Picture of the other dresser (though I changed the arrangement a bit) - just looking at coordinating mirrors.

Thinking this one over the tall dresser (I already have this in the perfect size, just in another room right now).

Here is the one for over the long dresser. Both these mirrors would be hung with long side horizontal.

Another option if I wanted to go with silver framed mirror over the long dresser.

This one is also a possibility for over the tall dresser.

Of these I would say none of the above, sorry. They don't relate to the existing furniture very well.

I agree with Pal. Your things are more "country" (modern country?) and darker than the choices offered. I see frames in a similar wood to the furniture or like the iron on your bed - which is what I'd likely choose.

Also, I'd only hang a mirror over the low dresser. For the tall one, perhaps a tabletop mirror, if he wants one, since it's too tall to see anything significant reflected. I'd put a decorative item on the surface if I felt something was needed there for balance.

Ok - I see what you are talking about. So, I'll do framed art above the tall dresser (I have that) and what I had for the mirror temporarily was a thin black iron mirror with beveled edges. I wasn't sure if it was too thin or not, but does match the bed and knobs. I've posted a picture of the style below - though mine is 30"x42". I like the one I've posted, but don't know if they have it in stock anymore.

Ok - I see what you are talking about. So, I'll do framed art above the tall dresser (I have that) and what I had for the mirror temporarily was a thin black iron mirror with beveled edges. I wasn't sure if it was too thin or not, but does match the bed and knobs. I've posted a picture of the style below - though mine is 30"x42". I like the one I've posted, but don't know if they have it in stock anymore.

{{!gwi}}

Sorry, I agree that these mirrors aren't right for your room. Your room has sort of a country/rustic contemporary warmth. It's really lovely. Mirror 1 and 3 are too silver. Mirror 2 is too cottage. I really like the mirror you picture over the wide dresser. It seems to go well with the bed and the lamps.

Oooh, yeah. That last one is gorgeous, but I agree about needing more height. You'll find it!