Thinking black board and batten shutters, new black front door, and maybe a black garage door? I don’t like how the previous owners matched the roof to the home but since the roof is newer it doesn’t make sense to replace that right now.

And black light fixtures

Absolutely, black is so classy, always!

Also, brown/ black go well together, so don’t worry about the roof!

Any other ideas??

Replace current mail box with classic metal box on a post, painted black.

No shutters there is no room for proper sized ones black windows would be fabulous along with a black door . I also do not like the siding color or the white garage door. The garage door needs to be a much classier design maybe with some windows and this is one of my all time favorite colors for the siding with brick if all else stays the same.BTW that is the stlye of garage door you need.

Thank you so much Patricia! The windows and siding are 30 years old so down the road I did think we’d do black windows And probably white siding. What do you think on color of siding? Also, what color garage door? I love this style!

If black seems too severe, you can consider SW Urbane Bronze. It would complement your brick nicely. The front door and garage can be done for sure. And yes, a black mailbox.
Is there a way to paint the inside trim of your windows or are they vinyl? Very sweet house. It just needs a bit of contrast and drama.

I vote for no shutters.