Well, I guess your white and gray are neutral enough to support most any colors, but I would have gone for a cool gray (one of the lightest tones from your counter) and a number of other colors before I got to coral. What color is your flooring?

Can't disregard the color of your vanity which is a creamy white.

I stated above that I would paint the cabinets white. But, I really don't want gray or white walls in my bathroom. This article is a few years old, but it resonates with me. An excerpt that describes what I'm trying to achieve:

"You want colors that are flattering to the skin
— whatever you put on the wall will be the color reflected in your
(face's) shadows," says Jarrett Hedborg, whose celebrity clients include
Jim Carrey, Bette Midler and Jeff Bridges. "I'll never do a green
bathroom because cool tones tend to be unflattering and make you look
older. Yellow is another no-no, especially if you're applying makeup,
because it distorts your skin tone and makes you look jaundiced."

According to Jarrett, most skin tones are pink, so you want warm
tones that will pick up that color — such as peach and rose — and create
warm shadows."

Here's the link http://www.hgtv.com/design/rooms/bathrooms/discover-the-latest-bathroom-color-trends

If you put your make up on in a room with coral tones, it will make your skin look warmer and pinker than it is in real life. Then when you go out your make up will not have enough color. Keep your bright tones confined to your towels and shower curtains.

Coral and grey can be pretty together. I'd look for something a little more muted like this Priceless Coral by Behr.

Unfortunately, the computer never gives accurate colors so samples are the only way to really tell what you're going to get. Good luck with your project!

katinparadise, I like your suggestion. I tried to find a similar color in the S-W visualizer and came up with this. It may not be the final color choice, but I think that you pointed me in the direction I wanted to go. And, re-painting the walls is the cheapest part of the bathroom if I make a mistake.

Consider painting the walls a light gray or a spa-like aqua blue and install framed painted mirrors.

Lighted mirrors could provide proper lighting for makeup also.

SW Charisma with Elle Gray is a good combination.

GREY

It's only paint-right? I'm sure you'll find the perfect color. Please post pics of your results!

I really appreciate all the comments and suggestions, but I'm puzzled by all the gray and white suggestions. You can find plenty of bathrooms with color right here on Houzz like these http://www.houzz.com/orange-bathroom. When I asked for other color suggestions, I meant coral/orange/pink etc. I'm not a sophisticated person and it's an old house. The spa look would not fit in here. I want a bathroom that is colorful and cheerful. I've already bought the mirrors and lights and decided to paint the cabinets white, so the wall color is the only decision that's left.

I painted my guest bath in Sherwin-Williams Tidewater. I had the ceiling and walls above the white subway painted in that color; trim work is a creamy white. It works so well with grey (I used the same color in my powder room that has a black and grey marble floor), too. Since I'm using the guest bath while my master suite is being built, I've found the color to be very flattering. My bath has morning sunlight. I have sconces with shades on either side of the medicine cabinet.

@suzyq53, I like that color. What is it?

I would go with a color that makes your bathroom look better rather than someone's skin. On a daily basis you will spend more time observing the room rather than what is in the mirror.

With the colors you currently have, a cool gray will work great! You can get subtler grays mixed with a blue or green hue and that will really give you a spa-like bathroom.

Its BM Coral Gables. Not too orange, not too pink. Pretty in semi-gloss for the bath.

I really wanted coral. I liked it a lot, but when it came to choosing the exact color, nothing worked. They all looked dirty next to the granite. After 2 hours in Sherwin-Williams today, I went home and looked through all the paint chips I've collected. And, I found a boring light gray that looked perfect - Olympic Gray Beard. I got a sample and here are the results. It's so boring yet so perfect. Maybe I can get coral or rose to work in the other bath. I plan to take my paint sample to S-W tomorrow to have them match the color. I imagine most of you are wondering why it took me so long to get here, but I had to go through this process. I will be much happier with gray knowing that I tried other colors first.

It will be so fun filling the room with coral accents!! You will appreciate the delicate wall color.

I love coral myself so I understand how much you wanted to use it. If your other bathroom is neutral enough, it could work in there. Hopefully you can find some fun accessories to brighten it up and you'll come to love it!