I also want the Memoirs but decided it's too large. I don't want a "deep" vanity ... we rented a beachfront condo once with a "deep" vanity, and it took me a few days to figure out why I found that sink set-up uncomfortable.

The sink you're proposing is large ... but large isn't really a necessity in a bathroom. The (oval) sinks in my current house are roughly 18" wide x 14" deep ... and they're just average in size. With depth being a concern, I'd recommend you go with a smaller sink. Personally, I've already selected the Kohler Devonshire, which is about the size of the sinks I have now. Of course, it's an oval, and the rectangle may be what's driving you ... it's the ridges that I like.

Thanks for your advice. I will check under the sink. I can't do the wall mounted.

I love the Devonshire faucet because of the edges too and thought that the Archer sink will mirror those edges. We have an oval sink now and I'm really drawn to the rectangle.

Now I'm trying to decide on the faucet finish to go with my gray (MSI Vena Carbona) and Snowbound cabinets.

Laura I just measured UNDER the cabinets and it is 19 1/2 from front to back. If they put the Archer sink toward the front there should be room for the faucet. Thoughts?? I just don't want to order two sinks and have them sent to the fabricator and then not have them fit the cabinet base. Ugh.

Typically vanities are 21" deep ( 22 would include the doors ).

The open part of the vanity should be 1 1/2" less than the depth of the cabinet box ( 19 1/2" ) With in that space you need to fit the sink and the faucet. So if the faucet base is 2 5/8 that will def leave you less than 17" for a sink...

The first sink specs you posted will work, but the second one won't.

Good luck

Should I have them put that 4 inch backsplash on or leave it off? Would that give more room for the faucet?