I would choose a color from the area rug and use a combination of solid, texture, and pattern for window treatments, throw pilows, and accessories. I'd also add plants. This article with tips on how to choose colors you'll love should help. And this one has tips for mixing patterns and textures with solids.

Nice ideas from Flo to make room pop up! Love it. I would get nice chandelier. It makes absolutely great view in Flo's rendering.

Cari, have you tried showing your DH the photos with the alternate rugs. Your itself is great, but IMO it doesn't work with any of the other items you selected. Are you prepared to change those to something new? It's the 'twiggy' patterned chairs are the issue. You can get by with the leather wrapped chair.

Dear Husband

I kind of liked Cari's interpretation or use DDH (dear dumb husband.)

A different perspective on your room.

We think some window treatments, and a new rug would work well. Also you might look into adding more pillows, a nice plant in the corner, and a few side tables.

Buckhead Mid Century Modern Home · More Info

Downtown Aiken Law Office · More Info

Yeah!!!!

What do you think of these rugs?

I would not choose a neutral rug, but rather add color with a rug and drapery panels, like Bev suggested. The fabric on the chairs is a contemporary pattern which is why the traditional rug doesn’t look nice with them. I love the orange colors in Bev’s rendering, but you could do another color, turquoise for example. Just look for rugs that aren’t traditional in colors you like. I’d look for a rug that has one predominant color.

I love those chairs, by the way!

The first rug is too traditional, and the second one is a too bold geometric pattern for your chairs.

Calling @groveraxle to chime in. She (?) always posts lovely rug suggestions!

@carolae thank you for you input. It helps to know why the rug doesn’t work. I do love the chairs. Here is a solid I like.

I like that rug a lot! I think you need to see how it looks in your room. Colors are hard to judge on a computer monitor if you found the rug online. I’ve ordered two area rugs online, and one was much darker than I anticipated. Is it easily returnable?

I would repeat the rug color elsewhere in the room- in pillows, artwork, decor such as vases, and/or drapery panels. I’ve read that repeating a color in three places in a room makes for a harmonious look. Is your kitchen open to this room? Are there other colors in the room?

You could also add another color to this room in small doses- blue (not a light blue, but a medium or dark blue), turquoise, and hunter green all look great with orange.

I don’t like your current black and white pillows with this rug. I buy most of my pillows at Pier 1 or Walmart. Pier 1 has quite a large selection of colorful pillows that aren’t down (I’m allergic to down). If you like down pillows, Home Goods has a large selection of them.

I agree! Pillows came with couch. Waiting on rug decision for color of pillows.

Pick a color or two from your rug for your color accents. Draperies or simple panels in red and tan stripes or a simple pattern would bring color up onto the walls. Art over the mantel will distract from the mantel if you don’t like it. Art on the other walls will bring in more color. Hang art centered at eye level to an average adult.
The house looks wonderful. The floors and rug are beautiful, and you have done a great job selecting furnishings. All you need is the art and window treatments.

Following