I'd go with a countertop that mimics the look of Calacatta Gold marble, since your cabinets and wall colors are warm neutrals.

Pick an engineered quartz or compact surface vs. Corian. Dekton makes a nice one called Entzo:

It's neither like Quartz nor like Corian. It's called an ultra-compact surface and competes with Neolith. I haven't yet used it for a project, but I do know you have to make certain the fabricator is certified to work with this material. One thing to note: the "veining" doesn't go all the way through the material; it's just on the surface. So your edges will be the same as the background color (the off white). But the upside is that it's non-porous and really is super easy to maintain.

If you go this route, get a professional to fabricate and install.

I fear your wall paint color is way too pink to use throughout a home.

have to agree about the cocoa butter color. I don't like it w/the Cloud White. and it is very pink. What is your plan for the walls? Love the Hemlock idea for the island as it would look lovely next to your woods. But that cocoa butter,,,nope.

I like any of these w/those two other colors

BM White Sand

so you can see the diff

no. still too pink. look above. I added more pics to my comments

white sand is not gray.

you need a tan/yellow based,,,not a pink red based wall color. Or, change your white paint to something w/a pink base

Beth H. Where is that overdyed rug from? So stunning and understated at the same time.

Beverly,,,it's from Revival Rugs. they all come from Turkey. some beautiful (and reasonable) pieces on their website.