Here's another option I'm tossing around. Still using the same colour palette. Do you think this has better curb appeal? The metal wood long board is becoming very popular right now.

Yes the roof will be shingled shadow black.

I like keeping the entrance the focal point in this drawing. The garage doors seem to take too much prominence in black. Perhaps if the roof is black, the right entrance/door is your metal wood long board, the garage doors in a medium gray that pulls a color from the stone? There rest of the house white? I DO like the window trim in black.

I ordered the garage doors last week and front door has already arrived. Yes siding an off white. I may be able to change the garage door colour, but my colour options are a tad limited where I am. Thank you for your advice I appreciate your input. I find myself going in circles and overthinking it quite a bit.

I get it - but better to try every option in your head. I'm sure whatever you decide will look great once it's all put together. Good luck!

You can find great exterior paint palettes and paint matching services on www.painthunter.com