Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_517892875

I love Mutabilis but can my zone support it?

last month

I grew Mutabilis in zone 7a without luck but once my Husband accidentally sprayed something on it which led to its demise and the other time it just didn't flourish. I love this rose but live in 6b now. Is this a fool's errand to even attempt it?

Comments (8)

  • last month

    Mine did not survive one colder than normal winter in USDA Zone 8a.

    Double Delight thanked Paul Barden
  • last month

    Location is much more important than zone. Also, what are your expectations?

    So, where in the world are you?

    Will you be happy with a 2 ft rose that produces a half dozen flowers a year?

  • last month

    Nature wins.

  • last month

    Thank you all for your responses. It sounds like as much as I love the rose, it is too risky for my situation...no protected area, really. I am in Northern RI and we have numerous pine trees in our yard which limits the options. I will look at the hybrid musk and also saw Fuego de Amore at ARE. Anyone have any experience with that as well? TIA.

  • last month

    Esch-Sur-Sure looks like a lovely replacement but I don't think that it available in the US??

  • last month

    I grew it for a while. The one in the ground lasted a couple of years. The one in a pot I just got tired of. The thing about Mutabilis is that it doesn't have a big flush, but just constantly puts out a flower or two.



  • last month

    Hybrid Musks can usually take some shade if your pine trees are throwing it, so might be a good class to explore. They are more problematic for me because they can struggle in my intense summer heat.


    EsS is a fairly recent Lens rose, so no, it probably hasn’t made it across the pond yet. I’ve just remembered the older Lens rose ’Plaisanterie’ (Trier x Mutablis) which I think is available in the US. Softer colour blend but at least you get half the rose you want! The other parent must give it the better hardiness rating:


    https://www.lens-roses.com/en_US/shop/plaisanterie-14146


    Double Delight thanked NollieSpainZ9