Not a pro but Timberbark for the garage doors might help pull some focus from them since they're right in front. I'd go with the lighter color for the columns. There's a lot going on with the front of the house. Maybe something light/bright for the door to give it more focus. See what the pros here think.

I would try Timberbark (siding color) for the garage doors and do the front door and columns in the trim color. Not sure you need to add another color. A dark walnut stain is going to make your entry dark and I think it will just blend in with the siding color.

I wish your stone had more of the warm color. In the photo it just reads very gray, but might be different in person.

Removed some Tudor Timber details over the large garage door since they are not over the small garage door.

Please note that the stone on the second floor is being supported by the walls faced with siding on the first floor. This cannot happen in real life unless the stone is fake.

This is why there should not have been any stone applied to the second-floor walls. I know........too late, but maybe someone else will benefit from this info.

A good looking house!

I am assuming Timberbark is the color on the siding, not the shakes. The siding color for the garage doors would work. But the current color is not bad since it is repeated on the trim. After doing a crude mock-up, I think I like it better the way it is.

I agree with chispa for your color choices

I agree with chispa regarding a dark walnut stain, or anything dark for that matter. Just seems the front door needs more focus.

A gable nested in a Jerkenhead nested in a gable. And flying stone on the second level. Wow!

If it was my house, I'd paint the garage doors to match the siding. I'd also paint all those vertical trim pieces to match the siding.

The porch columns would get painted to match the other trim and the front door would get an accent color...perhaps Mark's Hunter Orange.

BeverlyFLADeziner, Thank you for your input. The stone is definitely not fake - it’s natural stone and the developer of the area has strict architectural guidelines. We needed to have at least 300 sq. ft. of stone on the front of the house -it would have been tricky to accommodate that much stone on the ground level (we tried!).

Chispa, thank you for your advice. The stone does have more grey to it; however, it’s really beautiful stone when seen in person.

An entry door needs much more than an actually visible color. It needs the approach to it to have clues that it exists, and that people are welcome to come to that door. There doesn’t seem to be much of an encouraging wide and friendly pedestrian path to the porch, where presumably, people will travel.

Right now? This looks like the cars are telling people that they are not welcome. The garage is the most obviously important part of the facade. It’s the most obvious and prominent element. And the front door isn’t visible, and has no designed path of destination to it.

The hardscape and landscape design needs to overcome this. Paint is secondary. But yes, paint all of the batten trim and the garage doors the house body color. That body color may need a big workout on a lot of elements, actually. Every necklace in the jewelry box is being used, and it’s too much.

The entry door needs a light bright color. School bus yellow. Bubble gum pink. Orchid purple. Acid citron green. Something that shouts rather than hides behind its mother’s apron.

Paint the trim around the garage doors house body color too. And that second floor levitating stone. I find the trim color entirely too contrasting with the body color as well. It draws attention to things that shouldn’t be in the spot light.

cpartist's rendition is close to what I had in mind.

What cpartist said. I think a brilliant yellow front door would be smashing. If you want a bit more subdued yellow, consider Farrow & Ball's "India Yellow".