Is the color of the house dark gray?

A nice aqua, not too vivid.

Yes the siding is iron ore and the roof is a shade of gray-blue

If the all of the wood…shakes, porch steps/railing, window box..is going to weather to grey, I would leave the door as is until that process happens. Since the house seems to have a more coastal/cottage vibe, a different door would be a better fit…a solid door painted in a muted aqua or a stained wooden door with seeded glass divided lites.

I found a design site that recommended the following colors to add a pop to Iron Ore:

Enticing Red SW 6600
Butter Up SW 6681
Knockout Orange SW 6885

Yellow is my absolute favorite color but I really love the orange here too. The red isn’t my fav, I’d lean toward a more orange red. Good luck!

Thank you this is great! I like the yellow also!!

Love the yellow with white side lights. I don't think you need a wreath; it hides the feature of the door.

Yellow!

I so agree wreath has to go, glad yellow is trending.

I second, third, or fourth the recommendation of yellow! We are currently building a custom home and are going to be using Hardiplank in Evening Blue (dark) with a light gray metal roof. We're planning on using SW 6909 Lemon Twist on the front door. BTW, I love your house, Catherine!

I love that. Your colour choices are lovely.

Yellow would look great! You could also add a few annuals to your garden.

Yours reminds me of this one.

I think you can do a bolder color since you have a modern door

here's a bunch of photoshops!

Wow thank you! This is so appreciated.

A cute red would stand out yet complement the colors of your home. Please feel free to check our portfolio to get great ideas. https://www.pearlremodeling.com/