Software
Houzz Logo Print
rouge21_gw

What would you do with this extra bit of garden? Or dont do it.

With respect to perennial gardening, the basic mantra to me has always been "less lawn means more plants".


But with experience I somewhat reluctantly know that there comes a point when less is more.


Look here:



If this was your front lawn could you "justify" the removal of this wedge of lawn to allow for more plants?


I did consult with venerable member 'woody' and she gave a qualified approval.


What say you? Do it or leave well enough alone?

Comments (37)

  • 7 years ago

    I would easily justify losing the wedge and then further justify removing the remainder of the grass.

    I would make the pathway through the garden with one of the existing hardscape materials like the interlock. You would never need to bring the lawn mower into the front yard again. You would still have lawn in your backyard.

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked peren.all Zone 5a Ontario Canada
  • 7 years ago

    Either of the above suggestions would work. The main things are losing the acute angle and not leaving the "odd-man out" circle on the top right. A broader view might help determine what the path should be.

    tj

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱
  • 7 years ago

    I would justify losing the grass for the same reasons above: easier to mow or stop mowing entirely, to eliminate the confusing shape; to have bigger plantings of same plant....to rest the eye and unify a design. On a personal note I remember your 'back garden' where you had a similar thing going on. Lots of discussion followed by digging out bigger curves. So losing the kink in this little plot might demonstrate you got the concept and applied to another site successfully. Do you love detail by any chance?

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked Marie Tulin Boston burbs z 6a
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I'd remove all the sod in the area and add some height--maybe a dwarf tree with seasonal interest---underplanted with bulbs and perennials--and a short fence on the corners only--for interest

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked User
  • 7 years ago

    I prefer a front yard be harmonious with the neighborhood. In a neighborhood with small front yards, a long sweep of lawn along the street creates cohesion. Perhaps your neighborhood has a patchwork of gardens along the street: in that case, your choice to remove the lawn is fine because you're not the odd duck out.

    I would remove enough sod to fix the curve. Next, I'd remove the plant on the right and sod that over. Marking the corner of your lot with a planting or fence feels ungenerous; you're marking your territory rather than sharing a bit of lawn.

    Next, I'd spend the winter thinking about your color palette and possibly restraining your choices. Sorry if this isn't what you wanted to hear ;)

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked cecily 7A
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    cecily, I had no preconceived ideas about what I "wanted to hear". All is good everyone. I learn lots from you guys and gals.

    Let me see if I can followup on some comments

    A broader view might help determine what the path should be.

    For sure that would help.



    .......underplanted with bulbs

    Catkin I am a big fan of bulbs. Here is how part of that same area looked earlier this spring:



    I have plans to add more of the red and white tulips to the strip by the driveway and maybe to the new section.

    Next, I'd remove the plant on the right and sod that over.

    I agree completely but the reality is that it can't happen.

    Let me explain:

    My partner has given me free rein re almost all things garden and I am grateful. But a few years back a very firm request ;) was made to include a hardy hibiscus with all white flowers. I can tell you that our property is small and at the time of this ask there was absolutely no place/space in an existing bed for this hibiscus. And so here it is. For sure it sticks out like a sore thumb but when in bloom it almost compensates for its poor location ;)



    And given the "out in left field" location of this hibiscus I cant envision a nice way to incorporate it into the existing nearby beds except by removing all the grass to the sidewalk and I am not going to do this.

    On a personal note I remember your 'back garden' where you had a similar thing going on. Lots of discussion followed by digging out bigger curves.

    Yup, I am now completely satisfied with the shape of the back garden(s). I took the advice of 'woody' and the group and it is "perfect" :).

    But I think the front area is a bit different (assuming we ignore "Hibiscus Island") as the two 'strips' of existing plantings, as seen best in the first picture, are actually connected right now.

    Having said that, at this point I am thinking I will further connect the two "strips" but if I am to keep some lawn next to the sidewalk I am now musing using a concave arc as the edge rather than the red/orange arc which is convex and hopefully including a (very) dwarf tree as part of this new space s suggested by Catkin...still thinking....always fun considering the possibilities.

    spend the winter thinking about your color palette

    Hmm...the colour palette can be changed as I think the "unrestrained" colours are from annuals.

  • 7 years ago

    Personally, I think that the design decision should be based on how the element fits into the whole. In other words, whether or not to remove part of the lawn first depends on how that section will fit with the rest of the garden and the style of the house. Looking at just the piece you may miss the big picture and end up with an unsatisfying design. Depending on your goals, that may also include your neighborhood. If, of course, your goal is just to get more plants in there, then the point is mute. Just take out the lawn and cram in more plants. If the space were mine, as usual, my landscape architecture training would be warring with my plant obsession.

  • 7 years ago

    If the space were mine, as usual, my landscape architecture training would be warring with my plant obsession.


    Exactly nosemeter.


    (As I wrote in my first post, i have come to realize that sometimes "less is more" with respect to beds and plants)

  • 7 years ago

    I personally would leave some negative space there....makes the flowers pop more.

    I would take out the triangle in first pic and add an ornamental tree...also remove the added edging/bricks. Consider discontinuing the pink and add purple instead. Unless you really love it of course. Sorry no offence, I’m just not a fan of harsh yellow and pink combos...

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked GardenHo_MI_Z5
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Just to clarify GH, you think that "triangle" of sod (with the long edge being my added orange/red ark) "should be removed, leaving room for an ornamental tree ?

    The yellow you see are from the long flowering perennial "Little Goldstar" rudbeckia.

    What colour(s) would you suggest for annuals, to be planted above and below them, in place of the current pink and white (geraniums) to best fit in with the strong yellow of LG? (Full sun location)

  • 7 years ago

    Rouge - it occurred to me that your situation there could be a place to do a smaller scale version of our front garden with the 'moat bed' and green grassy 'negative space' - but perhaps I'm just inclined to see an opportunity to repeat something that worked for us.....! I'm not good at MS Paint - especially since I don't have a stylus and am very shaky trying to use a mouse to draw/color lines! Hopefully you can see what I mean from this butchered image - plus, I've included some older pictures from here that show the overall 'look'. A key part of the reason for the 'moat bed' was to connect the two wisteria trees into one reasonably unified space - sort of the same issue of you needing to keep the hibiscus but connect it to the rest.... The narrowest section of the 'moat bed' is only 6" across for planting space - but that still gives room to put stuff in there that makes an impact! I've included a picture from a few days ago that looks across the narrowest point (I was taking pictures of the Heptacodium almost in bloom plus the dwarf white butterfly bush and hibiscuses in the main front bed....)

    My ghastly Paint attempt!:

    (The grass path should be at least ~30-36" wide to be functional and a nice smooth curve - you might need to lose a bit of the big bed to grass....)

    Old pictures of the similar front bed here, showing the layout is striking in almost every season!:

    A foggy day in February 2017 after a snow-melt! Even with dormant plants and grass, the structure makes a pleasing impact I think:

    The classic May view with the wisterias in bloom but the grass path an important element in the scene:

    Your white hibiscus would be the star plant in your set-up, and more connected to the rest of the front garden plantings.

    From the road a few days ago, showing that the very narrow 'moat bed' section is an important growing space too (and allows people to step into the garden, while still making a visual barrier between 'public' and 'private' space):

    Something to think about....?


    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked woodyoak zone 5 southern Ont., Canada
  • 7 years ago

    I guess "to allow for which plants and how will they fit in with plants (annuals, herbaceous perennials and woody shrubs) already present in the front garden?". Personally, I agree with catkin about height, but coordinated with other height already present in the front garden. I'd rather have the interest of the wedge than more bedding.

  • 7 years ago

    'woody', that first picture is very interesting, quite clever.


    Thanks for taking the time to do the painting.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    So losing the kink in this little plot might demonstrate you got the concept

    Yikes a test!

    Do I pass?


    (An improvement over the previous configuration?)



  • 7 years ago

    Big improvement!!! Nice job, and the edging looks great too!!

  • 7 years ago

    Here’s a few visuals for you...

    Hydrangea

    Dogwood (sorry I ruined the shape)

    Weeping conifer

    Dappled willow

    Dwarf Lilac

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked GardenHo_MI_Z5
  • 7 years ago

    I think I Prefer this placement much better... what do you think?

  • 7 years ago

    GardenHo, you are the best! (Thanks so much for taking the time to "draw" in your "idea trees".)


    I have had Japanese Maples on my brain this season so my first choice is a dwarf JM. The issue is the location ie subject to wind, snow and salt as it is close to the road and sidewalk.



  • 7 years ago

    That’s an improvement, Rouge. I agree with Garden Ho that something to balance the hibiscus would be good in the new area - I’d probably go with a white hydrangea that blooms at the same time as the hibiscus so they’d sort of mirror each other across the grass. I think, for your next planting-space-enlargement project :-) you should rework the circular edging under the hibiscus to follow the edging on the main bed to create a constant-width grass path, with the edging then following the sidewalk as in the new area but in the other direction, and then turning up at the property line - the hibiscus would then be enclosed in a larger space (more room to plant new things!) but relate well to the rest of the front garden. You want the grass path to be a distinctive ‘negative space’ with a pleasing shape. At this point the grass is still a ho-hum nothing-special shape....

  • 7 years ago

    You’re welcome. I thought about a JM also but not sure which kind?

  • 7 years ago

    P.S. I’d probably remove those annuals along the driveway on, across the side of the sidewalk. I’d just grass over that space so it doesn’t compete with the colourful main garden.....

  • 7 years ago

    I think I Prefer this placement much better... what do you think?


    Interesting GH but I think I prefer the small tree/shrub to go in the new location as it is there that it will be less likely to block the garden in behind.

  • 7 years ago

    You would know best rouge as you can see it from different angles. From this angle it appears to show more of your garden...

  • 7 years ago

    Playin’

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked GardenHo_MI_Z5
  • 7 years ago

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked GardenHo_MI_Z5
  • 7 years ago

    An open mind earns a 'pass' with no test at all. Congratulations! The japanese maple looks wonderful in picture, as long as there's no chance that it will be hit by snowblower, shoveled or plowed snow. I made that mistake along the front walk. there's no place to put the snow unless you walk shovelfuls somewhere else. PITA. And I paid someone for that mistake.

    no lilac please....about 3 weeks of seasonal interest. unless you grow a couple of clematis up it and I don't think that's the look you're going for in the front yard.

    Stewartia too big?

    Halesia too broad (and short lived)

    Picking trees is so much fun!


    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked Marie Tulin Boston burbs z 6a
  • 7 years ago

    Way better! Exactly what I was trying to describe with my 'grass path winding through'.

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 7 years ago

    GH (and others) you are having too much fun choosing a plant for that new spot!

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I’d probably remove those annuals along the driveway on, across the side of the sidewalk.

    Thanks but no thanks 'woody'. Those portulacas are symmetric on both sides of the driveway and each part of a "hell strip". in that no "nice" grass will grow there. I am sometimes tempted to take on the job of 'renovating' this strip with lots of plantings but as there is a water sucking town planted maple smack dab in the middle, with roots all over, i quickly am scared off.

    So it is either weeds or bright colours!





    (It isn't unusual for people walking by on the sidewalk to comment favourably on these annuals)

  • 7 years ago

    While I think this is a definite improvement, the path seems too narrow between the hibiscus and the colorful flowers where the bed edge now bends back in a backwards S. I would flatten the S a bit to make that part of the path a bit wider.

    I also wouldn’t want something particularly tall blocking sight lines to the front door unless it will be tall enough to limb up. Doors that are blocked visually by plant matter bother me and feel unwelcoming. Either keep that plant shorter than the hibiscus and have the mass provide the balance, or choose one that can be limbed up and the door seen below the branches. I like the idea of balancing the hibiscus, but the house itself cannot be ignored in the process.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I also wouldn’t want something particularly tall blocking sight lines to the front door

    I agree completely.

    The tree that goes there will be definitely less bulky than the Blue River II hibiscus.

  • 7 years ago

    I love woodyoak’ Grass path idea and gardenho’s idea of a Japanese maple.

    rouge21_gw (CDN Z5b/6a) thanked djacob Z6a SE WI
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    djacobz, I was out most of the day yesterday searching out a suitable JM (with expense being a major consideration). I picked up TWO small one as I couldn't decide :(. I will post a picture once it is planted.

  • 7 years ago

    “I picked up TWO small one as I couldn't decide”

    LOL!!!

  • 7 years ago

    I decided to plant the slow growing, with a narrow habit, dwarf like Japanese Maple called "Skeeters Broom". It stays a reddish colour all season and can do well in a full sun location.




  • 7 years ago

    Looks like a good choice..and good placement ;0)