Can you show your application, as they say a picture is worth a thousand words. Regardless, for me, I would use the Schluter.

I dislike the look of Schluter, so I always look for tile that has matching trim pieces or bullnose options.

Fireclay does have matching trim pieces, but you probably have to place a custom order and wait several weeks. Your link has that information!

They do not have matching tile for the non-custom line, only custom and colors vary btwn the two. I understand why they do it this way and appreciate an economical option they offer, though don't like Schluter so much either. The tile is happening bc it's otherwise perfect.

Good advice on the matching Schluter to the tile. Nearly all of the photos I've seen of this tile are with white grout but we'll be using a beige grout so your advice, @McDonald Enterprises sounds good.

I'm curious if anyone has done mitered returns....I found videos on mitered corners but not returns.

I'm rarely a fan of mitered tile edges as they're difficult to make look good, expensive, and prone to chipping.

I'm with chispa. I don't care for Schluter and think of it as a (very) last resort. In your case, I think your tile is easily replaced with something that has edge pieces.

In fact, I would ONLY consider tile that had edge pieces. There are SO many companies, I'm sure you could keep looking and find something quite similar.

Our tile guy did a beautiful mitered return at the end of our kitchen backsplash - like yours, the tile we chose had no trim, and like you, I loathe Schluter. This photo is obviously before it was grouted.

Your tile looks so good @theotherjaye! Thanks for sharing that photo.

We are not changing tile choice- 100% not happening. There are options for edge treatment and I am interested in discussing them here.

Curious on your update and how it turned out?