I always like fireplace screens, but I think it could use a larger on than the two you picture. Maybe try finding a taller, hinged screen to fill the space up a bit more!

Very pretty, i like the first one...

Neither is tall enough, though the first is better. Needs to be taller and wider. Looks ok without any. But if you want more detail then find another one. Good luck!

Here's a picture of a bigger hinged screen. I think the single panel screen might be more formal?(I do want formal). I probably need to just keep looking, any suggestions on places to find fireplace screens? We are in Houston, there is a lot of places to shop, but not finding many screens. Thanks so much!

I think a single is better too. Look up iron fire screens online, I'm sure you'll find something you like.

I vote for the first screen. Your second one seems too small.

Flat Fireplace Screens- Should overlap the opening by 1” (or up to 4”) on top and sides. Folding Fireplace Screens should be 3-4” taller than the fireplace opening and 10-12” wider. This will ensure that your screen stands on it’s own. The first fireplace screen is my choice, it works very nice with everything in your room.

No. I am typically a fan of fireplace screens, however your fireplace is beautiful without it.

If this is a real wood burning fireplace a spark guard is a good option, it will really protect your wood floors. I have four wood burning fireplaces and use them on all. I have the type on the second picture and have replaced the ugly handles with something more to my liking. You don't have to worry about leaving the fireplace unattended at night with a spark guard. You can get them online and they come in different sizes.

Without.

Perhaps, a collection of candles of varying heights (possibly in a nice candle holder) in the firebox would be way to decorate the fireplace. Since your firebox is raised off the hearth, you might have a hard time finding a screen that will cover the opening properly. Unless you will actually use your fireplace and you have small kids, then a screen is not necessary.

I heard from many of you that it would look good without a screen. I'm going to experiment with some of your great ideas- birch wood, candles etc and see what looks best. The fireplace has glass doors that are shut, so there really isn't a need for a screen, it would have only been for decoration purposes. I will post an update once I complete the project. Thanks again, I know I can always count on you all for the best ideas!!

None of those screens work. The first two are too frilly and the larger folding one doesn't fit either. Have one made. Taller and narrower than the last one. But it looks best without one.

Oh! If it has glass doors that are shut, no need for a screen, it would look contrived. Definitely birch logs (or any logs for that matter), candles are for non-working fireplaces, and really overused.

What material did you use around fire box (tile, marble, etc)? I like it

If it is a clear glass door, there are inserts to give the look of a screen.

stober- it is marble. White and it has some veins running through, which are hard to see.

Glass doors -- no screen.

There are some great looking screens on this website. Since this is for decorative purposes only, consider other decorative items that minimize the black opening and that can be put aside when the fireplace is in use and still look good in the room... painted mural screen, free standing panels, etc..

http://www.horchow.com/Golden-Branch-Fireplace-Screen/cprod87620071/p.prod?eVar4=You%20May%20Also%20Like

Both are too small but the firsts one is better

First one

In cases like yours with a raised in the wall fireplace, sometimes a fireplace glass door or screen door is the most appropriate application.

Here's an example we have created that shows how a well designed custom fireplace screen door that matches your mantel might look:

Try our FREE Fireplace Design Service where if you send us pictures of your fireplace and we will show you how various screens and doors will look so you don't have to buy them first.

I have the same dilemma and after seeing your pictures I like the fireplace with screen. Thanks for helping me decide.

If you intend to use the fireplace...ever...you will need a screen which is larger in both dimensions than the firebox opening so that no sparks or embers can pop out of the fireplace. Even if you don’t plan to use the fireplace, anything smaller than the opening
will look odd.