitchen, bathroom and entrance. The house�s three fireplaces still function, and have their original mantels and tilework.

    OUTDOOR SPACE: A front porch, a backyard, a main-level deck and a second deck off the upstairs reading room.

    TAXES: $3,424 annually

  • 15 years ago

    I pay the same taxes for my house. Hmmm. Mine is less than half that in value. Hmmm. Must be my great kitchen that inspires the taxes. Worth every penny.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm finding this particularly interesting, as I live a few blocks from this house! My house is about the same age, but with much less wallpaper. I wish I had that woodwork!
    Not sure the price is realistic in this market. Maybe 2-3 years ago. Certainly would not be a teardown as this is a historic district. Some of the value in this neighborhood is definitely location. The "lower avenues" houses are all older- those who want more modern layouts tend to look further up the hill or in another neighborhood.
    The kitchen is unfortunate. I won't say more.
    I'll keep my eyes open for an "open house" and wander through if I get the chance.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree, jcox, I'm sure it could sell, maybe not on that price, just based on location alone. The house has great character, but most probably can't really see it behind all the wallpaper and clutter. But with smooth single-color walls and less stuff, I can see that it would be spectacular.

    That would be great if you could see it in person. No pics of bathrooms. I think that would be interesting.

  • 15 years ago

    Thank you, marcolo. I kept thinking the kitchen reminded me of something, but I couldn't figure out what it was. Very apt.

  • 15 years ago

    I agree with all of you on the kitchen layout. But, keep in mind the a 700K house in SF is equivalent to a much lower priced house elsewhere. Our house, for example, is worth 3 or 4 times (at least) what my brother's house is worth, even though they're comparable. The difference is region...I'm in Maryland in the Baltimore/Washington, DC area vs my brother in the Buffalo, NY, area.

    Regional prices need to be kept in perspective when looking at finishes, etc. for same-priced houses.

  • 15 years ago

    Sheesh! I need to proof-read better!

    "But, keep in mind that a 700K house..."
    "...Baltimore/Washington, DC, area..."

  • 15 years ago

    The stained glass in front of the fireplace is going to melt!

  • 15 years ago

    I look at that house and just feel pure jealousy. All that space. Paint and wallpaper can be changed or removed. I think our entire home could fit into a couple rooms.

    We own in a 1,500 sq. ft. home in Southern CA valued at $700k. We can't even add sq. footage to our home because of a tiny backyard. Well, at least ours is paid for. :-)

  • 15 years ago

    I thought, for 700K in my town, I'll take this house the way it is! But as ideagirl pointed out, it's in Salt Lake City.

    So -- if this is a fixer in this neighborhood, at this price, I think the owner is excused from all mess! :-) That's what fixers are!!

    If this is a higher end home, then look at the other rooms and you can tell that whoever remodeled this house, probably did not know much in remodeling! That explains the goof ups.

  • 15 years ago

    I know exactly where that house is located. The Avenues has traditionally been a trendy and expensive location in SLC, but in our current market that house is definitely overpriced. As jcoxmd noted, some of the value in the house is the location, which is literally blocks from downtown, but I've seen much better appointed homes in the Avenues selling for less recently.

  • 15 years ago

    Oh my...Have just taken two Excedrin and will expect a call in the morning....those wallpapers did me in.... That being said ...back to Ideagirl's question about the layout in that kitchen...Just where do you put your bags of groceries down- certainly not next to the refrigerator which would be on the floor or on top of the soup that was simmering on the stove. When you get something out of the refrigerator - same question- where do you land??? This kitchen needs the GW miracle workers like Buehl, RHome and all the other talented designers to fix it!

    In the meantime...watch out for those monkeys while going down the yellow brick road....

  • 15 years ago

    Ok, I LOVE that house, HATE that kitchen! The wallpaper totally fits, and that house would sell where I live, EXCEPT for the kitchen! Also, the carpet on the staircase is putrid.

    The same type of house where I live (Long Island, NY) would have an awesome, huge, top-of-the-line, well-designed kitchen. It would also have more land. The taxes would be $15,000-$20,000 though. My taxes are $12,000 (that was on a 1,800 sq.ft. 3 bedroom Cape; we added on and fear what they will be now)! I've been in some of the local Victorians and they ALL have huge new kitchens - that kitchen is the crappiest, ugliest thing I've ever seen. It makes my tiny galley look impressive. At least mine is original to the house.

    Seriously, that kitchen would drop the value of that house by at least $100,000 - mostly because it is so small for that kind of house. Also, all the old houses I visited on the local house tour a few years ago were totally restored to the proper period, but they ALL had HUGE kitchen or kitchen / great room additions. Seriously, some of the kitchens were bigger than my entire second floor.

    I LOVE the barn-conversion house in Indianapolis, though! It even has the original Mid-Century Modern kitchen! But that could use some retro sprucing up, though.

  • 15 years ago

    99% positive those are KraftMaid Dalton birch cabinets! Chocolate glaze maybe?

  • 15 years ago

    There is no time to start picking that place apart. yes, the only sad lonely cute item is the fh sink. Not that the appliances are all bad but poorly placed. Sad state of affairs!