Greige is still popular so you could choose a color from the stone.

Here is one option, the same warm gray color for stucco and trim. These are not paint colors...color selected on the stone.

Here is similar with a bit more contrast.

With black trim. fascia, gutters. Very nice.

Planning on changing it next year when a new color is "in" The stone drives the color choice and IMO not much beige tone with that stone more on the gray scale IMO . Since you have black windows and roof IMO a nice warm gray would be a great .

Look at Sherwin Williams Shoji White. It has some depth and should work well with the limestone - best to order a large paint sample to see in person on both sunny and gloomy days.

Shoji White

Thank you! The stone will look much brighter once they finish bleaching and power washing it so I’d like to go with a darker color for contrast. What do you think of dovetail or Dorian Gray? Too dark? What is the other gray color you used in the second photo?

My pleasure. I did not use paint colors except for the Shoji White. These are examples of light/dark color blocking, I color selected my paintbrush on your stone colors.

Here is your Dorian Gray

Dovetail...

To me the dark Dovetail is starting to make the house feel top heavy.