Software
Houzz Logo Print
kimberly_barker7942434

Need Help for My Mom's Kitchen - What To Do? What To Do?!?

11 years ago

Hi all! Hoping to get some ideas for the updating of my mom's kitchen. I'm trying to help my parents update their home a bit for their own enjoyment and also because they will probably be selling in the next few years. Money is unfortunately, an object, but they are not afraid to splurge a little and they can afford to when push comes to shove. The biggest problem is that my dad loves loves loves wood and so my mom's dream of a classic white kitchen to go with all of her classic white millwork throughout the house is just that: a dream. So yeah, stuck with cherry at this point in the renovation game. Anyway, with all of that said, the main thing my mom is interested in doing is getting taller uppers with stacked cabinets on top and crown to the ceiling. She has 10 ft ceilings so we were thinking something like 42" uppers with 15" stacked (at least some glass) and then the rest with trim/crown? She will also be changing out the counters, backsplash and the appliances and putting in a new 48" wood mantle hood. You can't see it in the photo but two steps away from the island on the back wall is a huge bank of cabinets and so last year my mom had a fully integrated refrigerator installed there with panels. She always hated where the old refrigerator was and I agreed so moving the fridge was a great idea and has left that particular spot open for ideas? Also, miracle of miracles, while working on that project she found a fantastic (and reasonable) custom cabinet maker through her contractor and they have pulled off the impossible and have matched the cabinetry profiles and color EXACTLY. I mean you cannot even tell not even one bit. So, in the interest of trying to be economical, at this point she will only be replacing the upper cabinets. Knowing my mom she will probably get to the lowers eventually but if she never does,the kitchen will still look fine and a heck of a lot better than it does currently.

With all of that said, just looking at her kitchen myself, I think it needs to lighten up; in person the travertine backsplash and that old granite is really dull and kind of dingy and so if she can't have a white kitchen, she at least wants to lighten everything else up as much as she can. As I mentioned before, the house is full of millwork and it's quite traditional. She would like to keep the traditional feel but throw in a bit of a mix and make it al little more of a transitional mash up (or as much as she can with what she has). So a little bling would not be a bad thing!

So, sorry this is so very long but I don't even know exactly what I am asking other than for your magical, unicorn guidance! I have lurked here forever and I've learned so much for my own projects around here but this is my mom and we can use all of the help we can get for her so any advice, suggestions, guidance would be very much appreciated!

I am going to attach a photo of her kitchen as it looked last year (before the fridge was axed there) and then I will also attach a corny photoshop mock up I was trying to do (please ignore the goofy island legs) just to give you some small idea of what we have discussed.

Thank you for any help!




Comments (23)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Kimberly, what does your dad think of these proposals? Do you believe that your parents will really move in about two years or are they just talking about that as a possible option? If so, have they consulted with a realtor regarding the wisdom of doing these upgrades for their market? Improved lighting (i.e., pendants) could do wonders to lighten it up for now, and perhaps a lighter paint. If this were my house, I would wait and save the money for the next home. I very much doubt that most of the money spent on those upgrades would return that much of the investment back to your parents since their current kitchen is lovely. If the new buyers want this house, I don't believe the need for lighter counters and backsplash would deter them from the purchase. If fact, it may be a deterrent if new buyers want a white kitchen and are reluctant to spend money for a costlier home with updating they don't want.

    I happen to be a senior who sold my home about 5 years ago. At that time, I also thought my kitchen needed "updating" to sell. It had a 30 yr. old kitchen in an upper middle class neighborhood. My realtor discouraged me from doing so. The only changes I made to the house were updates to the lighting, new cabinet knobs, completely repainting the interior, and installing new carpet. My home sold in two days for more than I had originally planned. As it turned out, the remodel on my home for retirement was far more extensive than I had originally anticipated. Following my realtor's advice was a wise decision. Of course, all markets are different. I'm just trying to say that just because one has the money doesn't mean that it's wise to spend it for that purchase.

    However, all of this rambling doesn't answer your original question. Yes, the changes would look really lovely and update the house. Bottom line, your parents have a classy kitchen either way.

    Kimberly thanked texasgal47
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I agree completely to ask a local realtor or two. The costs of remodeling are seldom recouped, but real estate is very local.

    I think the proposed changes are lovely. Alternatively would your father be amenable to a two tone kitchen? Since you want to change the uppers anyway, maybe those could be the white your mother wants.

    Kimberly thanked Nothing Left to Say
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    The walls (and ceiling?) are looking beigy on screen -- how about saving on the 'splurge' of extending the uppers, and go with a lighter coat of paint up there? It may just be me being 'dark kitchen averse', but adding those stacked units (as lovely as they are) extends the mass of cherry upward.

    Kimberly thanked javiwa
  • 11 years ago

    I have to agree with everyone else. I would save the money if they are planning on moving in the next few years. The kitchen is beautiful as it is. You won't recoup the money you put into it.

    Kimberly thanked cpartist
  • 11 years ago

    Hi all, thanks so much for your input and comments. Very much appreciated! I probably should have addressed the real estate situation in my first post so apologies for not including that (didn't want to blind you anymore than I already had)! My parents live in a very upscale neighborhood that was built about 13 years ago, although there are still lots being built on in different areas so there is a mix of older and newer and my parents home is on the older side. The homes here range from the mid-four hundred thousands to over 3 million and counting. There is also a brand new upscale neighborhood that has been built right next door (they actually will be using the roads into my parents subdivision) and new building going on EVERYWHERE so a ton of new construction all over the area with prices that are climbing as we speak. The homes in my parents neighborhood which have sold, have been brought up to date in terms of modern aesthetics whether contemporary or traditional or a mix. The ones that people haven't touched including ones that look very similar to my parent's home because they were built and designed about the same time, sit on the market and don't move. At all. :-( I agree that the kitchen is very nice and in it's day, I'm sure it was perfectly suited to the area, but right now, and with what's happening here all around them, it reads as dated to buyers and unfortunately, if they do decide to sell, it will be slow going if they don't do anything to freshen it up.

    With all of that said, even though there's a possibility they will sell in a few years because they're getting older, my dad says they will have to take him out on a slab feet first and so honestly, a lot of this desire to "update" is for their own enjoyment. My mom (with my dad's support) is intent on doing something so it's not really a question of should they but more of a question of how to make it look updated while keeping that darn cherry wood I guess! LOL Don't get me wrong, they would definitely love to get some return on their investment should they sell so it's not all fun and games, but it is on the game plan to do and now it's just a question of what to do, what finishes to go with that have some hope of lasting for a while and how to economize but make it all look like a million bucks without sweating! :-)

    My mom and I are both real estate junkies and keep up with pretty much everything going on around here that has anything to with the market, so there are definitely some things worth doing that won't be just throwing money away so no worries on that front. More importantly, I know it's what my mom wants and she definitely wants to update. So there's that!

    Anyway, so there you have it. Again, thank you so much for your comments and any suggestions!

  • 11 years ago

    Remind your parents that life is about compromise :)

    Consider changing out the uppers to a creamy white! Leave the base cabinets, island, range hood and oven cabinets the cherry.

    If you do that, I would seriously consider sliding the ovens down to the end and have the cream uppers and pretty glass dividers all together.

    Again, this is ONLY if your parents can really afford to do this. If not, consider driving your mom around to smaller homes with white kitchens! Maybe downsizing will seem like a better idea than remodeling.....it all depends on what is best for their situation.


    Kimberly thanked Lavender Lass
  • 11 years ago

    May I ask what age group your parents are? That too might be a determination.

  • 11 years ago

    They are in their early seventies. :-)

  • 11 years ago

    I like the before picture MUCH better!

    Kimberly thanked Sherry8aNorthAL
  • 11 years ago

    One additional note: The cherry cabinets are a bit lighter than they appear here...more of a natural color and not very dark red. Just thought that may help! Thanks again.

  • 11 years ago

    I do like your proposed changes. The only thing that I personally would prefer is a more streamlined (non-wood) hood, but it sounds like your mom likes the one you propose.
    I'd also put a built-in microwave in that empty fridge spot and perhaps a coffee station rather than the solid wood cabinets/drawers there, maybe even some open shelves for cookbooks.


    Traditional Kitchen · More Info
    Arcadia Kitchen Remodel · More Info
    Space for serving! · More Info


  • 11 years ago

    I agree with Javiwa and Sherry_7bAL, that is a LOT of dark wood in the second photo and to me, the light backsplash and counters clash with the warm wood. I just put in natural cherry base cabinets last year with painted wall cabinets, cherry is still a popular choice for higher end homes that don't want the all white/gray/marble kitchen, which in my opinion will be a dated look shortly. Now that the market is recovering in many areas and builders are back at it, the all white/grey kitchen is all the rage in the mid-priced cookie cutter homes, so designers will have to come up with a new look to convince everyone they need to update. It doesn't sound like your parents plan on moving, so this investment is purely for your mother's benefit, but I don't think she is going to get the look and feel she wants with dark cabinets to the ceiling, even if you add glass, light counters and light backsplash. If your mom is amenable to a two tone kitchen, I suggest trying to get your dad to compromise on the upper cabinets. He would still have his beloved wood in the base cabinets and your mom would get the lighter feel she is going for with painted wall cabinets.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    ...maybe show your dad some photos w/ white uppers and cherry lowers (if that's a compromise your mom would be happy with). Sometimes, people just can't (or haven't had the opportunity to) picture anything different in their minds.

  • 11 years ago

    The 15-20K that it would take to do what you are suggesting would be better deducted off of the asking price IF it comes time to sell. The existing kitchen is NOT ''outdated''. So, it's not the current popular fad. So what? It's modern, with a beautiful wood close to it's natural tone, and not overly ornamented. It's on the cusp of the next trend--which will be a backlash against white shaker and a move to zen modern. Take off the crown, and it's just about there.

  • 11 years ago

    I agree with everything Sophie said. I would simply add more lighting and enjoy those lovely cherry cabinets.

  • 11 years ago

    This is a beautiful kitchen as it is. I don't think the proposed marble fits with the cherry and prefer the granite that is currently there! If you want to brighten up the room, change the paint color add some bright accessories!!!! Seems very wasteful to me to rip out perfectly good materials in a fairly new kitchen for the sake of a new trend. JMHO.


  • 11 years ago

    Swapping the pulls and knobs for something sparkly... Polished nickel would be nice... May add a surprising amount of light to the kitchen. Esp if you put pulls on the uppers. (More sparkle.)


    If that's not enough, a lighter counter (maybe a quartzite? I feel like I have seen them.with streaks that would complement the cherry) and a new backsplash should be plenty. With a new undermount sink and a high arc ("modern") faucet. It would have a lot of the key "updated" features but leave those gorgeous cabs alone.

  • 11 years ago

    I love white marble and stained wood together. I do have two suggestions:

    1) I think your backsplash cannot also be white marble. You need a backsplash that marries the white stone and the dark wood. Perhaps pull a color from the marble veining (a taupe?) and make that the backsplash color. It'll obviously match the marble because it's the same as some of the veining, and the darker, warmer tone will also relate to the dark wood.

    2) There are SO MANY dark tall cabinets in the mock-up that it feels overwhelming and looming. It also makes everything at eye level that dark wood your mom doesn't prefer, and is just kind of boring? Kitchens these days are really starting to mix it up in terms of having lots of interesting variation in the cabinets -- glass, contrasting paint, contrasting materials, etc. It might be a good way to sell your dad on the idea of not everything's being cherry if you say that modernizing requires a little more interest.

    Another tactic would be to just have fewer uppers. Go for some open wall space with light, bright artwork that your mom likes. Or if this is an exterior wall, add windows. Consider a range hood that is made of a contrasting material or color. Your dad still gets all cherry cabinets, and your mom doesn't get stuck with an all-cherry kitchen.

  • 11 years ago

    Hi everyone, thank you for all of the comments. I do appreciate everything that has been written and all of the suggestions and points brought up. The thing is, my mom and dad have worked hard their whole lives and if this is something they want to do, I am in no position to tell them otherwise and wouldn't dream of doing so. My mom hates the short cabinets (not the cherry) and as this is her dream house otherwise, she is not going to budge on the idea of updating -- especially when she would prefer to stay in this home as long as possible rather than buy new. I guess I don't see it as wasteful if this is something she wants and again, I have to reiterate that when they eventually do go to sell, being a little fresher will not exactly hurt them; on the contrary around here in this particular market.

    As for the goofy photoshop I posted, none of those things were my suggestions or even set in stone...we were just playing around with ideas and especially wanting to look at the stacked cabinets. So not really trying to be trendy with the marble etc., just grabbed a lighter counter to use for the photo because I know my mom intends to lighten things up on the counters and backsplash. And again, the cabinets in the photos are darker looking than they are in real life so I'm afraid they are not the best representation.

    I have to admit I am kind of finding it amusing everyone on a decorating/remodeling site is advising against remodeling this kitchen even when the owner wants to, but I do understand your reservations and in many other cases, I would totally agree with you. Real estate wise, I've lived in areas where it didn't matter at all and I've lived in areas where it does and unfortunately (or fortunately if you actually enjoy the process), the latter is the soup of the day around here. I'm in the midst of a master bath remodel right now myself and it's downright addictive so I get why my mom is into the idea, though. Anyway, again, thank you very much! I will answer some comments below:


    Nosoccermom - "I do like your proposed changes. The only thing that I personally would prefer is a more streamlined (non-wood) hood, but it sounds like your mom likes the one you propose.
    I'd also put a built-in microwave in that empty fridge spot and perhaps a coffee station rather than the solid wood cabinets/drawers there, maybe even some open shelves for cookbooks."

    I actually would prefer it if she went with a metal range hood myself and she is actually thinking about going that way. Everything is still very much up in the air...she had just always thought she would like a wood mantle hood but seeing as she wants to mix the traditional with a touch of modern, some more sparkle would be a great idea. As for the microwave, it's actually in a drawer on the island but that spot by the fridge, she's been thinking about tall glass cabinets or open shelves there and some small drawers underneath which are actually not drawers but a flip up area for coffee etc. Hard to describe and my picture wasn't at all what she had in mind. Thank you for your suggestions!


    Fishymom and Javivwa, the two tone white and cherry is a non-starter not only because of my dad, but my mom is not a fan. I've seen some pretty versions of it though so I know what you're talking about and that's definitely a good option. I do think she was considering a creamy white island possibly but again, just in the talking stage. Thanks again!


    Sophie, in this particular area, unfortunately this kitchen is considered outdated...especially the short cabinets. Even the new cheap houses here have tall cabs so they're pretty much expected in the price range this home would be at. My mom is not into fads. In fact, she generally goes the opposite direction, so she's not really wanting to remodel to keep up with the latest trend. Again, it's both for her enjoyment while she lives in the home and when she does sell, the updates will not hurt. They never do unless they've gone horribly wrong, generally speaking. :-) Thank you for the suggestion!


    Kimberly, my mom is about the least wasteful person on the planet and she has done more for people in her lifetime than I will ever be able to do, so if she wants to remodel her kitchen, I don't think she's being wasteful; I think she's finally doing something for herself which I wholeheartedly applaud. She's certainly not doing it to follow a trend, she's doing it because she wants to and I don't see an issue with that. I'm sorry that you do, though. Thank you anyway.


    Elizard, yes, definitely all new hardware and lights etc. Jewelry is always important to a girl:-) And quartzite has actually been talked about so definitely an option, thank you!


    Jillius, thank you for the comments! Not sure if you saw up above but the cabinets are not that dark in real life. I understand what you mean about looming though and with the 10 ft ceilings and lighted glass as well as the cabinets that aren't that dark, it won't be quite as dismal as it might appear. I love the idea of mixing up a new material for the hood and I am definitely hoping she trends that way in the end. I really think that would help on a lot of different counts. As for the backsplash, that was just a mock up to use something lighter so definitely not the end choice or anything. I think you bring up a good point with that, however i know my mom is pretty set on keeping it all fairly light so we'll just have to see what kind of counter material she settles on and go from there I suppose.


    Anyway, thanks again everyone! This is the best place and I really do appreciate the time you've all taken.

  • 11 years ago

    If your Mom is anything like my Mom was, there is no way they are moving anytime soon so if updating will make your Mom happy, I say go for it. I thought by your first comment you expected them to move in a couple of years. Let them enjoy what works for them for as long as they desire. I'm so glad my Mom got to stay in her home until almost the end. :)

  • 11 years ago

    I'd say to go for it.

    Also, I'd seriously look into Aging in Place
    aging-in-place-home-ideas/kitchen/

    NAHB aging in place



  • 11 years ago

    I, too, had the impression they were moving soon. I agree that they should do what they want if they plan to stay there, and yes to aging-in-place design. If you could post the current kitchen layout with dimensions and the floorplan for the entire floor or, at least, adjacent rooms, I'm sure you will get a lot of good suggestions.

    I hope they will donate any cabinets they tear out to a Habitat Re-Store so someone else can enjoy those beautiful cabinets.