Your lake house looks so cozy! If you want to change the glass shades on the chandelier over the dining table, I would simply try to complement in style or color. Is your dining chandelier silver toned? If so, I might even consider painting it. Hopefully, some more creative folks will chime in :).

Pretty rooms.

Is the chandelier as high as it looks in the picture? Maybe consider lowering it. If the shades are the same type of glass I think they would work.

The 2 lamps on the buffet look too formal for your space.

Thanks for the tips. The DR fixture is kind of a antique pewter which I like and it’s similar to the others. I can’t lower the fixture because it is so wide people hit their heads on it. I’ve bought and returned several alternatives that are smaller but I just didn’t like them and they were relatively poor quality compared to this one - and bronze or nickel which I don’t care for. So for now I’ve raised it to prevent injury! Yes the buffet lamps aren’t quite right. These are the shades that came with them and eventually I’ll switch out the shades for something a bit more rustic. I think I will look for some glass shades for the dining room chandelier that are similar color and shape as the kitchen but not exactly the same.

I also got my new high arc faucet installed today (something else I asked about here). Fortunately I followed your advice and got it as it’s perfect - not excessively tall. And I recently replaced the dirty carpet on the stairs with wood - also wonderful. Really enjoying getting these things done that I’ve been pondering since we moved into this place almost three years ago. They’re small changes but make a big difference to me.

I don’t think you have to match glass shades exactly but I would probably stay in a similar color family as ruby Clare said. The shades on Chandy over island look glittery opalescent white. The shades in fixture over table look grayish (maybe it’s just shadows). But if they are gray, I’d replace with goldish-amberish tones. Home Depot has a decent selection of glass shades.

If foyer fixture is not within sight of others, you could do a fun color like cobalt blue, red, green, whatever goes best. Or you can stick to whitish-goldish tones. When in doubt, It is safest to do CLEAR.