Out of curiosity I looked at Google image with a copy of your house & all that came up was ranch style & rambler. Noted that styles were popular from 40’s to 70’s. Both of your doors are MCM but the top one, for me, is more suited to your house because it’s a less modern MCM style. I looked around on Google at similar door styles & there are some others with the 3 rectangular windows in different arrangements that look pretty interesting. I’d take a look at those before deciding. I hadn’t known there were other arrangements since I’ve only seen the one you show. I think I’d like a teal color over burnt orange for your red brick home.

Your ranch leans 'Colonial or Farmhouse' The doors you show are for MCM Prairie Style ranch house which means the bay window and shutters would have to go

first thought, Are you sure it's original? the bay/bow window looks like a newer feature.

If you are keeping all the windows as is, I would choose a full view front door, so it looks nice with the existing windows. No panels or grids. I would remove the shutters. I would also paint out the panels and trims around the bay to tone it down, not white.

"interior of the home which has more traditional elements like crown molding, chair rails, and six panel interior doors".

Make sure you WANT all that inside?

No matter what, a single pane glass door is the easiest and blends with everything.

The white iron railing needs to go, along with the shutters.

Color and landscaping help too

Many houses in the United States were constructed with no architectural design intent. They are a conglomeration of building parts selected by the builder from what was available from the local supplier. Houses possessed parts that had architectural style but lacked continuity that defined a specific architectural style. If these houses were dogs they would be considered mutts.

^^

I'd say MANY more than "many": ) constructed exactly as Mark said, everywhere USA. Doesn't mean you can't make an attractive exterior /interior.

Mc Mansions in the burbs of the nineties are just as hybrid and hybrid is used kindly, here.

I do not see MCM with your home so a door you like with some glass in it and a simple style will work well. Remove the shutters and I would paint all the white in a darker shade including that gable . Waht is the space on the left? The house has been messed with over time so no specific style .. I would not do a colored door in this case just a nice dark wood or bronze . I think more important in this case to meld the interior and exterior with the door. Maybe something like this not double of course

Your home’s front door is the personality-defining piece of your exterior, so choosing the right style really matters. First, look at your architectural style: a traditional home might pair nicely with a six-panel wood or inset-glass door, while a more modern home could shine with a flush door with vertical glass sidelight or a dark framed steel door.

Consider the finish too, natural wood tones bring warmth, whereas painted navy, charcoal or forest green add crisp contrast. Hardware matters: matte black gives a modern edge, while aged brass or oil-rubbed bronze feels more classic. Don’t forget lighting and proportion, your door width and sidelight sizes should match the scale of the façade so it doesn’t look “too small” or “over-grand.”

Will suggest that you "lean into" the whole midcentury modern vibe - outside and inside.