I like this for your space.

Do you think it might be too large for the space, that seems to be one of the problems with the current fixture?

Hmmm....I think the current light fixture is a bit too ornate.

What about something simpler and linear like this?

There are many choices for you. The one that really doesn't work is polished brass. The stainless appliances would look good with a brushed nickle or pewter look.

How about a couple of these?

We have many lights to go over a kitchen island. I have attached a few but you can also check out our website www.lanternandscroll.com for more lights! Good luck!

Instead of one large fixture, try hanging multiple pendants. Becomes very successful over kitchen islands. Here are a few examples from our showroom that would look great in your space while still keeping that traditional feel yet also adding more richness and color.