Hope you're having a nice Memorial Day.

The house color looks so different depending on the light.

I'm thinking black and white trim. Or charcoal and white.

And a rich brown for the front door resembling natural wood.

Cute house! Your siding is so neutral, you could literally pick ANY color for trim. Pick what you love.

I'm a blue fan and think that could look great:

I cant see for sure on your pictures, but, it appears that you have a brown roof, so no grays for your house. I do like the blue color posted by Olychick. The right shade of blue, is also a cheerful color.

The roof is brown? ...looks gray on my screen. You could go Urbane Bronze instead of Charcoal.

Yes, the house color changes all day. The front is south facing. During the day it looks beige, cream, even slightly orange. The roof is dark brown. We are replacing it, along with the gutters. We will select a roof and gutter color to match the wood post color. The only thing we must keep is the siding. Definitely leaning towards a deep blue for the shutters. We are liking SW smokey blue. 

Thanks so much for your ideas.

Trecefloyd could you mock that with blue columns? Please...

My pleasure.