Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_129235

ahhh the auction is ending soon! Flatware

10 years ago

I really do need flatware. I had received a set of 8 or 10 from my first marriage about 15 years ago and somehow they vanish. I am down to barely a set of 4. My kids FIGHT over this one spoon I had from my mother. Nothing fancy they just love it. Anyway I found a service for 8 (5 pieces each) that is unused on ebay. It is stainless steel and made in the late 80's early 90's. I can't figure out how much to pay and I was just outbid! It is made by dansk if that helps.


How much per place set would you pay?

I have not been watching it long so I have no idea if they get it, but it seems to be going for about $7-8 a piece for replacements.

It is a nice weight. I don't like sets that are too light.

Comments (20)

  • 10 years ago

    If I had an opportunity to buy UNUSED a stainless set of my daily pattern from the 1980's, I would pay much more than I could buy new today, because today's is made much cheaply. If you want it, and would be willing to pay Replacement dot com prices, then just bid 35-40 times 8, or 260-320. I wouldn't bid until the final few seconds of the auction, though. If it's the set I think, individual pieces are pricey on eBay, so the other buyer may be looking to cannibalize the set, which means he/she may be willing to go higher.

    Boopadaboo thanked deeinohio
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Make sure it's 18/10 stainless steel.

    If you're outbid or change your mind, a really great place to buy flatware is on restaurant supply sites. Tons of patterns. You can buy what you need, not sets, per se. And they're heavy because of the heavy wear flatware goes through in restaurants.

    I get mine from here


    Boopadaboo thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    I want this specific pattern though Tib. My kids LOVe it for some reason. I have no idea why I have one piece!


    It is 18/8 I have no idea what that means.


    I was thinking the same thing dee.

  • 10 years ago

    I've had another Dansk pattern as my everyday flatware for over 30 years. Still love it. Pay what you can afford. It will certainly last a long time.

    Boopadaboo thanked nhbaskets
  • 10 years ago

    Boop, it is 18/10. Your listing is the only one that shows 18/8.

    Boopadaboo thanked deeinohio
  • 10 years ago

    On the left, are options for your search ---- If you find "completed" and check it - you'll find past auctions - price in green means it sold for that price.

    Boopadaboo thanked Ziemia
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Dansk is a good quality and if 18/8, that was the "good stuff" years ago. Mow the 18/10 if the better stuff but bith are good quality. The numbers refer to the amount of chromium and nickel in the steel -- the second number being the nickel content and higher is better. The higher nickel content gives a shine or lustre and gives the steel better rust resistence. If you buy 18/0, you could have trouble with dulling, spotting and rusting and I wouldn't expect it to last as long. Quality stainless can last a lifetime, so paying more will pay of in the long run.

    As far as pricing, the per piece price on Replacements is the highest price reference you would be likely to find. They probably pay 1/4 to 1/3 of that -- and they might even be buying some of what you see on ebay for desired items. And a set price should be less than the sum of the individual pieces, so it would seem that $320 would be a top mark. But that's only a guide if it is a must have. Are you willing to pay top dollar for the set -- and will it be as special if you have a full set (in other words, do the kids love the design or just that it was their grandmother's and is the only one so THAT spoon is special?).

    The other thing I would consider is what you would pay for a full set and if this is worth a similar amount or more to you. That is entirely personal.

    As far as the weight and quality of stainelss bought now, I can tell you that my first stainless is 18/8 - the best I saw and it's still around. I bought stainless for my son when he moved into an apartment, and based on my experience with what I bought right out of college, I wanted to get something of decent quality. I gave him some choices and he picked Oneida Moda. It is 18/10 and heavier than my Gorham from years ago -- great shine, incredible weight and he loves it. Macy's has a set on sale now, a serice for 12 plus serving set, for $179.99, less 15% ($152.99) and you get $30 in Macy's Money to spend on a future purchase -- net cost of $123 for a service for 12. Your service would be 2/3 of that, so you could get a great quality set brand new and be able to add to it for around $80-100.

    All that said, do you want to be talked into or out of bidding more? ;-)

    Boopadaboo thanked lascatx
  • 10 years ago

    You all are the best. I let it go. It went too high I think. I will probably just get a couple of the spoons for now and Hope I can scrounge up enough Forks and knives for Christmas day and then figure out what to do for a set for the house!

  • 10 years ago

    Lascatz, I really liked that Oneida set you found. How long ago did you buy that for your son?

    We bought a very good quality Oneida about 35 years ago and about 10 years ago I was able to add some new pieces at an expensive, but reasonable price. I lost some more over the last 10 years. Where they go, I do not know!

    Anyway, I looked everywhere and it cost me as much for 4 forks (used) as it did for my original 2 sets! I ended up on ebay and bought 4 matching, but slightly longer new forks for the same price as the regular used dinner forks. I wish I'd seen the set you bought for your son!

  • 10 years ago

    Dansk was top quality stainless, made in Sweden. For a price comparison, look at the heavy stuff from Pottery Barn or East Elm, and in department stores.

  • 10 years ago

    I've looked further into the Oneida set Lascatz mentioned and 3 out of 22 people on BB complained the knives are rusting. How can you avoid that, other than buying the really old stainless?

  • 10 years ago

    Was your pattern the "Thebe" that just sold? You can do a search for Dansk Thebe and the "follow" that search. That way you can keep up with what is selling. The old stuff is much better than the new. I like the Buy-It -Now better than bidding. If you bid, decide what is the max you would spend and bid that as soon as you can. E-Bay will only bid enough to keep you on top and no one can see your max bid. Just don't get caught up in a bidding war and pay more than you want to. Don't forget to check the shipping costs before bidding and don't bid on two listings at one time (you might win both).

    Boopadaboo thanked Sherry8aNorthAL
  • 10 years ago

    Karen, I bought the Onieda set for my son about 4 years ago and three of those years it was abused by 3 roommates -- which made me both understand why most college kids get discards or Walmart quality stuff and made me glad the set I got him was good enough to hold up and still look great. I can't say that for a things we left behind or threw out rather than trying to clean up enough to try to salvage them.

    There were a couple of missing pieces. I think I bought one place setting, a couple of spoons and added some steak knives to match -- all new from BB&B. The original set looked the same as the new stuff. Makes me really wonder about the reviews that mention rusting. If you put stainless in a DW and it is touching something that is rusting, you can get rust on it, which is different from the flatware itself rusting. I don't know what to say other than I obviously didn't have ay hesitation filling in his missing pieces and adding the steak knives after I'd seen what the original set looked like after 3 years.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks Lascatx. I've been looking for my daughter and I just checked Dansk. They are made in Vietnam I believe. Some people claim that the stuff made in China is iffy in that sometimes recycled metals are used. Maybe some batches are Okay?

    I don't believe any of the knife blades are 18/10 on any of the stainless.

  • 10 years ago

    I have learned to take online reviews with a grain of salt. I have seen a number
    that are clearly for a different product by the same or sometimes a different maker. If you get an isolated one or two comments, I don't worry about them at all if there are a decent number of good reviews. You really just have to evaluate the degree negativity and whetehr it is a grneral patern. I saw some negative comments on every pattern I remember looking at with hm. Macy's has a pretty good return policy, if that makes it worth trying.

    Boopadaboo thanked lascatx
  • 10 years ago

    BTW, DS flew in tonight and mentioned his flatware -- he siad if someone was going to break into his apartment nad make off with something they could carry, it would probably be his flatware. LOL Tells you he thinks a lot of it still. I tolkd home I'd been talking about it and about the reviews that said knived rusted, Not only did he laugh whn I mentioned roommate abuse, he said that he'd left a knife standing in a glass of water a few times. That was the good treatment -- and he doesn't have any rusting.

    Boopadaboo thanked lascatx
  • 10 years ago

    Had another thought. This is the time of year (as you are very aware) of folks getting ready for the holidays. Prices might moderate some after. It is something important - and perhaps if you get more settings, that will bring you lots of satisfaction for a very long time.

  • 10 years ago

    For resale, I think you might be right. Not only are people getting ready for entertaining, but filling in lost or added pieces are great gifts for folks who are collecting. For new, I think this and Mother's Day/wedding season are the two times they tend to have good sales, especially on sets.

  • 10 years ago

    After reading the thread about redecorating, I thought I get tired of things. When I saw this thread I remembered I've never tired of the few pieces I still have left of my almost fifty years old Oneida Classic Shell flatware. I checked on eBay for my pattern and found at a reasonable price enough to make a complete service for eight of the heirloom cube. I find it quite funny I am so excited to have again my old Oneida flatware. This pattern is also sentimental for me, my stepmother bought it for me. I will mix my new eBay stuff in and feel that it was all from her. Thank you OP for this!