Personally. I would paint the house white, and choose a brighter color for the door. You could use some landscaping and decor for the porch as well.

Hi rachel, sorry i posted an old pic.

Here is one without the new roof

Nice landscaping, I’d still paint the siding white.

Another reason not to paint your house gray. 😉

Thank you Jinx. My husband loved the coventry gray! He thinks it will compliment our white shingle roof, and the white and black accents. I think you have helped us thank you again

Definitely test swatches on different areas of the house first, see it in different lights. I like that it’s a warmer gray, but you’ll need to see it how it pairs with everything and if you think it looks too dark, too light, whatever once you sample it.

Please update! :)

ETA: It does look good with black in photos I’ve seen:

https://www.remodelaholic.com/color-spotlight-benjamin-moore-coventry-gray/

You can search for other examples, lots of images come up.

I lie your landscape. Check color that go good with your roof.

Revere Pewter BM

Baltic Gray BM

Chelsea Gray BM