You Choose ! GAF Sienna or Camelot ? Which of these looks better?

alli katt
last year
last modified: last year

Hello Houzz,

I am trying to figure out which of these would be the best choice for a replacement? The home is quite traditional but I am hoping to help it to stand out a bit in a classy manner from the others in the neighborhood. There are two roofs in consideration including the GAF Sienna or the GAF Camelot 2.. both in the dark gray/slate/charcoal color scheme.

Which do you think is a better choice for this home?

Also...would you consider white washing this home at some point to improve the overall cohesive nature of the look?

Thanks for all input :).

Here is the Sienna...

VS. the Camelot 2...

Comments (12)