"It doesn't match the other Kohler vibrant moderne brass color."

Are you sure? All the color/finish icons and names used on the Kohler K-35908-4K-2MB and Kohler K-25497-2MB webpages are exactly the same.

@wdccruise yes, it says they're exactly the same, but they're actually different in person. I asked Kohler why this is, and they said it's because Studio McGee is a designer line. I wish it would've just stated that instead of letting me think they were the same! The Studio McGee line is a beautiful gold, but the regular Kohler Vibrant Moderne Brass is darker and more orangey, so they don't match.

My wife and I ordered the Studio McGee faucets and I went back-and-forth with Kohler on this after I saw this post. Kohler told me that finishes are the same, for what it's worth. That was confirmed by the company we are ordering our fixtures through.