I've been really loving the look of kitchens with different color islands.

I was going to do board and batten with corbels at a future date. I love your picture though!! Is that stainless at the base?? We are saving for new counters next. (That will take a while with kids in college and 4 still at home...smile)

I suspect the request for rest of kitchen was to see overall space so one could decide what advice to give. Pretty hard to give any wish you’ve shown so very little of the overall space.

The black works with your countertop but if you're wanting change for your kitchen and plan to paint all your cabinets, then consider choosing either of the two lightest colors -- the off white or the tan (tanish) -- likely would work well ... but with one caveat: if you have more white or off white in your kitchen (other than your ceiling), you might not want to use a second off white because one off white could make the other off white appear dingy by comparison -- in which case that same tan (tanish) (n your countertop (small places within it) might be the better choice. Or. You could be bolder and paint all your base cabinets black and all your overhead cabinets white -- a look I like: https://www.decorpad.com/photo.htm?photoId=116022. While I also like the light bright blue in your backsplash, since it's not in your countertop, I'd not use it for your cabinets.