Could not post pics in the post, here's some! Please excuse the mess in the front in the summer pic, ripping out tree stumps! First pic is today, brick porch is present now. Bad lighting though lol

And the shingle colors, I know online is terrible to go by but in case it helps haha

Going between weathered wood and Heather blend. Sometimes I worry weathered wood is too close to the roof we have now, too close to the current paint color, and too gray. I like Heather blend but I'm nervous to go with more of a "color" and the pics I see online of real roofs in that color vary SO much, sometimes they look gray sometimes they look deep brown!

Another vote for ”weathered Wood”.. good luck.

Weathered Wood for me, too. I’d stay away from anything that leans rusty/red-ish, such as the Heather Blend appears in your example.

Another vote for Weathered Wood.

Likewise

WW. been on my roof for decades.