Leave table as is because vintage tiger oak is meant to be that shade.

Besides - at least for me - aesthetically mixing light and dark woods is fine. I recently remodeled and have a lot of wood including some vintage pieces. Much of my new cabinetry is caramel medium quarter sawn white oak. My floors are a natural blonde oak and I have some vintage pieces Waterfall pieces in my bedroom which I refinished and are a deeper tone - the wood is a zebra veneer of some kind :-). I had a dining table done custom and it's a very light maple with dark walnut inset as a decorative motif :-).

I had to get rid of some of old stuff when I remodeled and redecorated because it was just too much stuff. I had a beautiful bowed glass curio buffet curio in the same gorgeous tiger oak. In my opinion, this kind of oak has absolutely nothing to do with the ubiquitous oak cabinets from the 1980's :-).

Keep the beautiful table as is! Your furnishings are lovely but perhaps overwhelmed by some extraneous things, like the " basket" thing standing beside the hutch. I might opt for a rectangular rug.

I will keep table as is. I see so many comments on Houzz about oak, that I was doubting the beauty of the grain. Also, moved my tiered basket...it’s for my produce, such as potatoes, onions, etc so I need it in my kitchen. Just got rid of a square rug and got this one on cl for 50 bucks. I’ll keep it for now.

I was into turn of the century oak in the 70's. We could pick pieces up for next to nothing because no on wanted it. Often I would find a piece put out on the side walk, the owner hoping some one would take it away. I will! I will!.. Your round oak pedestal table is great...don't stain it darker.

You have such a collection I am sure you know how pieces were "bought", but maybe some readers might not.

https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-1986-10-12-8603170273-story.html

I've seen many new kitchens with quarter sawn oak - so it is back in again:)

If you personally feel the grain is more busy then you like, a runner or set of placemats can decrease the visible wood. I have both dark and lighter shades of oak in my dining room too!

My kitchen cabinets are oak...keep em long enough and they’ll be back in. Lol

I'm not as big a fan of antiques as you clearly are (although I do have a few pieces amidst all the MCM stuff) but I wouldn't touch that table top. It's lovely just the way it is. And I agree with Helen that you can mix wood tones in one house - or even one room. That's what makes decorating fun.

Custom table pads help, as does a top made of tinted glass. Under the glass, you could can add a collage of children’s current artwork or favorite photos or other memory minders and conversation starters. meaningful flat items ThatvwgyvI

Sorry—cannot edit or delete. Clunky interface issues on my iPhone.

My kitchen is also oak. Here it is after a refresh done a few years ago:

https://www.houzz.com/hznb/photos/my-pics-work-in-progress-phvw-vp~110720042

https://www.houzz.com/hznb/photos/my-pics-work-in-progress-phvw-vp~109854029

It does not sound like you have plans for changing anything up, but here is my wood kitchens idea book with both new and older, refreshed kitchens:

https://www.houzz.com/ideabooks/75202366/list/wood-kitchens

When we renovated our home including the kitchen 24 years ago, I assumed our decorator would say that our colonial style oak harvest table and chairs would need to go, and I was prepared to fight for them LOL. (She was new to us, British, with a plummy accent and lots of style.)

But she was horrified at the thought that we would replace such a quality piece. Along the same lines, Prince Charles apparently wears suits with visible mending (apparently his tailor keeps the cutting scraps, for future repairs).

I am constantly amazed that people think that a kitchen that was beautiful 30 years ago is suddenly ugly because it is oak. And, heaven forbid, with cathedral arch raised panels. How can they be ewww when they were wow?

My kitchen is not beautiful, by any means, with my tile counters, oak cabinets, and hanging copper. But it’s homey and cozy. I have to tell you about a foreign exchange student, who was staying with my granddaughter and daughter who had the proverbial white kitchen. She was from Italy and when she walked into my crowded “old” kitchen, she just started laughing with joy. It reminded her of home! I’ve embraced it ever since.

Your table is beautiful as is. Please don't do a thing to it. For my taste, I would remove a few items in your curio cabinets so individual items can be appreciated. You can then rotate them when ever you choose. As they are now most are a bit lost. Love the wine press!

We just re-did our kitchen with new countertops and cabinets. But I incorporated a duncan phyfe buffet under wall cabinets and wine rack. I think it is wonderful to mix old and new. But what I see a lot of is beautiful antique furniture stuffed with tsotchkes. It looks cluttered and you miss the beauty of the antique furniture.

Less is more! This was taken during the holidays so a bit busier than usual

I really dislike the new oak that is in every house I swear but old growth oak was and is beautiful , leave the table as is . I do agree to simplify all the stuff you have everywhereRemove at least 1/2 of all the stuff in the cabinets and on the cabinets then you will begin to be able to enjoy the things you love., not to mention a lot less dusting.

Thank you for your comments about decluttering. Unfortunately we have a tiny house, with no storage and if I try to pare down our treasures, my DH will bring in something he found at goodwill...lol. So, we just live with our stuff and I dust!