An exact gold match across faucet and light brands is harder than most listings make it seem, so I would compare undertone first and brand name second. Some golds lean yellow, some lean champagne, and some sit closer to bronze even when the marketing names sound similar.

If you can, compare the Pfister finish against real finish chips or returnable samples in the room where the light will live, especially under nighttime vanity lighting. From a manufacturing perspective, the cleaner result usually comes from staying within the same warmth family rather than chasing a supposedly perfect match from a product photo.

If you cannot get a convincing near-match, a deliberate contrast can look more intentional than a gold that is close but clearly off.

Take your faucet, or a handle, to a good local lighting showroom and ask for help finding light fixtures with a similar finish. The lighting showrooms I have used, will also let you borrow a light fixture floor sample to see the finish in your own space or they might have sample color chips you can borrow.

Then make sure you buy the product from them, so we don't lose all the brick and mortar stores! If you find a better price online, make sure you give the showroom a chance to price match. Many will, but I am willing to pay a bit more for having used their showroom, samples and product knowledge ... and keeping a local business open.