Software
Houzz Logo Print
toxcrusadr

Water Leak Under Slab on Grade House

9 years ago

How does one fix a buried leaky water pipe UNDER the house?

My parents' house in New Mexico was built in '78 and is slab on grade. I was there to see neighboring houses built and I know they ran piping (and even HVAC) in trenches and then poured the slabs. My sister says there is a spike in the water bill and she can hear water running when she's in one of the bathrooms and everything is turned off. The soil is sandy/gravelly and drains extremely well so there is no sign of it outside the house. The leak could easily be 10 ft or more from the outside walls of the house. There was a similar leak several years ago but it turned out to be the pipe feeding the underground valve for the front yard sprinklers, which was located a foot or two outside the house. Easy to dig up and repair.

I'm afraid a plumber is going to tell us we need to tear up the bathroom floor tile and remove the tub and cut the concrete and dig a hole. The one redeeming thing is that it's a warm climate and the pipes probably aren't as deep as the ones here in MO. I sure am liking my Midwestern walkout ranch about now, with all the piping in the basement ceiling, easily accessible by pulling a few suspended ceiling panels. :-D

Any thoughts what to look for or what we might be in for?

Comments (17)

  • 9 years ago

    Been there. Done that. Only it was the kitchen floor we tore up.

    If freezing isn't an issue, the plumber may be able to reroute the plumbing through the attic.

  • 9 years ago

    This may not be available in your location but there is a process to insert a liner inside the pipe: http://flow-liner.com/water-lining.html?gclid=CPr_v7Cf39QCFdSXfgodSPwGmw

  • 9 years ago

    The first thing I would do is try to isolate the location of the leak -- just to rule out leaky toilets, irrigation, etc.

    Do you have PEX or copper pipe?

    If it is indeed a leak under the slab, the issue I have is what caused it. Meaning - is this a one-off problem or is this a systemic problem (such as dezincification of brass fittings on PEX pipe, or thinwall copper at the end of its lifespan).

    If it's a systemic problem, I'd go for a replumb through the attic.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I'm 90% sure it's copper pipe, at least that's what comes up to all the fixtures. Would not be surprised if it is deteriorating, that's nearly 40 years. Although the soil is alkaline so I would have thought it would not be corrosive.

    How can you isolate the location? Listen with a stethoscope on the floor?

    "Attic" is not what I'd call it...flat roof with maybe 12-16" between ceiling and roof, so square trusses, stuffed with insulation batts.

    "Replumb", would this involve the entire house? Yikes. Just spent nearly $30k to have the roof replaced, slopes installed to prevent water pooling, and had to move gas lines off the roof. Would have been a perfect time to run new piping when the roof sheathing was off. Dangit.

    Ugh, why couldn't they just put it right above the ceiling to begin with? Leaks would ruin the drywall but at least you could get to it quickly and without tearing up concrete.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    The first thing I would do tox is see if there's a stop valve on main just before it go's under slab. If there is a stop,chances are good that it's a *%##@$ gate valve that either doesn't cut off 100% or doesn't move at all. At any rate I'd turn water off right at slab even if it mean's installing a new ball valve then look for meter movement. 50-50 chance the leak is between meter and slab. If there's yard facuets downstream from indoor plumbing I'd do some digging and investigating of those also. Hearing it indoors means nothing,I can hear my outdoor yard facuets well enough they sometimes remind me to turn them off when I go to bed. There are services that specialize in locating slab leaks for plumbers so the know where to bust slab or tunnel under. Good luck,sound's like you have a full summer with the ceiling and all to go along with this issue.

  • 9 years ago

    I tend to agree with you Bruce until I remember getting a call Chriatmas Eve morning for a water leak comeing from atic in Dallas. It was an old home that had water lines installed in atic when remodled. One those rare times temperature dropped to low teens in that part of the country. If occupants can handle a shut off and drain,overhead isn't a bad option. I'm wondering if Pex could be snaked through the limited space in the subject home.

  • 9 years ago

    I get a spike every year about now. Are you sure it's leaking? Turn off the faucets and look at the water meter. There's probably something in there that spins or wiggles to indicate even small amounts of flow. If that spinner is sitting still, then no leak.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    You can bet that the rest of the pipe is shot if one area is. I would first get the city in-ground shut off valve turned off by the city. Then I would discuss with them the process of replacing the shut off valve and all of the supply line to the house. Most likely reroute a different way into the house than under the slab.

  • 9 years ago

    Vith said;

    "#1.You can bet that the rest of the pipe is shot if one area is.#2. I would first get the city in-ground shut off valve turned off by the city.#3. Then I would discuss with them the process of replacing the shut off valve and all of the supply line to the house. #4 Most likely reroute a different way into the house than under the slab."

    Vith what are you trying to do?. #1. We don't even know where the leak is,much less what caused it. #2. in every case I've seen the city cut off is "BEFORE THE METER". #3.Why should tox become involved with how public utilities handle replacement of their system? And when did it become the city's responsibility to replace service line on private property? #4 fall's under the cart before horses category. I'm sorry but this man is faced with enough without us hatching issues that are simply unreasonable..

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    The water line on your property is yours, not the city's. The meter in your house is theirs but the water line is not until you hit city property. So the water line under the house is the homeowners. The in ground shutoff is theirs (usually on their property either the sidewalk or the street), but if im going to trench a new line it would be nice to have a new shut off, but not completely necessary if not an option the city will do.

  • 9 years ago

    I saw that 'pipe liner' product used on an episode of This Old House on a home in New Orleans. It was a drain pipe under a slab. Though the process is not cheap, it compares favorably with trenching and slab busting. It can also be used on 1/2" copper lines in walls or underground.

  • 9 years ago

    OP:

    If you are still dealing with this issue - please look again at my original post.

    You need to understand if this is a system wide issue. If it is system wide, meaning that the plumbing is at the end of its life, you need to re-plumb and the only practical way of doing that is through the attic and side walls. Your flat roof will make this much more difficult. The good news is you can do it with PEX and fish some of the lines into place.

    You can consider pipe lining -- but if you have copper pipe that has reached end of life - I'd question how long of a fix that would be. It would be something to ask about if you go that direction.

    Copper plumbing has a lifespan of 50-70 years so 40 years is a little short if it was properly installed unless it was thinwall copper. Ground chemistry, water chemistry, even electrical currents, etc can shorten the lifespan.

    You may be able to see what type of copper -- K, L or M -- was installed if you can find a length of expose pipe with the printing on it. If it's type M - that's the thinnest type and I'd say you are at the end of life.


  • 9 years ago

    Pardon the pun,lineing the network of 1/2" pipe beneath slab is a pipe dream. Even lineing sewer pipe is possible only if there is no branch between start and finish points of liner. Making it fartur difficult (think impossible) is turning short radius 90* turns in pipe. Then there's the fact that every single loop above slab would have to be un-soldered. It isn't going to happen.

  • PRO
    last month

    A leak detection specialist would find the exact spot before anyone tears up tile. The modern methods: acoustic listening (a sensitive ground microphone picks up the leak hiss under the slab), tracer gas (a harmless gas is pumped into the line, then sniffed at the surface to mark the spot), and thermal imaging for hot water lines. Pinpointing first means one small cut instead of guessing across the whole bathroom.

    Once the spot is known, the options are a spot repair through the slab, or rerouting that line through walls or ceiling and abandoning the buried pipe. With a 1978 copper system, a reroute is often the smarter money, because the rest of that pipe is the same age and the next leak is just a matter of time.

    One more thing: check the homeowners insurance. Many policies cover the cost of opening the slab to reach the leak, just not the pipe repair itself.

    John Anthony, ProLine Leak Fix Pros, Lynnwood WA

  • last month
    last modified: 29 days ago

    Don’t start by tearing up the bathroom. A good plumber should be able to isolate the leak first with a pressure test and leak detection equipment. If the line is buried under the slab, rerouting the water line through the attic or walls is often much less destructive than breaking concrete and tile. I’d get a leak detection specialist to locate it and then compare the cost of a reroute versus slab access.

  • PRO
    25 days ago

    Before anyone breaks concrete, the single most valuable step is proper leak detection. A specialist with acoustic listening equipment and pressure-testing gear can usually pinpoint the leak within a few feet, which turns a scary unknown into a defined repair. Turn off all fixtures, watch the water meter for movement, and isolate the hot line from the cold - that alone narrows things down a lot.

    From there you generally have three options. A spot repair means jackhammering the slab at the leak point - cheapest when the rest of the pipe is sound, but disruptive to flooring. Rerouting the line overhead or through walls avoids the slab entirely and is often faster, though it changes the plumbing layout. A partial or full repipe makes sense when the pipe is aging out - copper from the 70s with one pinhole leak often means more are coming, since the same water chemistry affects the whole run.

    Get at least two or three quotes, ask each plumber why they recommend their method, and check whether your homeowners insurance covers the access work (breaking the slab) even if it does not cover the pipe itself. This overview of pipe repair and repiping options explains when rerouting beats breaking concrete: https://plumbingyumaaz.com/pipe-repair-repiping-yuma/