Not a Pro.

It's a great wall. I would leave as is. It looks great!

Tweaking as Groveraxle said is all it may need.

Ok, I’ll try to post a photo of the stone we were thinking if using, wondering if we should go with the original plan with cladding the fireplace top and bottom or just the bottom, we are thinking of putting a larger tv in and new engineered flooring.

Ok so as I am a novice, I can’t post a photo but it’s island stone in tropical white parrarles V

Is this your thinking?

Is it this in tropical white?

No if that is the stone you are thinking stacked stone is already a dated look > IMO your wall loks great just the way it is replace the mirror that is reflecting nothing worth seeing twice with anothe nice piece of art.

So like this?

My first thought is to replace the 3 pieces of artwork (which aren't very impactful) with a larger and bolder piece.

Following

It’s more like this, modern update to a stacked stone. But I would carry the ledge all the way across, what about that idea?

Maybe more colorful art on the left area...those frames are the right size but the pictures are very small. Also, I would consider more color and perhaps some window treatment, even if simply one colorful drapery panel at each side of the window.

Yes I do have more colorful art, I can see changing. The tv will be a 65” staying in the same place but modifying the space wider to accommodate the tv. What are you ideas on the fireplace, thinking of staying beneath the ledge now with the White Island Stone... also need input on the ledge, would I leave it painted with the wall color or clad it in dark wood?
Thanks

This is the stone I am contemplating.

cool, but I like the horizontals more than taking the stone all the way up. but it's your house! :)

Is that TV comfortable to watch as it looks awful low.

I don't know how much larger your new TV will be, but if it's much larger than the current one, I don't see any way to accommodate it below the mantel. I suppose the one I rendered must be about a 1200" TV.

Thanks everyone! The TV alcove will be modified wider to accommodate the wider tv. My furniture is low profile only 15” off ground, TV seems to work at eye level. After viewing the renditions, I think I will keep the horizontal look and use the stone on the lower half.
I will change the paint color and art work. Thanks again for everyone’s comments