Software
Houzz Logo Print
courtney_dawn38

Granite or quartz to go with outdated cabinets and floors?

5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago

Hi all, I'm struggling. My husband is finally giving ok to update our counter tops to granite or quartz. The problem is my cabinets are still dated oak and floor is typical 80's. I was hoping to find a counter top that would maybe add some update to my kitchen along with some tile backsplash and adding hardware to the cabinets to give us a little face lift. He said no to floors because we dont know how much that would entail from guestimation and with installation it looks like 1500 minimum and no to painting cabinets. His reasoning is fair, that we are only going to be here another 2 years or so hopefully before selling. He wants to wait to get our dream kitchen for our next house. I know he wants a nice kitchen as much as i do in our next home bc he is actually the cook of the family. Is there any suggestions i can do with countertops and backsplash that will help me feel like I'm not stuck in my 80's kitchen? We recently saw fantasy brown at slab yard and loved it but now im nervous it will be too busy for my cabinets. Help please??trying to figure out how to add some pictures

Comments (180)

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Courtney, are you guys feeling better?

  • 5 years ago

    @Lisa Caudill Designs yes, thank you! Just started coming back to life and running on about 50% power yesterday! I’ll post the counters. It’s far from organized since I only put a few things away. I ordered a new bottle drying system for all my baby bottles so it will take up less counter space but bottles and sippy cups will be my mommy style for a while unfortunately haha. Also , we Decided we have to delay doing our floors For a bit or maybe permanently. I will be going though several procedures over the next 2 months including another intensive ivf cycle as we try for baby #2 so hubs just says we have to prioritize and with me being down with procedures he will have very little time to actually work on the floors along with his other projects. I’m disappointed but i Also know he isn’t wrong. So I’m back to thinking about grout renew . I cleaned my grout good tonight and tried a white and platinum grout renew. The platinum Is a definite not, the white I don’t hate but told hubs we have to decide on a direction with the back splash bc I feel like it matters regarding the color I choose for floor grout, do I want it to be contrasting or light or coordinate. So that’s to be continued. Again, I’m super bummed about the floors being at the very least postponed.


    we are still waiting on the asbestos test, it was supposed to be back to us Thursday, it’s late. So we can take this popcorn down and figure out the lightening .


    I tried to take down the blinds over the sink, couldn’t get them so my husband will do that, they are going. Along with the foam piece. white toaster will also go. It’s great but only used as a back up since our stainless broke.



  • 5 years ago

    @Beth H. : see update above for pics and sadness about floors being postponed :(


    great call on the leathered granite , we both love it and my husband admits while he thinks the polished would look “fine” he likes the look of the leathered with our ugly oak.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Glad you are feeling better and best wishes on your ivf journey.

    The counters and sink look great!

  • 5 years ago

    @Lisa Caudill Designs thanks so much! My 10 month old is the result of 3 years and 3 rounds of ivf so we are hoping number 2 doesn’t take so long. Appreciate the well wishes.


    I love the sink, it’s huge compared to what we had

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    courtney, sorry you're not feeling well. is it the side effect of the treatment?

    hoping you don't have to go through 3 rounds again!!

    love the counters! they really look nice w/the oak. Can't remember if you decided on hardware? doing the black or the nickel?

    if the ceiling was done after the mid-late 70's, it prob won't have asbestos. just FYI. Hopefully test yields negative.

    bummer about the floor tiles. BUT, I think if you do the grout renew AND bring in a nice rug, it will look great. don't do a bright white. look for a creamy beige tone (on the Grout Renew) that matches you floor tile. (platinum is too silver. you're matching the tile, not the granite)

    you want something similar to this


    what about Bone, Alabaster, Antique white, Canvas? see if any of those work. bring home a couple and test, returen what doesn't work.


    I also like the painting idea. (c last pictures. I posted a bunch of pictures this time!)

    So, what do you think of this for the window? (gave you Cloe tile in Gray) Cosmas matte black hardware


    I also painted and stenciled your floor tiles. we talked about this, right? I mean, if a year or two from now your'e going to rip them out, and you hate them now, why not paint/stencil them w/a cool pattern to go w/your new stone?

    I also gave you a solid gray roman blind, and a simple white pendant



    wayfair, $51



    I really like #5 too. if you did a woven wood blind, or a lighter gray blind, that black pendant would look great. and some simple black hardware too.





    here are some other window ideas




    don't know if you were going to tile all the way up, or do a wider window trim to eat up the space to the cabinets.


    don't know if you have recessed lights in there, but I like the woven light fixtures w/the oak. Maybe you could find one to hang over the peninsula area. Notice the runner in front of the street they have in this pic.


    this is called a cotton Dhurrie rug and they come in all colors. inexpensive too. Look at Cost Plus World market. they have some decent choices.

    some are made of a cotton, flat weave, or even a wool, like this gray one.




    a sisal or jute would work too

    I still think you should go for the paint on the tiles!






    Doesn't have to be heavy looking, unless you want a darker gray color (Cutting Edge Stencils)


    I think this looks great. you could paint the base color, and then come in and do the stencil a little bit at a time. (cover w/a rug until you get it done and sealed)







    tons of diff designs.


    I've seen this one done with multiple colors. just depends how artistic you want to get

    https://www.royaldesignstudio.com/blogs/stenciling-tips


  • 5 years ago

    I think painting the floors is a lot less work than getting the grout cleaned up. And you can have a different color than what you have now! Or a stenciled pattern if you feel up to it. I hope your ivf treatments work faster for baby #2.

  • 5 years ago

    @Beth H. :no , no side effects of treatment , just a good ol fashion stomach virus. I’ll have a procedure at the end of this month that will have me down a good week then another full ivf round next month and hopeful to try to implant embryo for a chance at baby #2 in July. Thank you, financially we can only afford one more ivf round since it’s about 7k out of pocket each time so if it doesn’t work we will accept that we are meant to be parents to just out one little miracle.


    i havent decided on black vs nickel finishes . I like the idea of black bc I really think the black makes my cabs look a tiny bit better like you suggested with the counters. We really love the granite and so glad we took your advice on the leathered. Also love the new sink, it’s huge compared to what we have and I love it!


    called about the asbestos test apparently it’s backlogged but they said we will have results by 6pm tomorrow. I was speaking with a neighbor who has been here since our development was built. He said he didn’t know about asbestos however over the years he found out when they were building out development they did a lot of short cuts and stuff they were not supposed to do. We found a few things in our own home that shouldn’t have even passed inspection so I’m glad we did the test just to be sure. Our house was built in 83 however our neighbor said they started years earlier and easily could have used older supplies that could have contained asbestos before they were banned just to use up supply. So we will see.


    yes we talked about painting tile. I think it wouldn’t work for us because of our dog. His nails scratch everything And I feel like would scratch the paint up at least in spots easily. Also the amount of water he brings all over my kitchen on a daily basis is ridiculous so I think grout renew and a nice rug is more the direction that id go. I love the look of the pattern painted but if he chips or scratches I know it would drive me nuts and I’ll hate it until it’s fixed each time, I need less maintenance. so I will def look at those rug ideas you posted. I think adding a little color in the rug would be good.


    im also considering doing a solid subway tile in Either off white or light grey and lay it in herringbone pattern as backsplash. Keep it simple in color since I kinda have a few colors on the floor tile. we will be doing the tile all the up the window Regardless of pattern we choose.


    I was thinking Roman shade or no shade at all to keep all the light coming in? Though we decided to leave blinds off our sliding door so we will get light from there too. I can’t wait to take the light box down bc I feel like it’s tinting my room more peach Tone than it really is from the fluorescents.


    I like a lot of the lights you posted! For the main light i know we will have to likely leave the hook up where it is bc my husband isn’t snaking any electricity. so likely a main light fixture in the center and then one above the sink. We don’t eat at the island area, we really just prepare food there to cook . I like the woven light. Not sure if it blends too much with the oak , but could that be my main light and then still do a pendent over the sink or do just the woven light as the main?


    I assume I paint the walls last right ?

  • 5 years ago

    @RedRyder i like the look of painted tile but don’t think it’s gonna work for me with my crazy dog whose nails scratch everything ! Between his nails and the amount of water he drags through the kitchen I don’t think pain it would stay in good condition very long.

    thank you so much! We only can do 1 more round so we will see, fingers crossed.

  • 5 years ago

    @Beth H. : I forgot to attach pics. I tried bone bc that was the only one of your suggestions they had in store . I ordered alabaster but won’t be here until like may 25th

    Here you can see all 3 colors alone


  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    well hopefully it takes this time around!!

    tiles,,,too bad you can't go for the paint. maybe keep dogs nails trimmed and filed??

    But, if still a no (just trying to get rid of those tiles for you!) then grout renew it is.

    bone is hideous! omg, didn't realize how pink your tiles are. nothing w/yellow. can't tell if alabaster leans more yellow or more pink/taupe.

    what about antique white?

    arctic ice?

    Rose Beige?

    Quartz?


    Mapei has a version of this. maybe they have diff colors



    Silver? Smoke? Warm Gray?

  • 5 years ago

    They definitely have a pink tone to them but it looks more dramatic in the picture than it does in person in my opinion. I will check out other colors. The bone doesn’t look horrible to me , the silver does and I don’t love the white but don’t hate it either. Antique white and Bone look pretty similar on screen in samples to me. Alabaster looked lighter and closer to what I think will match. Lowe’s has the other grout stain you mentioned so I will check there for another shade. These tiles are hard to match, I just want them to blend more compared to the current copper color grout that’s in here now.


    the pup gets groomed every 3 weeks and nailed are cut and filed each time. They grow obnoxiously fast and he has a think about not letting anyone get close to his feet so he won’t let us touch his nails at home. It takes the groomer and my husband holding him for them to even get done at the groomers.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    run him on the sidewalk!! that will keep them filed. lol.

    I get it. but you'd have to see how that floor paint holds up to scratches. it's a similar floor paint used for patio and decks, so it shouldn't scratch that easily. you could also put a topcoat over it.

    I still like all of this for your kitchen! (minus the whtie cabs and butcher block)


    you can buy these tiles off wayfair or find a similar stencil and paint it


    I love these w/your kitchen.



  • 5 years ago

    @Beth H. : he gets walked several times a week on our street, I swear his nails grow and get sharper every day. Poor guy kills me bc he swears he’s a little lap dog so I have scratches all over.


    thoughts on lvt? It’s not ideal and not something I’d be into for my money invested kitchen in the future but thinking maybe it would be an upgrade to my peachy tile for appearance sake here. from our research we can do it over the existing tile and my husband is confident he could complete the project in a day instead of removing tiles (he isn’t even sure how to remove since current tiles go under our cabinet bases and he is nervous he would mess up the base cutting tile ) and then installing new tile which would probably be a longer project . With me being down with procedures mover the next couple months he feels it’s a decent alternative option. I ordered 4 for samples , 2 I hated the color so they were a no, one I will post below and the other I’m awaiting a box for delivery on Thursday or Friday .


    we got the asbestos results back and as you predictEd, no asbestos so we are gonna tackle the ceiling this weekend or next and then I can get the florescent lights out which are clearly not doing me any favors color as wise.


  • 5 years ago

    I think the lvt looks great! Can we see it next to your Pergo? How high will the transition be? I'm sure there are Pergo transition pieces to accommodate.

  • 5 years ago

    @tozmo1 the transition height is barely noticeable, a lot less than my husband expected it to be he said


  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Nice choice!

  • 5 years ago

    That looks good! I like that you found a 'stone-look' LVT since it will abut the 'wood-look' Pergo.

  • 5 years ago

    That looks really good with the Pergo too. Glad the transition won't be tricky to resolve. Looks like a winner to me.

  • 5 years ago

    @rachel ty! Yeah I couldn’t do wood lvt against the pergo and I just didn’t like the way my pergo looked with the cabinets if I continued the current pergo we had so I specifically looked for stone. I have one more choice coming in tomorrow or Friday , it’s like a light grey color. Also picked up a few more colors of grout renew and mapel as Beth suggested so can try them but I really hate my tile so I’d rather cover it if I can .

  • 5 years ago

    Courtney, I did the same in my new build. Most of the home is hardwood but in the basement, I used Shaw Journey Tile. If you are looking for other LVT stone options, this is a nice line. Here's the one I selected . . . not saying this is good for your kitchen. But an example. There are many nice colors available.

    shaw lvt 0494V journey tile kingsport - Google Search · More Info


  • 5 years ago

    @rachel I checked out some Shaw and didn’t see any stone that I was like over the moon for. I did get the last option in today and I think I like it better than the one I previously posted. Pic below. I threw in one piece of the one I pictured the other day to show the difference



  • 5 years ago

    @rachel I checked out some Shaw and didn’t see any stone that I was like over the moon for. I did get the last option in today and I think I like it better than the one I previously posted. Pic below. I threw in one piece of the one I pictured the other day to show the difference



  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I like the newest option better also. But I'm not great with color so wait and see what someone like @Beth H. : or others who are good at color say.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Either one looks great!

  • 5 years ago

    @tozmo1 the colors are very similar but the 2nd is less marble effect which I think I like

  • 5 years ago

    I like the calmer option better too.

  • 5 years ago

    @Lisa Caudill Designs I definitely don’t mind either option I think I just like the less marble as well as the feel of the newest option. Also, it’s a smaller tile which to me is more to my taste. My husband says he is fine with either so my choice and he will install as soon as it arrives. I think either option visually is better than the peachy tone I have going on now lol. We will hopefully be taking down the popcorn this weekend and then I will get a sense of what type of light fixture I can go with.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Exciting! And agree much better options. Can't wait to see what the ceiling is like without the light and popcorn and of course here for input on lighting options!

  • 5 years ago

    @Lisa Caudill Designs thank you! Will keep you posted with shape of ceiling under popcorn. If it’s bad we may be forced to try to cover it back up in some way but fingers crossed any repairs will be minimal

  • 5 years ago

    Yes, I like the newer one better.

  • 5 years ago

    Popcorn is down! ceiling Doesn’t look too bad to me but I’m sure my husband will let me know how to move forward with finishing it. this is the opening I have to work with for light, he’s not willing to put too much effort into figuring out how to move it .


  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    nice courtney!

    so if you want to move the hole, he can piggy back off of that one and fish the line through to another hole. why not use that hole for a canned light, and maybe put in a few more?



    can you take another picture that shows most of the kitchen w/the ceiling?

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    This one would look great in there.

    LNC 32" 5-Light Wood Farmhouse Brown Linear Kitchen Island Light · More Info

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Lisa, sorry, do you mean to put that in the original spot she's shown or if she moves the hole over above the peninsula ? The size is 31" X 40"

    . if you look at the original photo, she used to have a light box in that spot. that hole is not over anything. that light you posted is dining table light or a island light. but look at how short her ceilings are! if you hang that thing in the middle of her ceiling, a 6' person would hit their head walking by!

    plus, what's she supposed to do for overall lighting?

    courtney, if you can't move that hole or do added can lights, do a semi flush mount ceiling light w/multiple bulbs






  • PRO
    5 years ago

    It can be as short as 10 " post and doesn't have to be over an island or table. How high are you ceilings Courtney?

    If really low then here are some additional options

  • 5 years ago

    @Lisa Caudill Designs i love it but I agree that I’m pretty stuck with a flesh mount light due to our ceiling height. My husband is 6’3 so anything hanging too Low won’t work.



  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    @Beth H. : i will take a picture in daylight tomorrow, my husband shut the electricity off in kitchen when doing ceiling and is waiting fir it to dry more before turning back on.

    do you know where the 2nd and 3rd lights you posted were from? I found similar to first picture or maybe the same, do you think the wood tone will compete /clash too much with the cabinets? They have it is a silverfish/black finish(posted below.) I’m thinking I’ll still be doing a pendent light over the sink but would like to still have a main light. My husband won’t fish anything. He isn’t super confident in electrician skills and really just wants it to be straightforward with using existing hole.

    options I have found. I’ve only gotten to look online at Home Depot and Lowe’s but open to other options









  • 5 years ago

    @Lisa Caudill Designs ill measure ceiling height tomorrow .

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    I think any of those would work. you just have to make sure to use the LED bulbs that are at least 80W. even if the fixture says 60W maximum, using the LED with brighter lights will be ok because they use less wattage. so get the bulbs in the daylight/4000K, 100W if you have only two, if you have 3, use the 75 or 80W.

    this one is on sale. has the 4 bulbs (you'll want 60 or 75W daylight bulbs) and it's nice looking. similar to the other one but without the mesh cage. And, it's a nice large size.

    https://www.quoizellightinglights.com/product/quoizel-lighting-new-harbor-semi-flush-mount-nhr1718bn.html




    https://www.amazon.com/4-Light-Fixtures-Airposta-Farmhouse-Lighting/dp/B089NCV64Z

    home depot has these 1st two.


    since there are only two, I'd use 2-100W


    this one is shades of light:


    https://www.shadesoflight.com/products/mesh-industrial-semi-flush-mount-ceiling-light



    https://www.shadesoflight.com/products/mesh-industrial-flush-mount-ceiling-light

    this one is kind of cool. 8 lights too! you could use the 60W and really light up your kitchen



    https://www.amazon.com/Ceiling-Fixture-Industrial-Finishing-Restaurant/dp/B07DQHXQJ7

    This one comes w/the 3 bulbs, but I guarantee its' going to be those real yellow, dim bulbs. you need daylight bulbs in a kitchen



    https://www.lowes.com/pd/Kichler-14-in-Olde-Bronze-Transitional-Incandescent-Semi-flush-Mount-Light/50355988



    https://www.lowes.com/pd/Progress-Lighting-Gulliver-17-in-Galvanized-Coastal-Incandescent-Semi-flush-Mount-Light/1000522919


    https://www.lowes.com/pd/Kichler-Mascarello-14-in-Anvil-Iron-with-Distressed-Antique-Grey-Industrial-Incandescent-Semi-flush-Mount-Light/1000949284

  • 5 years ago

    I recently saw one like this installed. Very nice and bright.


  • 5 years ago

    I have 2 of those LED flushmount fixtures in my basement. They are a good choice when you need a lot of light without much height, like in my 7 foot basement. The LED fixtures give out a much more evenly spread light than individual bulbs.

  • 5 years ago

    I want to like the led flush mount but visually it’s just not appealing to me. If we can get something that is more appealing to my eye and gives us decent light I’m in!

  • 5 years ago

    So we picked up this fixture tonight to see if we like it since this was one husband and I both liked initially but was sold out


  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Cute!

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Just wanted to update this thread. we are still working in here, grout needs to be done but tile went up today. We are putting a little piece of molding at the top of tile window area. tile wasnt the one i wanted but hubs and i compromised since we spent extra on the floor . overall im happy with how its coming along!




  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Looking good!

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Looking good!

  • 5 years ago

    nice job courtney. I like the floor tiles too.

    you guys have done a very nice job!

  • 5 years ago

    It looks great so far!

Sponsored
Preferred General Contracting, Inc.
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
Fairfax County's Specialized, Comprehensive Renovations Firm