" Bronze (which will look black from afar, its dark) "

Dark Bronze and cream trim/fascia/gutters, etc...

Your third example is a nice mix of light and dark--cream (or perhaps taupe or green), not white trim with bronze windows.

Looking at the big picture, which needs to be taken into account, @lisedv shows a change to the garage door to something darker, The current white garage door makes the garage more prominent than your actual home. Consider a wood or wood effect garage door, or a darker painted door, as you make changes to your trims as well as your windows.

Front of Home at Dusk - The Genesis - Family Super Ranch with Daylight Basement · More Info

I don’t know if I love dark windows with your roof, at least if I was writing the check I’m not sure I could justify the added expense, especially since your roof and the brick are the main players while your windows are minor characters in your facade.

Bronze and white are the same cost for Marvin windows. The roof is about 29 years old, so will see a change soon. I don’t want to go too dark for the roof, since it’s large and accidentally draw too much attention to it
Dark on the

I never like white with brick so I would do dark but I also would do the garage door dark and then your light can come form some fabulous landscaping which you are in huge need of . Open up that entry area all those hedge things gone for sure a much wider walkway to the front door and large planting beds fiiled with color and a mice mix of plants that do well in your area. A garge door with windows in the same bronze as the windows and maybe no grids this time .

Is your new roof going to be gray like your sample photos? They look different from your current roof...more gray than yours which is a brown color.

I think black windows might be better with a gray roof than the bronze windows.

"The roof is about 29 years old, so will see a change soon. I don’t want to go too dark for the roof..."

Cool Roof Rating Council:

• What is a Cool Roof?
• General Cool Roof and Wall FAQs
• Rate Roof Directory

Our condo building installed ~99 Enerlux fiberglass windows which are available in eight standard colors plus custom. I compared Enerlux with Marvin (Essential, if I remember correctly) and though the Enerlux windows were better constructed (Enerlux sent me a small sample window for comparison).