Software
Houzz Logo Print
palimpsest

Architect-vernacular MCM-brutalist house with traditional kitchen

15 years ago

This interesting, Historically Certified, house just went on the market. The underlying house is old, the rehab is 1960s-70s.

I posted this in the Home Decorating forum as well but I know that some people do not venture much into both forums.

There is a little more kitchen talk in this post.

This is a fairly typical example of an architect-designed (and probably owned) MCM rehab that was going on in the city when properties were cheap and the neighborhoods were transitioning. The construction is very "homemade": I am not sure any of the windows are more than a sheet of glass put into a stick built frame--they don't look like they open.

The detail under the windows, which screens air conditioners and other vents is stacked sewer pipe. Typically the "conceptual" or the design ideas that drove these projects outpaced both the technology at the time and the budget.

All in all its an interesting house--expensive now @ $600K--and a historical document (which has been recognized) and at the same time its all a little crude and ugly, while being beautiful at the same time.

I am not sure the new kitchen is doing it any favors. Its fairly simple at least but its a little too slick with the granite and the country hutch is kinda strange. An old hutch easily would've been one of the furnishings in this house--but beat up or painted. Maybe this one could be redone in turquoise. The original kitchen would have been like the office cabinets. There is probably a way to get a 2000s kitchen in here, but I am not sure this is it--IKEA would've been better. It almost works but not quite.

The bathroom is crazy:) I would have to leave that one even if I didn't use it. There are two others, probably more conventional in size.


{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

{{!gwi}}

Comments (18)

  • 15 years ago

    Pampliset,

    Wow. The bones are great there, as is the light. I agree with the kitchen assessment, but maybe a color change, new countertops (soapstone) might improve it? It certainly is a house that you could easily revise over time...

  • 15 years ago

    Oh what a neat home and what looks like a charming neighborhood! The kitchen would be such an easy fix with removing some of the upper cabinetry and adding some vertical boxes�and some type of salvaged sculptural metal designed into a little island. And the things you could do with those fireplace walls.
    When I win the lottery I want to buy a place like that.

  • 15 years ago

    You can bleach the wood in the kitchen. Strong alkali and strong acid to neutralize it. (This is dangerous work and requires careful attention.)

    I would gradually change a few things. In each area, the rework was done with an idea in mind. Accepting this and understanding the idea lets one appreciate the work more.

    HTH

  • 15 years ago

    How old is the house itself?

  • 15 years ago

    I agree that houses do have a natural evolution, and the kitchen in this one did preserve the brick wall and the tongue and groove ceiling. I think its the hutch that seems so out of place to me. There is a bit of tension between the relatively "rough" original work and the refinement of the newer work.

    (This is a better fit than the butter yellow, highly carved and corbeled Clive Christian kitchen that I saw shoehorned into a smallish one bedroom apartment in a brown and bronze high rise that was pure "Bob Newhart" show (the psychologist, not the inn owner).

  • 15 years ago

    The underlying house could be 1800s, like the one next door.

  • 15 years ago

    Correction...I meant horizontal cabinets.

  • 15 years ago

    It's a great house with so much potential.

    The feet on the hutch stand out to me, the colonial square ogee style would be less "cute" and more grounded.

  • 15 years ago

    That is just wrong, on so many levels. I see that in MCM homes in my area (Southern city) but here they typically go at it pretty scorched-earth. There is NO MCM remaining save for perhaps a few beams the drywall hangers missed. Around here, if it ain't French, it ain't $*#@.

    I have to think that this was a flip, and that the kitchen hasn't even been used. I don't think that anyone who would have lived in the house and kept the other 90% of it the way it is would have installed that kitchen.

    Somewhere, there is a nice, warm family home in want of a kitchen. Unfortunately, this one lost its way.

  • 15 years ago

    I don't know what is on the other wall of the kitchen, but I'd want to eliminate the counter run with the sink and DW, and replace the solid railing with something either acrylic or wire. Open up the view to the living space and make the kitchen completely traumatic for anyone afraid of heights. But not knowing the rest of the layout, I have no idea if that would even work.

  • 15 years ago

    Actually the current owner, according to the public tax records has been there for seven years.

    Its harder than it sounds for many people to conceive putting in a kitchen in something other than the current mode, so I don't want to be too hard on the current owner. At least its natural wood and not neo-Edwardian. I think its the hutch that really grates and thats not such a big piece of the picture, I guess.

    The original kitchen in this house was probably stick built, not incredibly functional and maybe kinda ugly--I've seen some of the originals and I dunno...There was an iconic Louis Kahn glass and wood box up for auction last year or so, in order to try and save it from being torn down and replace with something neo-palatial, and one of the problems really was the kitchen: Tiny; shallow cabinets; some with sliding thin ply doors, that old 60s track light and 60s appliances. And you almost would have had to do an addition of another glass box in order to get what is currently considered a functional kitchen in the house.

  • 15 years ago

    Okay, the hutch is bad, though functional. If you can't rip it out right away, take off the upper doors, the beadboard and the bun feet, and distress it-glaze it-strip it or something.

    It's a great house. Frightening bathtub, but a great house.

  • 15 years ago

    I actually appreciate Brutalist architecture.

    I don't appreciate remuddling though.

    But if you're going to do it, don't lose your nerve and have an attack of "good taste" right before you sell. You please no one.

    That kitchen reminds me of Cousin Marilyn, the unfortunate blonde "straight" girl in the weird/cool Munster family.

  • 15 years ago

    I seem to have lost a post somewhere. I have a variation on this thread in Home Decorating so I am forgetting what I say where.

    The most successful Brutalists understood what light could do in harsh, rugged spaces. Some of Louis I Kahn's pockmarked buildings are beautiful with the sun shining through the spaces.

    I hope the frightening bathtub stays. A bathroom like this is almost pathognomonic of a crazy-architecty house like this.

    If I were the owner I may not *use* the bathtub (there are two other bathrooms in the house, presumably more conventional)...but I would want to keep it.

  • 15 years ago

    I think this kitchen by Henrybuilt would be a better fit, perhaps. Modern, but organic.
    {{!gwi}}

  • 15 years ago

    Oh, yes! That kitchen has a nice MCM look without being too architect specific. It would be perfect!

    Re the frightening tub, I wasn't suggesting you get rid of it, necessarily. It is a feature and an authentic piece of the vision. But "pathognomonic"? So we're agreed? Architecture is a disease?

  • 15 years ago

    The tub is trisomic icelandic sauna specific. It better be a warm bathroom. The bulbs need a mirror collar to direct the light in a forward beam and to let that warm wood bask in indirect glow.

    Are the thermostats electronic? So many baseboard heaters, so long and strong. Must be to let them be warm, not hot. Is the house cold and poorly insulated?

    Driftwood-bleaching kitchen wood makes it match the bruto surroundings. Then you don't need gnomonic assistance, you just gno what it is.

  • 15 years ago

    What a fascinating house. A Henrybuilt kitchen would be perfect. I must admit to being quite intrigued with that bathtub. Before buying the house we're in now I fell for a house with two original early 1960's bathrooms - one pink, one turqoise. Both were very well designed and installed and were in excellent condition despite their age. Very modern style and modern amenities, lovely to my eye, and perfect for the FLW inspired bungalow they resided in. We very nearly bought that house, but in the end I had to choose neighbourhood over dream house. Anyway, a few weeks after we passed on that MCM masterpiece I was discussing the house with an agent who had shown it a few times. He said the big problem with selling the house was those two "awful" bathroooms, and that the owners should rip them out and then sell. I was truly horrified.

    That house will always be my dream home, and to this day I worry about those bathrooms. I just hope someone with an affinity for MCM design bought that house.

Sponsored
Premier Home Services, Inc
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars19 Reviews
Loudoun County Complete Turn-Key Contracting Solutions