I am considering these options

It's all personal. I'm not a fan of gold with gray. I'm not a fan of mixing metals.

Looks nice! Mixing metals is simple, all you need is select one main color and stay with it. Black is neutral, it goes with everything. You can choose from gold/brass (aka yellow tone), bronze (brown tone), silver/chrome/nickel (gray).

too much of everything : gold, silver, black

nice: brass + black

So if i went with the black & gold wold a aged bronze work well for fixtures or would you recommend a more simple matte black?

Im sorry, oil rubbed bronze

Miki Hopkins

black - neutral

oil rubbed bronze - brown

gold - yellow

Matte black and oil rubbed bronze make different emotions ans aesthetic. Interior design is all about cohesiveness. Do you want more polished, posh bathroom? Or relaxed, shabby rustic?

Relaxed, shabby rustic

Miki Hopkins

Great, black and oil rubbed bronze will match! Gold is a no-no, too shiny. You can add aged gold or brass however.

NO gold with shabby rustic. Bronze or straight on black.

IMO what color are the faucets ?They needed to be chosen for the shower hook up ao I would stay with thta color for the other hardware. I think the gold does now work with the style of tile at all For sure no Edison bulbs in any room in a house . You have nice warm colors and the edison bulb will skew them all to yucky yellow cast . I The vanity should have been the first choice you made BTW.

Please…no Edison bulbs in a bathroom. Look beyond bathroom sconces and fixtures.