something like this?

Here is a link that might be useful: Hinkley light French Bronze

I like the look and the price point. Is cast aluminum a durable material for an exterior light? Is hinkley a good brand? The labor involved in this project will be more than the fixture most likely (high COLA plus will likely need to relocate the fixture a bit which will mean patching the stucco and painting) so I want to make sure we buy something that will last for decades.

Thank you!

We have bought custom outdoor lights from a few good sources, but here is a favorite, from our trip to New Orleans last spring. We bought some exterior lights for our beach house from them.

Here is a link that might be useful: nice quality and great looking

This is what I found re: cast aluminum. I know a lot of outdoor furniture is made from cast aluminum, and it looks like an awful lot of outdoor lighting is as well.

Here is a link that might be useful: What is cast aluminum?

I would give Hinkley a call tomorrow. If you do, also ask them about the different "systems". If you click on "System", a number of options drop down. No idea what they mean.

Hubbardton Forge has really high quality pieces, made in the USA, but am not sure if they have a style that would suit you/your home. I'd definitely stay away from anything manufactured in China, and even though HF is "forged" in the usa, I would inquire about the innards. They could easily be from China. I'd check that on any brand you're considering. Frankly, its hard to imagine much being sold these days lasting decades!

Here is a link that might be useful: Hubbardton Forge

Thank you! I did poke around a little more and found the CA company linked below. Local-ish which is nice.

Here is a link that might be useful: Old California lighting company

I am a big Troy lighting fan and like their website. You can see the light installed in most cases, which I find very helpful.

Here is a link that might be useful: Troy lighting exterior lighting

on oldbat's site, I think the Troy would look good on your house if you want to go contemporary, or the Beacon Hill for a more traditional look.

Beacon Hill - I think you will want black, no? I removed your light so we can play :)