Pretty much any countertop that looks beautiful to you. Everything matches white subway tile. I recommend you find a countertop fabricator who will let you visit their suppliers and see the full slabs of granite, marble, and quartz. Find something that looks beautiful to you. There is really no good answer to your question since you're the one who will live there. Even if I suggested something I loved, it might not be your taste at all. That said, here are a few colors that might look nice.

Thank you, Antonella, for your thorough analysis of Danby marble! I've been a proponent of Danby marble for quite some time now--it's really beautiful and so dense that I have not one stain on my countertops after nine months of continued use. It was explained at one of the stone yards that the reason for the low absorption rate of Danby is due to the stone being in the underground quarry, and therefore not subjected to the ravages of weather (rain, snow, sunlight, etc.) that other marbles are battered with. I agree that in order to select any material you need to educate yourself, and then go with the one that fits your lifestyle the best. No one material is right for everyone. That being said, in the New York metro area where I live, the stone yards can't keep the Danby slabs in stock--they are so popular that they're sold as soon as they come in. I was lucky, I happened to visit ABC Stone in Westbury, NY, just as they received a shipment of 20 slabs, and got to select the 2 I like best!

If you post a picture it will be easier to answer your question:)

Katie - I’m not sure if you are asking me or someone else...but we did go with an Italian Carrera Marble. I attached pics of the now done space. Quartz technology isn’t there yet. Everything we looked at for marble imitation quartz was just that.....an imitation. It was too dotted or gray. But I will say these are pics of our marble 6 mos later. Still no stains or etching. I seal it every other month to be safe, but it’s a quick thing to do. I still love love love it and I don’t regret it AT ALL!!! ❤️