Software
Houzz Logo Print
kim_brown954

Give and take for best layout

last month

Hello, I feel like im missing something in this floor. My vision is a traditional style home with an closed concept layout. The bathroom on left, near the living room, I want to access the full bath from livingroom and Gallery however I do feel like too much room is wasted on that side (making the living room smaller). But im looking for improvement.

Comments (10)

  • PRO
    last month
    last modified: last month

    Post the second floor and exterior elevations and site plan.

  • last month

    Seems like a lot of hallway space for the size of the first floor ...



  • PRO
    last month
    last modified: last month

    I think the circulation space would be better illustrated like this:



  • last month

    Some comments:

    • Just solving for a larger Living/Guest, make the bathroom a standard 5'x7'-?" (78" long is minimum) layout. Trying to understand your access statement I show the bathroom as fully open to the hallway, but that conflicts with having a Powder Room elsewhere in the house.
    • The Living Room has a conflict with the French doors. If you lay out furniture based on the fireplace you have no circulation to outdoors. Such is the problem with perfect symmetry focused at the centerline. Place a door(s) in line with the Foyer view, or inside the Breakfast Room.
    • The Mudroom should have a window, even if a transom, otherwise it's a long dark hall.
    • Some of the doorway openings should be addressed. A "closed concept" layout does not mean that you have to have small doorway sizes to each room. Just a short return, enough for the casing size, will visually make each room feel like separate rooms. What is more important in detailing is how these openings align, what you see through these openings, and how those openings restrict/control circulation or visual access.






  • PRO
    last month
    last modified: last month

    Yikes! The garage is larger than your living/dining/kitchen spaces.

    Design for kitchen/dining room to be one space. Close of the door from the entry into the living room (?). Too many closets with doors (you lose feet with the swings). Do built ins.



  • PRO
    last month

    Why the access from the main house on the left . That space feels odd as a bedroom and too small really. The pantry I gree needs to be a pass through to work.a butlers pantry is a space to move from kitchen to DR anything else is just storage. The access from bedroom to closet on the right is poor design .The FS tub is not good there since it does not have space around it at all , . The closet then the bathroom would make more sense. Are there bedrooms upstairs ? Waht is the gallery for since it has few walls ?IMO if a bedroom suite on the left side is a must then IMO no LR just a FR and make the left side a s 2nd master

  • last month

    You're right that the bathroom placement is eating into the living room. Have you considered accessing the full bath from the gallery hallway instead of the living room? That would let you shrink the bath footprint on the living room side and give you back valuable wall space for furniture. A pocket door on the bath could also save the swing space. The closed-concept traditional feel would actually benefit from keeping the living room walls uninterrupted — it makes the room feel larger and more formal.

  • last month

    " A pocket door on the bath could also save the swing space "


    Worst idea, nothing good happens with a pocket door on a bathroom, especially one in close proximity to the family room.

  • PRO
    last month

    Any door's "swing space" will be within the space required to get people and/or equipment through the doorway; it does not save anything.